Author Archives: Hall

TN: Post-conviction petitioner bears burden of showing warrantless search was invalid; here, no witnesses to search called

Defendant on post-conviction did not prove that the motion to suppress an inventory would have been granted (and Tennessee law is favorable to the defense). All he called as witnesses were the lawyers involved and himself, but that does not … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Consent, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on TN: Post-conviction petitioner bears burden of showing warrantless search was invalid; here, no witnesses to search called

LA: Trial counsel not ineffective for not moving to suppress search that was clearly based on exigency

Trial counsel was not ineffective for not pursuing an exigency-based search issue where police entered after hearing cries for help when the grandfather of missing children entered and found blood on the floor. A suppression motion would have lost. State … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Consent, Emergency / exigency, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on LA: Trial counsel not ineffective for not moving to suppress search that was clearly based on exigency

CA5: Suppression of evidence in state court does not per se raise a basis for a claim in federal court on whether the officers violated clearly established rights

Suppression of evidence in state court does not per se raise a basis for a claim in federal court on whether the officers violated clearly established rights, particularly when the suppression hearing transcript wasn’t provided to the federal court. Cleveland … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA5: Suppression of evidence in state court does not per se raise a basis for a claim in federal court on whether the officers violated clearly established rights

OR automobile exception requires vehicle must be mobile when first encountered in connection with a crime

To justify the automobile exception in Oregon, the vehicle must be mobile when first encountered in connection with a crime. If parked, a warrant must be sought. State v. Belander, 274 Ore. App. 167, 2015 Ore. App. LEXIS 1175 (September … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Emergency / exigency, Reasonableness | Comments Off on OR automobile exception requires vehicle must be mobile when first encountered in connection with a crime

W.D.Va.: VA statute that permitted natural gas companies to survey open fields doesn’t violate Fourth Amendment

Virginia statute that permitted natural gas transmission companies to enter open fields for survey purposes did not facially violate the Fourth Amendment or Virginia Constitution. Charlottesville Div. v. Dominion Transmission, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 132554 (W.D.Va. September 30, 2015). 2255 … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Open fields | Comments Off on W.D.Va.: VA statute that permitted natural gas companies to survey open fields doesn’t violate Fourth Amendment

D.Conn.: Police entry into public bar area clearly within Fourth Amendment; customers have no right to have sex in public

The Fourth Amendment claim that police entered the bar area of the plaintiff’s business because of police calls fails because it was open to the public. The selective enforcement claim fails on the facts. There is no First Amendment right … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on D.Conn.: Police entry into public bar area clearly within Fourth Amendment; customers have no right to have sex in public

W.D.Pa.: 1-2 yr old info coupled with current info showed ongoing drug operation at house

Information that was 1-2 years old was included in the affidavit, and there was current information, too. The old information supported showing that defendant’s counterfeiting operation was “protracted and continuous and that it was ongoing just two days to two … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Inventory, Staleness | Comments Off on W.D.Pa.: 1-2 yr old info coupled with current info showed ongoing drug operation at house

The Hill: Privacy hawks see momentum in encryption fight

The Hill: Privacy hawks see momentum in encryption fight by Cory Bennett: Digital rights advocates are looking to capitalize on positive signals from administration.

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on The Hill: Privacy hawks see momentum in encryption fight

CA2: CBP could photocopy a notebook on entry into the U.S. based on info from DEA that was RS

Warrantless copying of an international traveler’s notebook by CBP was with reasonable suspicion via the DEA. Essentially, the collective knowledge doctrine can permit a more extensive border search than would otherwise occur. Defendant was under investigation for stock fraud and … Continue reading →

Posted in Border search | Comments Off on CA2: CBP could photocopy a notebook on entry into the U.S. based on info from DEA that was RS

MA: CSLI seized before state law clarified; remanded

CSLI was seized: one defendant five days worth, another seven days worth. State case law all developed after that happened, so remanded to reconsider the CSLI under those cases. Commonwealth v. Tewolde, 2015 Mass. App. LEXIS 156 (October 1, 2015). … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Cell site location information, Probable cause | Comments Off on MA: CSLI seized before state law clarified; remanded

Cal. Riverside: Refusal of a BAC test was constitutionally protected and couldn’t separately be prosecuted

Mere refusal of a BAC test was constitutionally protected and couldn’t be prosecuted. “Here, police did not attempt to obtain a warrant or to perform a forced blood draw based on another exception to the warrant requirement, such as exigent … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on Cal. Riverside: Refusal of a BAC test was constitutionally protected and couldn’t separately be prosecuted

CA3: A corporate shareholder and executive doesn’t have standing in the corporation’s computer server; no personal connection

“To show he can challenge the search of SPI’s and CDS’s offices and the seizure of the employees’ computers and network server as a shareholder and executive, Nagle must show a personal connection to the place searched or to the … Continue reading →

Posted in Plain view, feel, smell, Probable cause, Standing | Comments Off on CA3: A corporate shareholder and executive doesn’t have standing in the corporation’s computer server; no personal connection

CA1: Consent not tainted by statement officers would search anyway where they had PC for SW

Defendant’s consent was not tainted by the officer’s assertion that his apartment would be searched anyway because there was probable cause for a warrant. Defendant drove himself to the police station for an interview, and he wasn’t in custody for … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Probable cause | Comments Off on CA1: Consent not tainted by statement officers would search anyway where they had PC for SW

LA4: State failed to show justification for search of bookbag not on def when he was arrested

The state failed to prove an exception to justify a search of defendant’s bookbag. It was seized, but it was wasn’t on him when he was arrested. It couldn’t be a search incident or inventory. State v. Berrigan, 2015 La. … Continue reading →

Posted in Search incident | Comments Off on LA4: State failed to show justification for search of bookbag not on def when he was arrested

Washington Examiner: Administrative subpoenas: Relics of the Star Chamber

Washington Examiner: Administrative subpoenas: Relics of the Star Chamber by Mark J. Fitzgibbons: The Drug Enforcement Administration is involved in a lawsuit for targeting medical records using judge-less warrants called “administrative subpoenas.” The quantity of DEA administrative subpoenas issued unilaterally, … Continue reading →

Posted in Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters | Comments Off on Washington Examiner: Administrative subpoenas: Relics of the Star Chamber

Cert. grant: Utah v. Strieff: 4A violated by outstanding warrant found during illegal stop?

Utah v. Strieff — Question Presented: “Should evidence seized incident to a lawful arrest on an outstanding warrant be suppressed because the warrant was discovered during an investigatory stop later found to be unlawful?” Prior post from January: Under the … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule, SCOTUS | Comments Off on Cert. grant: Utah v. Strieff: 4A violated by outstanding warrant found during illegal stop?

Two on Davis good faith exception; one a 20 year old cold case

In a cold case rape and murder that came from retesting defendant’s DNA 20 years after the crime, a search incident that was valid in 1985 was now saved by Davis good faith. State v. Adams, 2015-Ohio-3954, 2015 Ohio LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Search incident | Comments Off on Two on Davis good faith exception; one a 20 year old cold case

Cal.1st: Probation condition to reveal all passwords to search phones and social media was overbroad

A juvenile’s probation conditions required that he and his family turn over all passwords to cell phones and social media sites. The condition is overbroad considering what probation seeks to accomplish (seeing if he has stolen iPhones), and it implicates … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on Cal.1st: Probation condition to reveal all passwords to search phones and social media was overbroad

D.N.J.: Plain view supported seizure of records outside scope of search warrant

In a Medicaid fraud document search warrant, some documents found were outside of the scope of the warrant, but they satisfied the plain view doctrine that their potential incriminating nature was immediately apparent and they were found in the course … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Plain view, feel, smell, Scope of search, Standing | Comments Off on D.N.J.: Plain view supported seizure of records outside scope of search warrant

W.D.Ark.: Warrantless DNA sample 16 days after arrest was unreasonable

Warrantless taking a DNA sample from an arrestee under state law but 16 days after his arrest violated the Fourth Amendment. If it was at the time of booking, it would have been reasonable. Nominal damages awarded. Lewis v. Brazell, … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Drug or alcohol testing, Immigration checkpoints | Comments Off on W.D.Ark.: Warrantless DNA sample 16 days after arrest was unreasonable