Category Archives: Independent source

D.Minn.: 1A retaliatory SW claim defeated by actual PC for the warrant as an independent source

Plaintiff’s claim that a search warrant for his house was retaliatory for First Amendment activities doesn’t overcome the fact there was independent probable cause for the warrant. Therefore, the Fourth Amendment claim fails. Fredin v. Clysdale, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS … Continue reading

Posted in Independent source, Search incident | Comments Off on D.Minn.: 1A retaliatory SW claim defeated by actual PC for the warrant as an independent source

MN: Independent source doctrine obviated need to decide private search

Defendant appeals his sexual assault conviction. His victim came to his house to bum a cigarette, and she stayed to drink with defendant and his girlfriend. She fell asleep and awoke in the morning, fully clothed, with defendant’s girlfriend yelling … Continue reading

Posted in Independent source | Comments Off on MN: Independent source doctrine obviated need to decide private search

CA6: Dist.Ct.’s findings don’t support inevitable discovery, so court applies independent source instead

The district court’s analysis doesn’t support application of the inevitable discovery exception because the court didn’t make sufficient findings on the second part of the test. Instead, the record fully supports the independent source doctrine instead. United States v. Chapman-Sexton, … Continue reading

Posted in Independent source, Inevitable discovery, Standards of review | Comments Off on CA6: Dist.Ct.’s findings don’t support inevitable discovery, so court applies independent source instead

FL2: State failed to show search of house was within limited scope of def’s consent

Police received a shots fired call involving a duplex. When defendant opened his door, they could see a shell casing and smelled gunpowder from a fired gun. A protective sweep occurred finding nothing. The exigency was over. Defendant gave a … Continue reading

Posted in Consent, Independent source, Scope of search | Comments Off on FL2: State failed to show search of house was within limited scope of def’s consent

M.D.Fla.: Def was given guest standing to challenge a knock-and-talk that both sides agree was unreasonable

The knock-and-talk turned into a full scale raid, and the parties agree it was unreasonable. The R&R is rejected that defendant didn’t have standing. “The Court finds that defendant has standing to challenge the police conduct in and near the … Continue reading

Posted in Independent source, Knock and talk, Standing | Comments Off on M.D.Fla.: Def was given guest standing to challenge a knock-and-talk that both sides agree was unreasonable

D.Minn.: Second SW cured defects in first

First search warrant probably violated the Fourth Amendment, but another was sought that omitted everything about the first search warrant, including what was found. The second was valid, and the good faith exception applied. United States v. Eggerson, 2018 U.S. … Continue reading

Posted in Good faith exception, Independent source | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Second SW cured defects in first

M.D.Fla.: Asking that lawyer look at SW isn’t refusal to consent under Randolph

Asking that a lawyer get to look at a search warrant with an electronic signature for validity is not a refusal to consent under Georgia v. Randolph. United States v. Sanchez, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 187115 (M.D. Fla. Nov. 1, … Continue reading

Posted in Consent, Independent source | Comments Off on M.D.Fla.: Asking that lawyer look at SW isn’t refusal to consent under Randolph

N.D.Ga.: Even though initial entry may have been unlawful, reentry at def’s request to get cell phone to call lawyer was by consent and permitted protective sweep

Defendant was arrested in what was alleged to be an unlawful entry. After he was out, he requested his cell phone so he could call a lawyer. Going back in with him and the protective sweep with it was by … Continue reading

Posted in Consent, Exclusionary rule, Independent source, Protective sweep | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Even though initial entry may have been unlawful, reentry at def’s request to get cell phone to call lawyer was by consent and permitted protective sweep

DE: State const’l claim Caballes should be rejected would not be considered on mere plain error review

Defendant for the first time on appeal raised a state constitutional argument that Caballes on dog sniffs as searched should be rejected. The court declines to go there on plain error review. Bradley v. State, 2018 Del. LEXIS 477 (Oct. … Continue reading

Posted in Dog sniff, Independent source, State constitution | Comments Off on DE: State const’l claim Caballes should be rejected would not be considered on mere plain error review

OH8: Home inspections was a reasonable probation condition for 42 housing code violations

Defendant was convicted of 42 counts of housing code violations of a house in constant disrepair since 2002. As a condition of probation, he was ordered to permit home inspections, and this was reasonably related to the offense of conviction. … Continue reading

Posted in Independent source, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on OH8: Home inspections was a reasonable probation condition for 42 housing code violations

AR: Cell phone search suppressed and state gets do over with independent source doctrine

Probable cause was shown for a search warrant for a cell phone for taking video of defendant’s daughters changing clothes under a door. The independent source doctrine permitted police to get a second search warrant for the phone after the … Continue reading

Posted in Cell phones, Independent source, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on AR: Cell phone search suppressed and state gets do over with independent source doctrine

CA10: You can’t tell the court it needs to apply the independent source case law a certain way and then complain on appeal that it did what you asked

This case started with hotel housekeeping coming in to clean a room and seeing obvious drug paraphernalia. The police were called, and they were shown. A search warrant was prepared showing probable cause to connect defendants to the room by … Continue reading

Posted in Burden of pleading, Burden of proof, Independent source, Scope of search | Comments Off on CA10: You can’t tell the court it needs to apply the independent source case law a certain way and then complain on appeal that it did what you asked