Category Archives: State constitution

MA: Riley applies under state const. to digital cameras

A digital camera, like a cell phone, can be seized incident to an arrest, but it can’t be searched without a warrant. While SCOTUS hasn’t applied Riley to digital cameras, the state constitution here affords the same protection to digital … Continue reading

Posted in Computer searches, Reasonable suspicion, State constitution | Comments Off

CO: In this recreational MJ use state, a dog sniff is a “search,” and a positive alert isn’t PC a crime is occurring

Use of a drug dog on a car is a “search” in marijuana recreational use Colorado, and a dog alert which could be of either legal or illegal substances is not probable cause. People v. McKnight, 2017 COA 93, 2017 … Continue reading

Posted in Dog sniff, Probable cause, Search, State constitution | Comments Off

IA: Breath test of boater was valid as search incident under 4A but not state const.

“[T]he breath test [of a boater] constituted a search incident to arrest excepted from the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement under Birchfield.” State v. Pettijohn, 2017 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 78 (June 30, 2017):

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Search incident, State constitution | Comments Off

OR: Generalized consent to open and look in a purse at a courthouse entrance is not per se consent to search a closed container inside

Court reaffirms that generalized consent to open and look in a purse at a courthouse entrance is not per se consent to search a closed container inside. State v. Winn, 361 Ore. 636, 2017 Ore. LEXIS 422 (June 29, 2017). … Continue reading

Posted in Consent, Reasonable suspicion, State constitution | Comments Off

NH: Limited state auto exception recognized where plainly visible contents are contraband

NH recognizes limited state automobile exception under state constitution where a warrant is not required where “the police have probable cause to believe that a plainly visible item in the vehicle is contraband.” State v. Cora, 2017 N.H. LEXIS 132 … Continue reading

Posted in Automobile exception, State constitution | Comments Off

ND: Separate state constitutional search argument has to be developed to be considered

Appellant’s “unconstitutional condition” argument under the Fourth Amendment has already been rejected in this case, and the state consitutitonal argument wasn’t developed. Marman v. Levi, 2017 ND 133, 2017 N.D. LEXIS 133 (June 7, 2017).* Defendant’s untimely motion for new … Continue reading

Posted in State constitution | Comments Off

HI imposes triggering condition in anticipatory warrants under state constitution

“We are faced with a question of first impression for this court: Does the Hawai’i Constitution require that an anticipatory search warrant identify the triggering condition on the face of the warrant? In light of the privacy protections contained in … Continue reading

Posted in Anticipatory warrant, State constitution | Comments Off

MA: SW required to access def’s text messages under SCA and state const.

The state needed a search warrant to access defendant’s text messages under the SCA and state constitution. Commonwealth v. Fulgiam, 2017 Mass. LEXIS 338 (May 5, 2017). (Massachusetts has already held that CSLI is protected under the state constitution.) “We … Continue reading

Posted in Cell phones, State constitution | Comments Off

MA: Minor deviations from the DUI roadblock plan don’t require suppression

The minor deviations from the plan for the DUI roadblock here don’t require suppression. Commonwealth v. Baker, 2017 Mass. App. LEXIS 53 (May 4, 2017). A citizen informant’s call that defendant had a knife in his back pocket justified a … Continue reading

Posted in Roadblocks, State constitution | Comments Off

NY Co.: Taking a “recidivist transit violator” outside the turnstiles was a reasonable detention

Plaintiff was a “recidivist transit violator” stopped for moving between cars. Taking him off the train outside the turnstiles was a reasonable detention under the state constitution. Vargas v. City of New York, 2017 NY Slip Op 27116, 2017 N.Y. … Continue reading

Posted in Seizure, State constitution | Comments Off