Author Archives: Hall

NJ: There is a rebuttable presumption that a dropped 9-1-1 call is an emergency, and the presumption applied here on the objective facts

Here, the objective facts supported the conclusion that there was an emergency from a dropped 9-1-1 call. There is a rebuttable presumption that a dropped 9-1-1 call is an emergency, and the presumption applied here. State v. Reece, 2015 N.J. … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on NJ: There is a rebuttable presumption that a dropped 9-1-1 call is an emergency, and the presumption applied here on the objective facts

D.S.D.: Standing here was established by other witnesses without def even testifying; USMJ erred in denying full hearing

The USMJ found no standing, but defendant did not need to testify to establish standing. Here, there was evidence in the record that others said the duffle bag was defendant’s and his papers were found inside it. That should be … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Standing | Comments Off on D.S.D.: Standing here was established by other witnesses without def even testifying; USMJ erred in denying full hearing

CA5: Air fresheners and odd responses to basic questions were enough for reasonable suspicion

Air fresheners and odd responses to basic questions were reasonable suspicion, and the court declines to get into analysis of the other factors. The initial stop was for going 2 mph over the limit. United States v. Peña-Gonzalez, 2015 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA5: Air fresheners and odd responses to basic questions were enough for reasonable suspicion

Wisconsin adopts Heien on reasonable mistakes of law

Wisconsin adopts Heien on reasonable mistakes of law, overruling all past cases. Reasonable suspicion is all that’s needed for a traffic stop, not probable cause. State v. Houghton, 2015 WI 79, 2015 Wisc. LEXIS 484 (July 14, 2015). Fleeing into … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Qualified immunity, Reasonableness | Comments Off on Wisconsin adopts Heien on reasonable mistakes of law

The Atlantic: A Year After Eric Garner’s Death, Has Anything Changed?

The Atlantic: A Year After Eric Garner’s Death, Has Anything Changed? by David Graham: For the past 12 months, America has actually paid attention to police violence—but what has it learned?

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on The Atlantic: A Year After Eric Garner’s Death, Has Anything Changed?

FL2: Gesture to enter was consent

Defendant lost his phone at the scene of a burglary. Police came to his house to talk to him, and the evidence supports the conclusion that his sister invited them in by her gestures, and she had apparent authority. Thompson … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on FL2: Gesture to enter was consent

CA10: Stop for riding a bicycle without light unreasonably extended; search of backpack suppressed

Defendant was stopped for riding an unlighted bicycle across the street at night in the middle of the block. Once stopped, the officer questioned him about his backpack and secured an admission he was armed. The questioning was unreasonable and … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA10: Stop for riding a bicycle without light unreasonably extended; search of backpack suppressed

PA: DUI accident provided PC for automobile exception search

In a DUI accident, the officer had probable cause to search defendant’s vehicle for evidence of the impairment under the automobile exception. Commonwealth v. Best, 2015 PA Super 151, 2015 Pa. Super. LEXIS 409 (July 16, 2015).* The officer’s participation … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Automobile exception, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on PA: DUI accident provided PC for automobile exception search

CO: DNA taken in violation of statute not suppressed

Taking DNA from this defendant on a misdemeanor arrest was not a Fourth Amendment violation under King. It did violate state law, but the court doesn’t suppress. It matched DNA in a rape case and led to him being charged. … Continue reading →

Posted in DNA, Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on CO: DNA taken in violation of statute not suppressed

WaPo: Judge: No-fly list procedures were — and still might be — unconstitutional

WaPo: Judge: No-fly list procedures were — and still might be — unconstitutional by Matt Zapotosky: A federal judge on Thursday ruled that the way the United States implemented its no-fly list was unconstitutional years ago when it was used … Continue reading →

Posted in Airport searches | Comments Off on WaPo: Judge: No-fly list procedures were — and still might be — unconstitutional

CA9: Not questioning search likely sound strategy where defense at trial was disassociation from the drugs and the place they were found

Defendant’s IAC claim on his search isn’t proper for direct appeal, and it should proceed in a 2255. “However, counsel may have had strategic reasons not to file a suppression motion to avoid having Birrueta testify. For example, testifying at … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Standing | Comments Off on CA9: Not questioning search likely sound strategy where defense at trial was disassociation from the drugs and the place they were found

D.Minn.: Violation of state law in admin subpoena for ISP information of no consequence in federal prosecution

Defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his third party information with his internet service provider, so the validity of the administrative subpoena isn’t an issue under circuit precedent. The fact that state law was used by state investigators … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Violation of state law in admin subpoena for ISP information of no consequence in federal prosecution

S.D.Tex.: Officer’s failure to note everything in car didn’t undermine claim of inventory nor show pretext for search

The court credits the officer’s testimony about the purpose of the search of defendant’s car to be inventory. He made notes of the items found but not all made it into official reports. The court credits this was an innocent … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on S.D.Tex.: Officer’s failure to note everything in car didn’t undermine claim of inventory nor show pretext for search

MI: Plaintiffs failed to show that a “smart meter” violated their privacy or Fourth Amendment rights

Plaintiffs alleged but failed to show, inter alia, that a “smart meter” violated their privacy or Fourth Amendment rights. Detroit Edison Co. v. Stenman, 2015 Mich. App. LEXIS 1384 (July 14, 2015):

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on MI: Plaintiffs failed to show that a “smart meter” violated their privacy or Fourth Amendment rights

GA: Mistake in address not prejudicial where right place was searched; police used address listed with Assessor

The search warrant had a mistaken address. It authorized the search of the plaintiff’s building but listed it as 11195 when it was actually 11193. The wrong building was not searched. Plaintiff did not state a claim for trespass by … Continue reading →

Posted in Particularity | Comments Off on GA: Mistake in address not prejudicial where right place was searched; police used address listed with Assessor

WaPo: Radley Balko’s ‘The Watch’ Blog: This week in police shootings

WaPo: Radley Balko’s ‘The Watch’ Blog: This week in police shootings: There were two more disturbing stories about police officers killing people this week, although both of the actual incidents occurred two years ago.

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on WaPo: Radley Balko’s ‘The Watch’ Blog: This week in police shootings

AK: Slightly changing search incident argument on appeal and including Gant was changing the issue

Defendant raised a search incident claim about his arrest: “(1) the toiletry bag was not “immediately associated” with his person, and because (2) the search of the bag was not sufficiently contemporaneous with his arrest.” On appeal, however, he raised … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on AK: Slightly changing search incident argument on appeal and including Gant was changing the issue

OR Const. doesn’t permit weapons inquiry to jaywalker without RS

Oregon Constitution does not permit an officer to inquire of a jaywalking suspect whether he is armed without some reasonable suspicion. State v. Jimenez, 357 Ore. 417, 2015 Ore. LEXIS 441 (July 9, 2015):

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, State constitution | Comments Off on OR Const. doesn’t permit weapons inquiry to jaywalker without RS

TN: CI’s reliability mooted by trash pull

Whether the CI was reliable was essentially moot based on a trash pull that showed all kinds of marijuana cuttings. State v. Altman, 2015 Tenn. Crim. App. LEXIS 556 (July 13, 2015).* [Usually, the courts say that the CI was … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation, Independent source, Inevitable discovery, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on TN: CI’s reliability mooted by trash pull

D.Minn.: Hypodermic needle felt in patdown could be seized as potential weapon

A patdown that felt a hypodermic needle was valid because a needle could be used as a weapon. United States v. Rush, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 90250 (D.Minn. July 13, 2015). Defendant was stopped for suspicion of DUI on federal … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Hypodermic needle felt in patdown could be seized as potential weapon