Author Archives: Hall

WA: Child porn SW permitted search and seizure of adult porn, and that made it overbroad; merely citing the CP statute doesn’t narrow it

Where a child pornography search warrant also permitted seizure of adult pornography which is not unlawful, it was overbroad under established precedent for 23 years. Merely citing the child pornography in the search warrant wasn’t a cure. State v. Besola, … Continue reading →

Posted in Overbreadth | Comments Off on WA: Child porn SW permitted search and seizure of adult porn, and that made it overbroad; merely citing the CP statute doesn’t narrow it

NY3: It’s not IAC to not listen to the audio of the SW application where there was a motion to suppress for lack of PC

Defense counsel was not ineffective for not listening to the audio of the oral application for the search warrant challenging probable cause. The defense moved to suppress on lack of PC, and it was denied by the trial court and … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Informant hearsay, Reasonable suspicion, Reasonableness | Comments Off on NY3: It’s not IAC to not listen to the audio of the SW application where there was a motion to suppress for lack of PC

OH5: Order to remove shoes during traffic stop was not consent

The order to defendant during a traffic stop to remove his shoes showed it was not by consent. The trial court’s suppression order is affirmed. State v. Carothers, 2015-Ohio-4569, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 4455 (5th Dist. Nov. 3, 2015). Police … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on OH5: Order to remove shoes during traffic stop was not consent

AL: Federal adoption of a forfeiture deprives the state court of jurisdiction to order return of property

Federal adoption of a forfeiture deprives the state court of jurisdiction to order return of property. Gray v. City of Opelika, 2015 Ala. Civ. App. LEXIS 254 (Nov. 6, 2015). A traffic offense justified this stop, then “the smell of … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay, Plain view, feel, smell, Rule 41(g) / Return of property | Comments Off on AL: Federal adoption of a forfeiture deprives the state court of jurisdiction to order return of property

The Atlantic: Body Cameras and The Death of a 6-Year-Old Boy

The Atlantic: Body Cameras and The Death of a 6-Year-Old Boy by Marina Koren: Police say footage of an officer-involved shooting contributed to prosecutors’ decision to press charges.

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on The Atlantic: Body Cameras and The Death of a 6-Year-Old Boy

D.Nev.: Execution of SW in def’s home and moving him to basement for questioning made it custodial subject to Miranda

“No circuit court has held that an occupant must be Mirandized as a matter of course when the police execute a search warrant in the home.” The nature of a search is, of course, police dominated by definition, and, in … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on D.Nev.: Execution of SW in def’s home and moving him to basement for questioning made it custodial subject to Miranda

VA: Davis-type good faith exception applies to the length of the detention where Rodriguez decided while case on appeal

Davis-type good faith exception applies to a violation of Rodriguez on the length of the detention where no state or Fourth Circuit case said an overlong stop was unreasonable. (Rodriguez was decided while the appeal was pending, but the defense … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception | Comments Off on VA: Davis-type good faith exception applies to the length of the detention where Rodriguez decided while case on appeal

LA3: The person who owned a document obtained by SW clearly has standing for its return

Somebody was denied a job at a hospital, and complained to the Jefferson Davis Parish Sheriff’s Office who sought a search warrant for the letter received that apparently caused the job denial. A judge pro tem issued the search warrant … Continue reading →

Posted in Rule 41(g) / Return of property, Standing | Comments Off on LA3: The person who owned a document obtained by SW clearly has standing for its return

CO declines to give greater state const’l rights to closed container

Defendant was stopped for fictitious tags, and he had a revoked DL and no insurance, too. An inventory of the vehicle was conducted, and a closed cooler was searched. Conceding the search valid under the Fourth Amendment, he argued that … Continue reading →

Posted in Collective knowledge, Inventory, State constitution | Comments Off on CO declines to give greater state const’l rights to closed container

TX1: Davis GFE does not apply because of statutory exclusionary rule

“[T]he judge-made Davis exception to the judge-made federal exclusionary rule does not create an exception to the Texas exclusionary rule adopted by the Texas Legislature. Because the search warrant in this case was not based on probable cause, the Texas … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on TX1: Davis GFE does not apply because of statutory exclusionary rule

APNewsBreak: US border agency staff rejects body cameras for agents, citing cost, terrain

APNewsBreak: US border agency staff rejects body cameras for agents, citing cost, terrain by Elliot Spagat: Customs and Border Protection staff concluded after an internal review that agents and officers shouldn’t be required to wear body cameras, positioning the nation’s … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on APNewsBreak: US border agency staff rejects body cameras for agents, citing cost, terrain

CA9 en banc: Violation of Posse Comitatus Act was systemic but unique and suppression will not be ordered

“[T]he scenario presented by this case is both extreme and unusual”: An NCIS officer conducted a statewide investigation of P2P computers with child pornography on them and reported defendant. NCIS investigators are civilian but answer to the Secretary of the … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on CA9 en banc: Violation of Posse Comitatus Act was systemic but unique and suppression will not be ordered

OH2: Heroin gel caps found by plain feel

Defendant was fully cooperative and the officer was not overbearing, so the consent was voluntary. Heroin in gel caps was found by plain feel. State v. Mabry, 2015-Ohio-4513, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 4400 (2d Dist. Oct. 30, 2015). http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/2/2015/2015-Ohio-4513.pdf Officers … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on OH2: Heroin gel caps found by plain feel

NYTimes: How the F.B.I. Can Detain, Render and Threaten Without Risk

NYTimes: How the F.B.I. Can Detain, Render and Threaten Without Risk by Patrick G. Eddington (Opinion): Eight years after Mr. Meshal’s rendition, his case ended up before a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the District … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on NYTimes: How the F.B.I. Can Detain, Render and Threaten Without Risk

The Hill: House bill would require warrants for aerial surveillance

The Hill: House bill would require warrants for aerial surveillance by David McCabe: A House bill introduced on Thursday would require federal law enforcement officials to get a warrant if they want to conduct aerial surveillance inside the country.

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on The Hill: House bill would require warrants for aerial surveillance

WaPo: The FAA is about to require recreational drone registration. Here are the recommended rules.

WaPo: The FAA is about to require recreational drone registration. Here are the recommended rules. by Matt McFarland: A government task force created to recommend registration guidelines for recreational drones wrapped up three days of meetings in Washington Thursday.

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on WaPo: The FAA is about to require recreational drone registration. Here are the recommended rules.

CA7: § 1983 SOL starts from the date of the search and seizure

Plaintiff was arrested, searched, prosecuted, and acquitted. He claimed illegal search and seizure and police theft of property, but the claim was filed 2½ years after the occurrence, and Illinois has a two year limitations period. “Claims for wrongful search … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on CA7: § 1983 SOL starts from the date of the search and seizure

D.D.C.: Asking a man on the street to pull up shirt to expose waistband is not a seizure

Under D.C.Cir. case law, an officer driving by a person in a high crime area and asking him to pull up his shirt or expose his waistband is not a seizure. Here, officers did that with a small group and … Continue reading →

Posted in Seizure | Comments Off on D.D.C.: Asking a man on the street to pull up shirt to expose waistband is not a seizure

CA10: Unlawful provoked flight to make an arrest supported criminal civil rights violation against officer

Defendant was a sheriff indicted in Albuquerque for excessive force during an off-duty road rage incident. The victim’s unlawful arrest was based on provoked flight caused by the sheriff. There was also 404(b) evidence of similar occurrences. He was sentenced … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest | Comments Off on CA10: Unlawful provoked flight to make an arrest supported criminal civil rights violation against officer

NM: Lack of prior notice of a sobriety checkpoint not fatal; suppression reversed

“The State of New Mexico appeals from an order granting a motion to suppress evidence based on an unconstitutional sobriety checkpoint. The State raises a single issue on appeal: whether the lack of advance publicity makes a sobriety checkpoint unconstitutional, … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Exclusionary rule, Ineffective assistance, Roadblocks | Comments Off on NM: Lack of prior notice of a sobriety checkpoint not fatal; suppression reversed