Category Archives: Issue preclusion

E.D.Cal.: Successor habeas petition can’t be based on withheld information of a 4A violation

A successor habeas can’t be based on allegedly withheld evidence of a Fourth Amendment violation. Sanchez v. Cates, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 226067 (E.D. Cal. Dec. 12, 2024). Defendant can’t show that defense counsel was ineffective for not moving to … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion, Prison and jail searches, Strip search | Comments Off on E.D.Cal.: Successor habeas petition can’t be based on withheld information of a 4A violation

NY3: “Common sense” that a drug dealer might have evidence on his cell phone isn’t PC

Just because defendant was a suspected drug dealer, there wasn’t probable cause for searching his cell phone. “While [officer] Bruno recounted that there was a quantity of drugs found in the motel room, along with the two phones, he did … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Informant hearsay, Issue preclusion, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on NY3: “Common sense” that a drug dealer might have evidence on his cell phone isn’t PC

ND: Calling 911 about OD’g child in your house is exigency for entry

Calling 911 that the child you’re caring for OD’ed on your fentanyl is consent to their emergency entry. State v. Gothberg, 2024 ND 217, 2024 N.D. LEXIS 221 (Dec. 5, 2024). 2255 petitioner pled guilty knowing the facts of the … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Emergency / exigency, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion | Comments Off on ND: Calling 911 about OD’g child in your house is exigency for entry

IL: Smell of raw cannabis from car in a recreational state is still PC

“In sum, we hold that the odor of raw cannabis coming from a vehicle being operated on an Illinois highway, alone, is sufficient to provide police officers, who are trained and experienced in distinguishing between burnt and raw cannabis, with … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Issue preclusion, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on IL: Smell of raw cannabis from car in a recreational state is still PC

S.D.W.Va.: Issuance of a criminal citation is not a seizure

Issuance of a hunting violation citation is not a seizure. Even if it was, there was probable cause. Defendant wildlife officer’s seizure of antlers from a taxidermist can proceed. Craft v. Gills, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 219453 (S.D. W.Va. Dec. … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Issue preclusion, Reasonable suspicion, Seizure | Comments Off on S.D.W.Va.: Issuance of a criminal citation is not a seizure

C.D.Cal.: Requiring a building demolition permit doesn’t state a 4A claim

Requiring plaintiff to get a demolition permit of a building fails to state a claim because “Plaintiffs’ legal theory that the … actions result in a violation of their fourth amendments rights is unclear and conclusory.” Macy v. San Bernardino … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Issue preclusion, Probable cause, Seizure | Comments Off on C.D.Cal.: Requiring a building demolition permit doesn’t state a 4A claim

CA11: No prejudice for failing to file motion to suppress drug def was acquitted of

2254 petitioner can’t show prejudice from defense counsel’s failure to file a motion to suppress cocaine when he was acquitted of that charge. Zayas-Acosta v. Sec’y, Dep’t of Corr., 2024 U.S. App. LEXIS 30236 (11th Cir. Nov. 27, 2024). Challenge … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of pleading, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion | Comments Off on CA11: No prejudice for failing to file motion to suppress drug def was acquitted of

D.Nev.: In a § 242 prosecution, defense expert can’t testify to PC

In a § 242 prosecution for violating civil rights, the defense proposed expert is barred from opinion on whether probable cause existed for the arrest. “Whether a given set of facts constitutes probable cause to arrest or charge for a … Continue reading →

Posted in Admissibility of evidence, Issue preclusion, Pretext, Probable cause | Comments Off on D.Nev.: In a § 242 prosecution, defense expert can’t testify to PC

D.Mass.: Gun suppressed in FIPF case still not excludable in violation of supervised release

Defendant was an alleged felon in possession and was charged with a new federal crime and a violation of his supervised release. He was sentenced to 22 months on the violation. The gun was suppressed in the new gun case … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Exclusionary rule, Issue preclusion, Probation / Parole search, Voluntariness | Comments Off on D.Mass.: Gun suppressed in FIPF case still not excludable in violation of supervised release

Dual sovereignty: W.D.Mich: The defense can’t relitigate grant of state court suppression of the same evidence in federal court (but the federal government can)

2255 petitioner originally had a motion to suppress granted in state court, and the federal government indicted him. Defense counsel wasn’t ineffective for failing to argue collateral estoppel, and issue foreclosed under circuit precedent. Miller v. United States, 2024 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion | Comments Off on Dual sovereignty: W.D.Mich: The defense can’t relitigate grant of state court suppression of the same evidence in federal court (but the federal government can)

CA3: Handcuffed detainee can still be frisked with RS

Just because a detainee is handcuffed, the potential threat hasn’t abated, and a frisk can occur. United States v. Jackson, 2024 U.S. App. LEXIS 28229 (3d Cir. Nov. 6, 2024). The affidavit for the warrant for defendant’s home was based … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Issue preclusion, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA3: Handcuffed detainee can still be frisked with RS

S.D.Fla.: Raid on a business alleged to be retaliation for political speech survives motion to dismiss

A warrantless raid on a business alleged to have a First Amendment political retaliatory motive survives a motion to dismiss. “Taking the Complaint’s allegations as true, we think that Hernandez’s organizing a raid of Bellas to suppress political speech—‘actions reminiscent … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion, Reasonable suspicion, Retaliation | Comments Off on S.D.Fla.: Raid on a business alleged to be retaliation for political speech survives motion to dismiss

N.D.Cal.: Second frisk at scene of SW was still with RS

Defendant was frisked a second time during execution of a search warrant, and a gun was found. The second frisker didn’t know about the first. There was still reasonable suspicion for a frisk that he was armed and dangerous. United … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion, Pretext, Protective sweep, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Second frisk at scene of SW was still with RS

E.D.Va.: Reporting requirements of Corporate Transparency Act don’t violate 4A under California Bankers

Plaintiffs challenge the Corporate Transparency Act on several grounds. As to their claim the reporting requirement violates the Fourth Amendment, there is no likelihood of success on the merits under California Bankers decided 50 years ago. Community Ass’ns Inst. v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonable suspicion, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on E.D.Va.: Reporting requirements of Corporate Transparency Act don’t violate 4A under California Bankers

NY: Not IAC to not raise a novel knock-and-announce argument

Defendant’s ineffective assistance of counsel argument that defense counsel was deficient in not raising a novel argument about not following SCOTUS’s Hudson knock-and-announce case fails. No reasonable defense lawyer would have seen the need to raise it, and the merits … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of pleading, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion, Knock and announce, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on NY: Not IAC to not raise a novel knock-and-announce argument

M.D.Ala.: Officers executing arrest warrant at house could do protective sweep

Officers executing an arrest warrant for murder could conduct a protective sweep. United States v. Moss, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 191835 (M.D. Ala. Sep. 9, 2024), adopted, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 190695 (M.D.Ala. Oct. 21, 2024). Children’s services “ordering” plaintiff … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Issue preclusion, Protective sweep | Comments Off on M.D.Ala.: Officers executing arrest warrant at house could do protective sweep

D.Colo.: Failure to produce paperwork promptly justifies an extension of the stop

Defendant’s failure to promptly produce the insurance information and registration on his car justified ordering him out of the car and reasonably extended the stop. United States v. Malone, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 188452 (D. Colo. Oct. 16, 2024).* 2254 … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion, Reasonable suspicion, Reasonableness, Tracking warrant | Comments Off on D.Colo.: Failure to produce paperwork promptly justifies an extension of the stop

CA2: A wrecked vehicle that has to be towed away is mobile for the automobile exception

Defendant wrecked his rental car and it was undriveable. It was still subject to the automobile exception because it would almost certainly be towed away, and that’s mobility. United States v. Jones, 2024 U.S. App. LEXIS 25563 (2d Cir. Oct. … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Excessive force, Issue preclusion, Search incident | Comments Off on CA2: A wrecked vehicle that has to be towed away is mobile for the automobile exception

D.P.R.: Officer’s construction of traffic law was “ardous” and unreasonable under Heien

The officer’s conclusion defendant violated a U-turn statute was unreasonable, and the motion to suppress is granted. “While mistakes of law based on arduous questions of statutory interpretation may justify an officer’s judgment, a poor study of the law cannot … Continue reading →

Posted in Issue preclusion, Private search, Reasonableness | Comments Off on D.P.R.: Officer’s construction of traffic law was “ardous” and unreasonable under Heien

FL5: Weaving justified welfare check stop

Defendant’s obvious weaving justified at least a welfare check stop that was reasonable. State v. Sheldon, 2024 Fla. App. LEXIS 7892 (Fla. 5th DCA Oct. 8, 2024). 2254 petitioner doesn’t show that he didn’t get a full and fair opportunity … Continue reading →

Posted in Community caretaking function, Consent, Issue preclusion, Seizure | Comments Off on FL5: Weaving justified welfare check stop