Author Archives: Hall

CA7: Cigarette sales in Chicago is “closely regulated” and subject to inspection

The sale of cigarettes in Chicago has been closely regulated since 1941 and required a license since 1900. Defendant was a prior offender of the ordinance in selling untaxed or individual cigarettes, and the city decided to inspect the cigarettes … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search | Comments Off on CA7: Cigarette sales in Chicago is “closely regulated” and subject to inspection

MA rejects Navarette on anonymous 911 calls but still finds reasonable suspicion from observation of driving

An anonymous 911 caller reported defendant’s erratic driving, and that led to defendant’s stop after the officer saw it for himself. Reliance on Navarette is rejected. “We decline to endorse the Supreme Court’s reliance on the use of the 911 … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay | Comments Off on MA rejects Navarette on anonymous 911 calls but still finds reasonable suspicion from observation of driving

TN: While tip was anonymous, def’s apparent impaired driving was RS

Officers received a 911 anonymous tip about a suspected impaired driver. Observing the driving gave reasonable suspicion for the stop, and whether Navarette is implicated doesn’t need to be decided and is outside question certified for review. State v. Headla, … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras, Consent, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on TN: While tip was anonymous, def’s apparent impaired driving was RS

IN: Concerned citizen report of man likely with gun was sufficient for encounter

Identified citizen informant’s 911 call that a man in the neighborhood appeared to be armed was reason for a police encounter with the defendant who became more skittish as they talked. Concerned citizen tips are important and should be acted … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on IN: Concerned citizen report of man likely with gun was sufficient for encounter

Politico: Drone privacy push could stall out

Politico: Drone privacy push could stall out by Tony Romm: The debate over drones and privacy is just one facet of a broader policy battle surrounding the future of the unmanned craft.

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on Politico: Drone privacy push could stall out

Oregon refuses to follow Illinois v. Rodriguez on apparent authority

Oregon refuses to follow Illinois v. Rodriguez on apparent authority finding it doctrinally different than how it has interpreted the state constitution since the 1970s. State v. Bonilla, 358 Ore. 475, 2015 Ore. LEXIS 955 (Dec. 31, 2015):

Posted in Apparent authority, State constitution | Comments Off on Oregon refuses to follow Illinois v. Rodriguez on apparent authority

Two on detentions without cause and no attenuation

Officers were running license numbers of cars on a drug store parking lot and found one where the owner had warrants out for him. When the driver showed up, and he generally matched the description of the owner, he fled … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on Two on detentions without cause and no attenuation

MA: Police remaining in def’s house after he went to hospital after a well-being check led to an unreasonable search

“In this appeal, the defendant challenges the denial of a motion to suppress the two tequila bottles seized during the well-being check. We conclude that the police had objectively reasonable grounds to believe that the defendant may have been injured … Continue reading →

Posted in Community caretaking function | Comments Off on MA: Police remaining in def’s house after he went to hospital after a well-being check led to an unreasonable search

NPR: Police Expert: Tasers Should Be Used Only When Suspects Are Threats

NPR: Police Expert: Tasers Should Be Used Only When Suspects Are Threats: The Chicago Police Department is doubling its supply of Tasers in an effort to reduce the use of lethal force. NPR’s Rachel Martin speaks with former Baltimore police … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on NPR: Police Expert: Tasers Should Be Used Only When Suspects Are Threats

NYLJ: Judge Denies Suppression Bid but Cautions U.S. Prosecutors

NYLJ: Judge Denies Suppression Bid but Cautions U.S. Prosecutors by Andrew Keshner: Eastern District Judge Raymond Dearie refused to suppress information from grand jury subpoenas improperly demanding secrecy from their recipients, but warned prosecutors he wouldn’t rule out suppression or … Continue reading →

Posted in Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters | Comments Off on NYLJ: Judge Denies Suppression Bid but Cautions U.S. Prosecutors

MN: Charging driver with the crime of refusal violates 4A and due process

Charging a driver with violating Minnesota’s refusal statute for refusing to submit to a urine test implicates a fundamental right because a warrantless search of the driver’s urine would not have been constitutional under an exception to the warrant requirement. … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on MN: Charging driver with the crime of refusal violates 4A and due process

D.Minn.: Redacting information from SW affidavit allegedly illegally obtained still left PC

The police entered after making an arrest and did a protective sweep then “froze” the premises to get a search warrant. Redacting the observations from the entry for the protective sweep from the affidavit still leaves probable cause for the … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Protective sweep | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Redacting information from SW affidavit allegedly illegally obtained still left PC

CA11: Hot pursuit permitted entry onto curtilage

The officer here was in hot pursuit of a car suspected of being the car taken in a carjacking. Finding it in the driveway of a house, the officer could enter the curtilage to ask about it. United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage, Emergency / exigency, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on CA11: Hot pursuit permitted entry onto curtilage

NYTimes: Op-Ed Contributors: A Better Standard for the Use of Deadly Force

NYTimes: Op-Ed Contributors: A Better Standard for the Use of Deadly Force by Olevia Boykin, Christopher Desir, Jed Rubenfeld: IN police shooting cases like that of 12-year-old Tamir Rice in Cleveland, grand jurors are typically asked to focus on one … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on NYTimes: Op-Ed Contributors: A Better Standard for the Use of Deadly Force

Cincinnati.com: What’s next for feds’ seizure program after local payments stopped?

Cincinnati.com: What’s next for feds’ seizure program after local payments stopped? by James Pilcher: Local law enforcement agencies will no longer reap any rewards from a controversial federal program that allows police to take money and property from individuals – … Continue reading →

Posted in Forfeiture | Comments Off on Cincinnati.com: What’s next for feds’ seizure program after local payments stopped?

WSJ: Viral Videos Shape Views of Police Conduct

WSJ: Viral Videos Shape Views of Police Conduct by Scott Calvert and Valerie Bauerlein As citizen footage sharpens a debate, states work to ensure transparency The article also mentions seizures of cell phones and iPads to delete the videos, which … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force, Surveillance technology | Comments Off on WSJ: Viral Videos Shape Views of Police Conduct

NY Times: Prosecutors’ Secrecy Orders on Subpoenas Stir Constitutional Questions

NY Times: Prosecutors’ Secrecy Orders on Subpoenas Stir Constitutional Questions by Stephanie Clifford: Marked with an official seal, the federal subpoena arrived at the red brick offices of Zuccarello, Zerillo & Co., an accounting firm in Whitestone, Queens, in early … Continue reading →

Posted in Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters | Comments Off on NY Times: Prosecutors’ Secrecy Orders on Subpoenas Stir Constitutional Questions

S.D.Fla.: Threshold arrest led to plain view and risk of destruction of evidence justifying entry

Officers had probable cause to arrest defendant at his house without a warrant, and they only crossed the threshold after seeing drug evidence in plain view when the door was opened, and defendant hesitated like he was going back in. … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on S.D.Fla.: Threshold arrest led to plain view and risk of destruction of evidence justifying entry

CA11: Two men, two beds = common authority over room

When two men shared a room with two beds, one can consent to a search of the whole room. This is joint custody and control. “Marvin had common authority to consent to search his shared bedroom, including Espinoza’s designated side … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Good faith exception, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on CA11: Two men, two beds = common authority over room

D.Kan.: Govt failed to prove legal basis for impoundment and inventory

Defendant had standing in his father’s car that he let defendant drive. The inventory of the car and impoundment was not for a legitimate inventory purpose. It was impounded because another police department asked for it. “The government has failed … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory, Search incident, Standing | Comments Off on D.Kan.: Govt failed to prove legal basis for impoundment and inventory