Author Archives: Hall

CA2: Crossing threshold to arrest without warrant violates Fourth Amendment

Officers stepping across the threshold to arrest without a warrant violated the Fourth Amendment. United States v. Allen, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 1467 (2d Cir. Jan. 29, 2016): “[W]hen it comes to the Fourth Amendment, the home is first among … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest | Comments Off on CA2: Crossing threshold to arrest without warrant violates Fourth Amendment

S.D.N.Y.: Motion to suppress denied for lack of proffer on standing

Defendant’s motion to suppress was denied because he didn’t even suggest in his papers he had standing in the vehicle he was only a passenger in. United States v. Londonio, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 8472 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 13, 2016). There … Continue reading →

Posted in Motion to suppress, Standing | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: Motion to suppress denied for lack of proffer on standing

OH5: Not unreasonable to deny passenger permission to retrieve purse before dog sniff of car

The smell of burning marijuana was probable cause for a car search. The officer’s refusal to let the passenger retrieve her purse from the car before the search did not violate the Fourth Amendment. State v. Eiler, 2016-Ohio-224, 2016 Ohio … Continue reading →

Posted in Collective knowledge, Dog sniff, Reasonableness | Comments Off on OH5: Not unreasonable to deny passenger permission to retrieve purse before dog sniff of car

D.N.J.: No REP in a rental car where def not an authorized driver and car was way overdue

Defendant was driving a rental car that was so overdue the tags were expired. It was rented by a cousin and the rental car company didn’t know who he was. With the stop, they were called and they wanted the … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on D.N.J.: No REP in a rental car where def not an authorized driver and car was way overdue

SC: Reading a computer SN was a “search” under Hicks, but it was permitted under a valid probation search

Defendant was on probation and believed to be involved in a murder where a red widescreen Acer laptop was taken. Probation officers went to his house to talk to him with reasonable suspicion, and he was sitting there with a … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search, Search | Comments Off on SC: Reading a computer SN was a “search” under Hicks, but it was permitted under a valid probation search

TN: Laptop search issue first raised in MNT is way too late; issue waived

Defendant was convicted of four counts of rape of a child. A laptop was properly seized from his car with probable cause under the automobile exception. It was searched without a warrant. Defendant waived the search of the computer by … Continue reading →

Posted in Immigration checkpoints, Motion to suppress | Comments Off on TN: Laptop search issue first raised in MNT is way too late; issue waived

E.D.Mich.: IAC claim over search denied for lack of factual proffer

2255 petitioner’s IAC claim denied for generality and no factual basis: “Here, the petitioner has failed to develop any factual basis or legal argument on the performance element, beyond the naked assertion that his attorneys did not advance any arguments … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Pole cameras | Comments Off on E.D.Mich.: IAC claim over search denied for lack of factual proffer

WaPo: 80 percent of Chicago PD dash-cam videos are missing audio due to ‘officer error’ or ‘intentional destruction’

WaPo: 80 percent of Chicago PD dash-cam videos are missing audio due to ‘officer error’ or ‘intentional destruction’ by Radley Balko: From DNA Info, here’s the latest piece of evidence that the corruption and abuse in the Chicago Police Department … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras, Police misconduct | Comments Off on WaPo: 80 percent of Chicago PD dash-cam videos are missing audio due to ‘officer error’ or ‘intentional destruction’

TX6: Def’s clothes were properly seized with PC under SI doctrine

Defendant’s clothes were believed to be evidence of a crime, and they were properly seized incident to arrest with probable cause and in plain view. In Texas, a municipal police officer may execute a search warrant countywide. Crayton v. State, … Continue reading →

Posted in Search incident | Comments Off on TX6: Def’s clothes were properly seized with PC under SI doctrine

SC: CoA missapplied std of review by reweighing facts; warns that “nervousness” isn’t a blank check

The court of appeals misapplied the standard of review by reweighing the facts. The court can’t help, however, in talking about nervousness as an “omnipresent” factor in reasonable suspicion. State v. Moore, 2016 S.C. LEXIS 5 (Jan. 27, 2016), rev’g … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Standards of review | Comments Off on SC: CoA missapplied std of review by reweighing facts; warns that “nervousness” isn’t a blank check

Cal.1: Electronic search condition of juvenile probation was overbroad; no relation to underlying offense

An electronic search condition of juvenile probation was overbroad. There was no relation between the offense and the condition that officers be allowed to search his phone and social media. In re Mark C., 2016 Cal. App. LEXIS 65 (1st … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on Cal.1: Electronic search condition of juvenile probation was overbroad; no relation to underlying offense

ars technica: Warrantless stingray case finally arrives before federal appellate judges

ars technica: Warrantless stingray case finally arrives before federal appellate judges by Cyrus Farivar: “Cell-site simulators raise especially serious questions under the Fourth Amendment.”

Posted in Cell site simulators | Comments Off on ars technica: Warrantless stingray case finally arrives before federal appellate judges

DE: Def made a sufficient offer of proof to get a Franks hearing in a DUI blood warrant over omissions in how the FST was done

Delaware refers to affidavit material omissions as a reverse-Franks issue, and here he made a sufficient offer of proof to get a hearing on a search warrant for blood in an DUI case about how the field sobriety test was … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine | Comments Off on DE: Def made a sufficient offer of proof to get a Franks hearing in a DUI blood warrant over omissions in how the FST was done

Conn.L.Trib: Editorial: Court Rulings Suggest That Police Should Consider Nonlethal Alternatives

Conn.L.Trib: Editorial: Court Rulings Suggest That Police Should Consider Nonlethal Alternatives Courts have held that the Fourth Amendment does not require police officers to choose the least intrusive alternative, only a reasonable one. As we see more and more innocent … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on Conn.L.Trib: Editorial: Court Rulings Suggest That Police Should Consider Nonlethal Alternatives

Road and Track: One Company Is Selling Location Data for Billions of License Plates to Police

Road and Track: One Company Is Selling Location Data for Billions of License Plates to Police A private company called Vigilant Solutions owns 2.2 billion photographs of car and truck licenses. Is this a violation of privacy?

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on Road and Track: One Company Is Selling Location Data for Billions of License Plates to Police

AZ: General consent to search includes use of a drug dog

A general consent to search includes use of a drug dog. State v. Becerra, 2016 Ariz. App. LEXIS 9 (Jan. 25, 2016). A woman concerned about the safety of a child conducted the cell phone search here, and that was … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Private search | Comments Off on AZ: General consent to search includes use of a drug dog

CA11: Attorney has no standing in legal mail searched in a prison cell

An attorney of an inmate has no Fourth Amendment right in his client’s prison cell for the opening of prisoner mail during a cell security search. Williams v. Russo, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 1063 (11th Cir. Jan. 22, 2016). Appellate … Continue reading →

Posted in Standing | Comments Off on CA11: Attorney has no standing in legal mail searched in a prison cell

D.Nev.: Minor discrepancies in the facts not enough to require a hearing; suppression denied on the papers

“Despite minor discrepancies [about smelling marijuana], the essential facts [in the reports] demonstrate that the officers’ conduct was reasonable under the Fourth Amendment. The search of defendant’s car and resulting discovery of the firearm is therefore valid and will not … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof | Comments Off on D.Nev.: Minor discrepancies in the facts not enough to require a hearing; suppression denied on the papers

IN: Search of a pill bottle found during a patdown for arrest for no DL was permissible under state constitution; court of appeals reversed

Search of a pill bottle found during a patdown for arrest for no DL was permissible under state constitution, and the court of appeals is reversed. Garcia v. State, 2016 Ind. LEXIS 30 (Jan. 21, 2016), rev’g 25 N.E.3d 786 … Continue reading →

Posted in Search incident | Comments Off on IN: Search of a pill bottle found during a patdown for arrest for no DL was permissible under state constitution; court of appeals reversed

CA11: Miami’s seizure and destruction of ptf’s “ugly” sailboat stated a 4A claim under Soldal

Plaintiff lived on his sailboat in the City of Miami on state waters. He was stopped by marine officers who complained of his lack of property sanitary facilities and not having a good enough anchor light. They accused him of … Continue reading →

Posted in Seizure | Comments Off on CA11: Miami’s seizure and destruction of ptf’s “ugly” sailboat stated a 4A claim under Soldal