Author Archives: Hall

S.D.Ga.: Search incident of car valid where def on ground being searched when officers looked for gun

Defendant was wanted for a recent shooting with a shotgun, and the USM fugitive squad was in on the manhunt. When they found him, they stopped the car and had him on the ground next to the car with the … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory, Search incident | Comments Off on S.D.Ga.: Search incident of car valid where def on ground being searched when officers looked for gun

ID: Def’s purse was in car at time of dog alert, so it was subject to search under automobile exception

Defendant’s purse was in her vehicle when a dog alerted on it. By the time the police were going to search her car, the purse was in her hands. The purse could be searched under the automobile exception because it … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception | Comments Off on ID: Def’s purse was in car at time of dog alert, so it was subject to search under automobile exception

M.D.Ga.: DNA taken under state law that was potentially purgable still could be used as evidence in a federal prosecution

Defendant was charged as a first offender under Georgia law, and, if he completed probation successfully, his DNA sample would have been purged from the system. Here, the DNA was matched to another crime when he was still on probation. … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, DNA | Comments Off on M.D.Ga.: DNA taken under state law that was potentially purgable still could be used as evidence in a federal prosecution

N.D.Ill.: There is no REP in the information provided by a “smart meter” to the power grid

Plaintiff organization sued the City over its “smart meters” that were installed through a Dept. of Energy grant to modernize the power grid. The meters provide realtime information about power usage in a home. The court denies a Third Amended … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on N.D.Ill.: There is no REP in the information provided by a “smart meter” to the power grid

CA1: Def consented to entry to serve an order of protection and sawed off shotgun hanging on wall was in plain view

Officers came to defendant’s house to serve a domestic abuse order of protection. He motioned for them to enter. They asked about guns, and defendant motioned to the wall where two guns were on display, one of which was a … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on CA1: Def consented to entry to serve an order of protection and sawed off shotgun hanging on wall was in plain view

D.Md.: McNeely doesn’t require a warrant for a breath test

Under the federal implied consent law, defendant consented to a BAC breath test. McNeely doesn’t require a warrant before a breath test. “Although a driver has a constitutional right not to be tested without a warrant or a valid warrant … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on D.Md.: McNeely doesn’t require a warrant for a breath test

Legal Intelligencer: The USA Freedom Act and Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence

Legal Intelligencer: The USA Freedom Act and Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence by Leonard Deutchman:

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on Legal Intelligencer: The USA Freedom Act and Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence

D.S.D.: Def’s REP in a mailed letter ended when it was opened on receipt

Defendant’s expectation of privacy in letter he mailed ended when it was received and opened. The USMJ did not abuse his discretion in not reopening the suppression hearing to ask further questions about photographs. The suppression hearing was three days … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonableness | Comments Off on D.S.D.: Def’s REP in a mailed letter ended when it was opened on receipt

W.D.Mo.: Reaching in def’s door to grab him and pull him out to arrest was based on PC and exigency of threat of violence

Officers received a call about defendant having a sawed off shotgun and pointing it at somebody. They had enough information to be probable cause. They went to defendant’s house to arrest, and defendant came to the door but wouldn’t come … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on W.D.Mo.: Reaching in def’s door to grab him and pull him out to arrest was based on PC and exigency of threat of violence

AZ: Even def lying about his identity on arrest didn’t justify search incident of cell phone

When defendant was arrested, his cell phone was seized and searched, and it could not be justified as a search incident even though defendant initially lied about his name. State v. Ontiveros-Loya, 2015 Ariz. App. LEXIS 111 (June 30, 2015). … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Consent, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on AZ: Even def lying about his identity on arrest didn’t justify search incident of cell phone

HuffPo: Will the Coming ‘Internet of Things’ Mean the Death of Privacy?

HuffPo: Will the Coming ‘Internet of Things’ Mean the Death of Privacy? by Vivek Wadhwa:

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on HuffPo: Will the Coming ‘Internet of Things’ Mean the Death of Privacy?

W.D.Va.: Def made a colorable claim that his indictment was based on an illegal search, so he gets early discovery of GJ materials

Defendant made a colorable claim that his indictment was based on an illegal search. Therefore, he is entitled to early discovery of the grand jury transcripts in an effort to prove that despite Calandra. United States v. Patiutka, 2015 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on W.D.Va.: Def made a colorable claim that his indictment was based on an illegal search, so he gets early discovery of GJ materials

CA3: Def was stopped, and without reasonable suspicion, as officers advanced on him; the fact he took two steps back was still submission

There was no reasonable suspicion for defendant’s stop. The fact he backed up a couple of steps as officers advanced on him was not flight. “In sum, we hold that Lowe submitted to the officers’ authority by staying put in … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CA3: Def was stopped, and without reasonable suspicion, as officers advanced on him; the fact he took two steps back was still submission

CA7: Backpack search for a weapon wasn’t justified; govt’s alternative theory was waived below

The search of defendant’s backpack wasn’t justified under any legal theory because there was neither probable cause nor reasonable suspicion for the detention. He and his companion were handcuffed behind their backs, and officer safety was no longer an issue. … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on CA7: Backpack search for a weapon wasn’t justified; govt’s alternative theory was waived below

NYTimes Editorial: The Activist Roberts Court, 10 Years In

NYTimes Editorial: The Activist Roberts Court, 10 Years In: What is the most useful way to understand the direction of the Supreme Court 10 years into the tenure of Chief Justice John Roberts Jr.? After a series of high-profile end-of-term … Continue reading →

Posted in SCOTUS | Comments Off on NYTimes Editorial: The Activist Roberts Court, 10 Years In

MS: Rental inspection warrant ordinance unconstitutional for no PC requirement

Madison’s rental inspection warrant system violates the Fourth Amendment because the ordinance does not require that the warrant issue on probable cause of a potential violation. Crook v. City of Madison, 2015 Miss. LEXIS 352 (July 2, 2015):

Posted in Administrative search | Comments Off on MS: Rental inspection warrant ordinance unconstitutional for no PC requirement

S.D.W.Va.: Lost warrant could be proved by unexecuted copies from the officer’s file

The affidavit and search warrant were lost, but they could be recreated by unexecuted copies from the officer’s file and the associated materials used with them, such as the criminal complaint which used the same information. United States v. Richardson, … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant requirement | Comments Off on S.D.W.Va.: Lost warrant could be proved by unexecuted copies from the officer’s file

E.D.N.Y.: Bootstrapping a minor offense into a search incident is generally unreasonable, but govt met its burden here

Defendant was seen tossing a green beer bottle and officers attempted to step in front of him to stop him to inquire into the littering. Instead of talking to them, he pushed past them, and that made them concerned he … Continue reading →

Posted in Search incident | Comments Off on E.D.N.Y.: Bootstrapping a minor offense into a search incident is generally unreasonable, but govt met its burden here

OH10: Asking for DL of driver of parked car was a stop of everybody in the car

Defendant was in a parked car with others when the police pulled up. It became a stop of everybody in the car under Brendlin when the officer asked for ID, and there was no reasonable suspicion of any crime whatsoever. … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, Probation / Parole search, Reasonable suspicion, Seizure | Comments Off on OH10: Asking for DL of driver of parked car was a stop of everybody in the car

E.D.Pa.: Def gets return of property seized 7½ years ago

Defendant is entitled to return of property originally seized 7½ years ago to prosecute him that is not contraband and no longer needed. United States v. Green, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 85174 (E.D.Pa. June 30, 2015). A state law enforcement … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Reasonable suspicion, Rule 41(g) / Return of property | Comments Off on E.D.Pa.: Def gets return of property seized 7½ years ago