Author Archives: Hall

MO: PC for personal quantity in console not PC for trunk under automobile exception

Defendant was stopped for potentially being under the influence, and he passed FST’s. The officer had him in the patrol car asking questions, and defendant admitted to Suboxone in the console. Still, for the automobile exception, the court finds no … Continue reading →

Posted in Scope of search | Comments Off on MO: PC for personal quantity in console not PC for trunk under automobile exception

The Hill: GOP chairman joins with Dems on bill to limit cellphone spying

The Hill: GOP chairman joins with Dems on bill to limit cellphone spying by Julian Hattem: The Republican head of the House Oversight Committee is teaming up with a pair of Democrats to try to enact new limits on the … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on The Hill: GOP chairman joins with Dems on bill to limit cellphone spying

The Hill: Blog: Drones are a national security nightmare

The Hill: Blog: Drones are a national security nightmare by Joel D. Joseph: The Federal Aviation Administration is rushing to pass regulations of drones within the next thirty days so that drones can be under your Christmas tree. Frankly, we … Continue reading →

Posted in Drones, National security | Comments Off on The Hill: Blog: Drones are a national security nightmare

TN: Motion for return of property doesn’t require a motion to suppress and can come after judgment

A state motion for return of property does not require a motion to suppress. “Additionally, the State’s argument that the trial court lacks jurisdiction because the judgment has become final is misplaced. The Defendant is not seeking to challenge his … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Rule 41(g) / Return of property, Seizure | Comments Off on TN: Motion for return of property doesn’t require a motion to suppress and can come after judgment

GA: If the dog sniff comes before dispatch reports back on the DL check, the dog sniff is valid (4-3)

A dog sniff of a car while waiting for the driver’s and passenger’s DL info to come back did not in any way extend the stop, so it’s valid. (4-3) State v. Allen, 2015 Ga. LEXIS 789 (Nov. 2, 2015), … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Reasonableness | Comments Off on GA: If the dog sniff comes before dispatch reports back on the DL check, the dog sniff is valid (4-3)

M.D.Tenn.: “[D]etermining when a traffic stop has been completed, or reasonably should have been completed, can be complicated”

Reconsideration was sought under Rodriguez, and the court finds that defendant consented to the search before the stop became too long. United States v. Hendrix, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 146860 (M.D.Tenn. Oct. 29, 2015):

Posted in Consent, Reasonableness | Comments Off on M.D.Tenn.: “[D]etermining when a traffic stop has been completed, or reasonably should have been completed, can be complicated”

TechDirt: Court Tosses Bogus Wiretapping Charge Against Man Who Recorded Cops Who Raided His House

TechDirt: Court Tosses Bogus Wiretapping Charge Against Man Who Recorded Cops Who Raided His House by Tim Cushing: For many years, law enforcement agencies used (mostly outdated) wiretapping laws to justify arrests and prosecutions of citizens who recorded them during … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones | Comments Off on TechDirt: Court Tosses Bogus Wiretapping Charge Against Man Who Recorded Cops Who Raided His House

Govt Technology: Does the Fourth Amendment Trump Your Locked Smartphone?

Govt Technology: Does the Fourth Amendment Trump Your Locked Smartphone? by Daniel Rothberg: Because of recent updates to the encryption on Google and Apple software, newly updated Androids and iPhones no longer can be unlocked — even if law enforcement … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Surveillance technology | Comments Off on Govt Technology: Does the Fourth Amendment Trump Your Locked Smartphone?

D.Nev.: Parolee with traffic warrants fleeing from car and tossing keys justified parole search of car

Las Vegas officers were randomly running license plates and they ran a Saturn’s plates on a Walgreen’s parking lot after the occupant went into the store. It showed that the owner had outstanding traffic warrants and was on parole. The … Continue reading →

Posted in Abandonment, Automobile exception, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on D.Nev.: Parolee with traffic warrants fleeing from car and tossing keys justified parole search of car

CA2: Uncle’s apparent authority over nephew’s room included under the mattress

Defendant stayed with his aunt and uncle in a room that everybody had access to when he wasn’t there. His uncle consented to a search of the room for a firearm when he wasn’t there. He didn’t contest the consent … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Scope of search | Comments Off on CA2: Uncle’s apparent authority over nephew’s room included under the mattress

UT: Police car’s overhead lights usually mean seizure to the motorist the police car is behind

A police car’s overhead lights can be ambiguous, but, to the motorist, they mean you are stopped and should not attempt to leave. It’s common knowledge the consequences of not staying stopped could be severe. Defendant was thus stopped, but … Continue reading →

Posted in Community caretaking function, Seizure | Comments Off on UT: Police car’s overhead lights usually mean seizure to the motorist the police car is behind

TX11: Invalid portion of warrant properly severed, but the cocaine was still admissible

Texas JP’s can’t issue evidentiary search warrants by statute. This was partially that and mostly for cocaine. The trial court properly severed the invalid portion and suppressed, and the cocaine was properly admitted. Van Spotwood v. State, 2015 Tex. App. … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule, Protective sweep | Comments Off on TX11: Invalid portion of warrant properly severed, but the cocaine was still admissible

CA6: Officers’ civil assist ended up in stating a claim in the retaking of a car

Officers were on a civil assist in aiding repossession of a car that was involved in a family dispute going back and forth for a couple of years. “Viewing the record in the light most favorable to plaintiffs, we agree … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Qualified immunity, Seizure | Comments Off on CA6: Officers’ civil assist ended up in stating a claim in the retaking of a car

Microsoft: Body-worn camera policy guide: Key guidance for managing body-worn camera video

Microsoft: Body-worn camera policy guide: Key guidance for managing body-worn camera video: Thinking of adopting body worn cameras? Here’s where to begin. Body worn cameras are the latest in technology enabling better policing. Departments across the United States and the … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on Microsoft: Body-worn camera policy guide: Key guidance for managing body-worn camera video

Wired: Turns Out Police Stingray Spy Tools Can Indeed Record Calls

Wired: Turns Out Police Stingray Spy Tools Can Indeed Record Calls by Kim Zetter: The federal government has been fighting hard for years to hide details about its use of so-called stingray surveillance technology from the public. The surveillance devices … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site simulators | Comments Off on Wired: Turns Out Police Stingray Spy Tools Can Indeed Record Calls

NPR: Stealth Mode? Built-in Monitor? Not All Body Cameras Are Created Equal

NPR: Stealth Mode? Built-in Monitor? Not All Body Cameras Are Created Equal by Martin Kaste: Amid the recent pressure on police to wear body cameras, one thing is often overlooked: Not all cameras are created equal. In fact, cameras vary … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on NPR: Stealth Mode? Built-in Monitor? Not All Body Cameras Are Created Equal

N.D.Ill.: With arrest in driveway on a fake drug deal, govt fails to show entry into garage was inevitable; cash suppressed

Defendant was handcuffed and questioned in his driveway about a CI’s planned transaction with him that the government controlled. He was handcuffed in his driveway and 10 officers were there. The court finds his statements about the money in his … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation | Comments Off on N.D.Ill.: With arrest in driveway on a fake drug deal, govt fails to show entry into garage was inevitable; cash suppressed

KY: No standing in GPS placed in a borrowed car

Defendant and others were suspects as serial robbers, and the police placed GPS devices on two cars in 2008. On defendant’s, he was not the owner and he just borrowed it. Placing the GPS in the first place was not … Continue reading →

Posted in GPS / Tracking Data, Standing | Comments Off on KY: No standing in GPS placed in a borrowed car

IA: Grandfather could consent over his grandson living in separate room

Defendant was staying with his grandfather, who couldn’t get him out of the house to work and a shoving match ensued. Grandfather called the police and consented to a search. Defendant wasn’t paying rent, and precedent already holds that occupant … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent | Comments Off on IA: Grandfather could consent over his grandson living in separate room

CA8: Air filter could be searched in inventory

Defendant argued that the search of the air filter container was excessive for an inventory because it was not an area where things were normally stored. The policy explicitly provided for search of that area, and the court has previously … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory | Comments Off on CA8: Air filter could be searched in inventory