Author Archives: Hall

NM: Police helicopter flyover at 50-100′ disrupted and damaged the property and scared the occupants and violated curtilage

A police helicopter flyover at 50-100′ disrupted and damaged the property and scared the occupants. Therefore, it violated the curtilage under the Fourth Amendment. Thus, the state constitutional issue does not have to be decided. State v. Davis, 2015 N.M. … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage, Reasonableness | Comments Off on NM: Police helicopter flyover at 50-100′ disrupted and damaged the property and scared the occupants and violated curtilage

OH2: Looking under an air mattress for a person was valid in a protective sweep

Officers in hot pursuit chased two men to a house, and the door was locked. They “knocked” and got no answer, retrieved a battering ram, and broke in. A protective sweep of the house revealed plenty of drugs in plain … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep | Comments Off on OH2: Looking under an air mattress for a person was valid in a protective sweep

S.D.Iowa: Looking for gun serial number exceeded scope of protective sweep and is suppressed

DHS officers executed a search warrant on an empty house looking for a 2×4″ object (an I-551 stamp). They didn’t find it. In the course of the search, they opened an Xbox box in a closet and found a handgun. … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep | Comments Off on S.D.Iowa: Looking for gun serial number exceeded scope of protective sweep and is suppressed

GA: No factual support for police conclusion a protective sweep was justified

The evidence here does not support the trial court’s findings that a protective sweep was justified. Two officers entered the house after defendant and he was subdued, and inside there was the defendant and two others. There was no suggestion … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep | Comments Off on GA: No factual support for police conclusion a protective sweep was justified

N.D.Cal.: Defendant’s wife’s turning over his computer hard drive to police was a private search

Defendant was out of town when his wife found child pornography on the computer he let her regularly use. She called the police and turned over the hard drive, and they got a search warrant for a forensic examination. He … Continue reading →

Posted in Private search | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Defendant’s wife’s turning over his computer hard drive to police was a private search

CA2: Def surprised at trial with unknown alleged consent search gets a post-trial evidentiary hearing on it

Defendant was surprised at trial with testimony that defendant’s wife had consented to a search of his computer prior to the search warrant issuing. Defendant moved for a mistrial. The FBI agent involved in that search was from Alabama and … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof | Comments Off on CA2: Def surprised at trial with unknown alleged consent search gets a post-trial evidentiary hearing on it

OH9: No standing in a package of drugs shipped to house in boyfriend’s name

A package containing cocaine was shipped to defendant’s house in the name of her boyfriend. She had no standing in the package because her name wasn’t on it. State v. Padilla, 2015-Ohio-4220, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 4112 (9th Dist. Oct. … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Standing | Comments Off on OH9: No standing in a package of drugs shipped to house in boyfriend’s name

TX2: Passenger puking in car was not an exigent circumstance; she was not in danger

The fact defendant’s passenger had puked in the car was not an exigency requiring police action. There was no evidence she was a danger to herself or others. They were already near hospitals. Byram v. State, 2015 Tex. App. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on TX2: Passenger puking in car was not an exigent circumstance; she was not in danger

FL3: Neighbor’s call of a broken back window brought police who suspected burglary; entry was justified

Defendant’s neighbor called the police because of a broken back window strongly suggesting a burglary. An officer arrived with a dog, and when no one answered, he sent in the dog. Following the dog, no people were found but the … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on FL3: Neighbor’s call of a broken back window brought police who suspected burglary; entry was justified

OH9: If the drug dog gets there before the paperwork is done, the sniff is fine

Defendant’s stop for a lane change violation was valid. A drug dog officer arrived before the paperwork was processed, so the stop was not continued for that. [So, as long as the drug dog arrives promptly, a dog sniff of … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff | Comments Off on OH9: If the drug dog gets there before the paperwork is done, the sniff is fine

Wired: Report: Feds Will Require All Drones to Be Registered

Wired: Report: Feds Will Require All Drones to Be Registered by Michael Calore: We should expect the new regulations to be made public Monday, the report says. This will enable the new rules to be put into place before the … Continue reading →

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on Wired: Report: Feds Will Require All Drones to Be Registered

AP (via AOL): Florida woman streamed live video of drunken driving

AP (via AOL): Florida woman streamed live video of drunken driving: Authorities say 911 calls from concerned viewers led to the arrest of a Florida woman who was streaming live video of herself while driving drunk. Lakeland police report 23-year-old … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on AP (via AOL): Florida woman streamed live video of drunken driving

CA10: Officers get qualified immunity for SW that was not completely without particularity

In this § 1983 case over the particularity of a search warrant over stolen cars on his property, the officers had qualified immunity. The warrant was not so lacking in particularity that a reasonable officer couldn’t rely on it. Rathbun … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Particularity | Comments Off on CA10: Officers get qualified immunity for SW that was not completely without particularity

OR: Opening garage door when defendant didn’t answer knock and said “hide that” was unreasonable

Police came to defendant’s house with state DHS and found the garage door open 8-18″. The officer called out for defendant to open the garage door, and he didn’t respond. From inside, they heard him say “hide that.” Then the … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on OR: Opening garage door when defendant didn’t answer knock and said “hide that” was unreasonable

C.D.Ill.: Before and after a CI does a controlled buy, there is no constitutional requirement that the CI be subjected to a body cavity search

Before and after a CI does a controlled buy, there is no constitutional requirement that the CI be subjected to a body cavity search. United States v. Sidwell, 440 F.3d 865, 869 (7th Cir. 2006); United States v. Garcia, 983 … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Informant hearsay, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on C.D.Ill.: Before and after a CI does a controlled buy, there is no constitutional requirement that the CI be subjected to a body cavity search

TX: Counsel’s isolated statements a SW wasn’t obtained for a blood draw was not enough to put state and court on notice that exigency needed to be decided

“Are isolated statements globally asserting that a blood draw was conducted without a warrant enough to apprise the trial court that it must consider whether there were exigent circumstances to permit a warrantless search in a driving while intoxicated case, … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Drug or alcohol testing, Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on TX: Counsel’s isolated statements a SW wasn’t obtained for a blood draw was not enough to put state and court on notice that exigency needed to be decided

AP (via ABC): Couple Prolongs Police Standoff for Sex ‘One Last Time’; leading to resisting charge

AP (via ABC): Couple Prolongs Police Standoff for Sex ‘One Last Time’: A man and woman have been arrested after officials say they prolonged a standoff with police in order to have sex. Police tell local news outlets they responded … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on AP (via ABC): Couple Prolongs Police Standoff for Sex ‘One Last Time’; leading to resisting charge

Forbes: While The Supreme Court Hesitates On Warrantless Cell Location Data Collection, Your Privacy Remains At Risk

Forbes: While The Supreme Court Hesitates On Warrantless Cell Location Data Collection, Your Privacy Remains At Risk by Abigail Tracy: Two conflicting federal court rulings at the appellate level over whether or not the government can obtain your cellphone location … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, SCOTUS | Comments Off on Forbes: While The Supreme Court Hesitates On Warrantless Cell Location Data Collection, Your Privacy Remains At Risk

N.D.W.Va.: Correcting a date in affidavit for SW in front of USMJ was hardly improper, particularly when the correct date was put in

Three month old information about an IP address in a child pornography case wasn’t stale. Also, the warrant wasn’t issued without probable cause just because the warrant was amended in handwriting before the magistrate, particularly because the correct date was … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Inevitable discovery, Probable cause, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on N.D.W.Va.: Correcting a date in affidavit for SW in front of USMJ was hardly improper, particularly when the correct date was put in

DE: Without a showing there is anything to test DNA against, a warrant for DNA may be without PC; but here moot for now

Without a showing there is anything to test DNA against, a warrant for DNA may be without probable cause. After surveying the cases requiring there be something to test for a sample to be obtained, the question here is moot … Continue reading →

Posted in DNA, Nexus, Probable cause | Comments Off on DE: Without a showing there is anything to test DNA against, a warrant for DNA may be without PC; but here moot for now