Category Archives: Ineffective assistance

CA9: Failure to deliver SW at scene of search violated Rule 41, but no suppression here

Failure to deliver the whole search warrant to defendant violated Rule 41(f)(1)(C), but it wasn’t deliberate so no suppression. United States v. Manaku, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS 16337 (9th Cir. June 14, 2022). 2254 petitioner’s ineffective assistance of counsel for … Continue reading →

Posted in Custody, Ineffective assistance, Seizure, Warrant papers | Comments Off on CA9: Failure to deliver SW at scene of search violated Rule 41, but no suppression here

CA7: Inevitable impoundment of car mooted claim dog jumped in car

Defendant’s car was inevitably going to be searched after impoundment, so the question of the drug dog jumping into the car doesn’t have to be decided. United States v. Overton, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS 16158 (7th Cir. June 13, 2022). … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA7: Inevitable impoundment of car mooted claim dog jumped in car

TN follows Kimmelman for 4A IAC claims

Tennessee follows Kimmelman: “Upon our review of the record and applicable law, we conclude that to establish prejudice with this type of claim, the petitioner must prove that ‘his Fourth Amendment claim is meritorious and that there is a reasonable … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Scope of search | Comments Off on TN follows Kimmelman for 4A IAC claims

NY Bronx: REP in one’s apartment building mailbox

Defendant had a reasonable expectation of privacy in his mailbox in an apartment building from unreasonable searches. A search warrant was sought through the Bronx DA, but they were short staffed and recommended the officers get landlord consent. That was … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Burden of pleading, Good faith exception, Ineffective assistance, Mail and packages, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on NY Bronx: REP in one’s apartment building mailbox

OH8: Disavowing reliance on Franks at suppression hearing is waiver

Defendant’s disavowing the search issue in his motion to suppress involved Franks is waiver for appeal. The state sought clarification it wasn’t an issue and got it. State v. Claytor, 2022-Ohio-1938, 2022 Ohio App. LEXIS 1812 (8th Dist. June 9, … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion, Waiver | Comments Off on OH8: Disavowing reliance on Franks at suppression hearing is waiver

ID: Not unreasonable to check wants and warrants on passenger during a traffic stop

“This appeal arises out of a traffic stop where a single officer, without having reasonable suspicion that a crime involving the passenger was afoot, checked the passenger for outstanding warrants. The officer used her patrol vehicle’s computer and received a … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Ineffective assistance, Inventory, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on ID: Not unreasonable to check wants and warrants on passenger during a traffic stop

RI: Commercial fishing is a “closely regulated industry” and a vessel’s monitoring system could be examined

Commercial fishing is a closely regulated industry. “Appellant also had a sea scallop permit, requiring the vessel to have a vessel monitoring system (VMS), which transmits global positioning system (GPS) coordinates every half hour to the National Marine Fisheries Service.” … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Dog sniff, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion, Reasonableness | Comments Off on RI: Commercial fishing is a “closely regulated industry” and a vessel’s monitoring system could be examined

D.Minn.: Tracking warrant issued without PC, but GFE still applied

There was no probable cause for the tracking warrant for defendant. But, it was not so lacking in probable cause that the good faith exception does not apply. United States v. Escudero, 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 89120 (D.Minn. May 18, … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Good faith exception, GPS / Tracking Data, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Tracking warrant issued without PC, but GFE still applied

UT: IAC shown for not challenging dog alert

The initial dog alert here did not provide probable cause for search of defendant’s vehicle. Thus, defense counsel was ineffective for not pursuing a Fourth Amendment challenge. “In summary, based on the record before us, a motion to suppress the … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of pleading, Dog sniff, Ineffective assistance, Motion to suppress, Standing | Comments Off on UT: IAC shown for not challenging dog alert

N.D.Ga.: Pro forma objection to R&R doesn’t articulate argument, so it’s waived

Defendant didn’t fairly articulate his objections to the R&R, so his objection is waived. United States v. Hill, 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 83707 (N.D.Ga. May 9, 2022). There was probable cause for this search authorization, and the good faith exception … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule, Franks doctrine, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion, Military searches, Probation / Parole search, Reasonable suspicion, Waiver | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Pro forma objection to R&R doesn’t articulate argument, so it’s waived

CA11: Def’s innocent explanation for his behavior still left PC

Defendant’s innocent explanation for his behavior still left probable cause. United States v. Clark, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS 11504 (11th Cir. Apr. 28, 2022). Defendant was arrested two weeks after a string of robberies, and his cell phone was taken … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Ineffective assistance, Probable cause, Reasonableness | Comments Off on CA11: Def’s innocent explanation for his behavior still left PC

NY Kings Co.: “There is no Fourth Amendment principle that forbids a police officer from being pleased at having found an illegal weapon”

“Set against the obvious reality that a well-documented full and proper inventory was carried out here, I do not find the mere fact that after spotting the gun at the outset, Officer Duran exclaimed, ‘that was easy,’ and ‘Now it’s … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Inventory | Comments Off on NY Kings Co.: “There is no Fourth Amendment principle that forbids a police officer from being pleased at having found an illegal weapon”

D.Mont.: Acting strange walking down the street is not RS

“While Vasquez was indeed acting strangely, for the stop to be valid, his conduct must be indicative of criminal behavior. The Court here simply cannot bridge the connection between the conduct here that is suspicious or odd in the lay … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion, Waiver | Comments Off on D.Mont.: Acting strange walking down the street is not RS

E.D.N.C.: Violation of state SW statutes and rules not a 4A violation

Violation of state statutes or rules in issuing search warrants is not a Fourth Amendment issue. And, nexus was shown: “So interpreting the affidavit, and based on the totality of the circumstances including the role cell phones generally play in … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonableness | Comments Off on E.D.N.C.: Violation of state SW statutes and rules not a 4A violation

E.D.Ark.: City’s court order made clean up and removal of ptf’s property reasonable

Plaintiff was told for years to clean up his property from unsightly construction materials and equipment. After many failed efforts to get him to do so, the city obtained a court order to remove the property. It removed nine trailerloads … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Excessive force, Ineffective assistance, Reasonableness, Seizure | Comments Off on E.D.Ark.: City’s court order made clean up and removal of ptf’s property reasonable

CA10: Def’s actions were completely consistent with innocence and did not add up to RS

The officer did not have reasonable suspicion for defendant’s stop or its continuation. Defendant’s actions were consistent with somebody who had nothing to hide, and the district court’s findings got no presumption of correctness. Denial of the suppression motion reversed. … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion, Voluntariness | Comments Off on CA10: Def’s actions were completely consistent with innocence and did not add up to RS

CA7: Younger and immunity bar ptf’s § 1983 claim against search

Plaintiff’s claims that the parties conspired to falsify evidence of this search against him, aside from being fantastical, was barred by Younger and qualified or absolute immunity for all the parties. Shaw v. Cnty. of Milwaukee, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA7: Younger and immunity bar ptf’s § 1983 claim against search

E.D.N.Y.: Visual surveillance of a car in a parking lot is not a search; no REP in the license plate

Visual surveillance of plaintiff’s car in a parking lot is not a search. “Mr. Porter alleges that Investigator Tucci committed an unreasonable search by conducting surveillance of his vehicle in a parking lot and by looking up his plate and … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Probable cause, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on E.D.N.Y.: Visual surveillance of a car in a parking lot is not a search; no REP in the license plate

TX: Affidavit incorporated in SW had specific description and saves SW from overbreadth argument

“The issue before us is whether the particularity requirement of the Fourth Amendment is satisfied if a warrant describes the place to be searched as a fraternity house as a whole without specifying a suspect’s actual room in the house, … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion, Particularity, Warrant papers | Comments Off on TX: Affidavit incorporated in SW had specific description and saves SW from overbreadth argument

D.Ariz.: To overcome Stone bar, pet’r has to proffer something about being denied “full and fair opportunity” to litigate 4A claim

To overcome Stone in a 2254, the petitioner has to proffer that he was denied a full and fair opportunity to litigate his Fourth Amendment claim. Failure to do so is fatal to claim. Bartels v. Arizona, 2022 U.S. Dist. … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Ineffective assistance, Issue preclusion | Comments Off on D.Ariz.: To overcome Stone bar, pet’r has to proffer something about being denied “full and fair opportunity” to litigate 4A claim