Author Archives: Hall

OH3: Trial court decided issue defense didn’t raise, and state prejudiced

The trial court erred in sua sponte raising a length of detention issue that the state did not get to respond to. State v. Miller, 2015-Ohio-3529, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3443 (3d Dist. August 31, 2015):

Posted in Burden of proof, Motion to suppress | Comments Off on OH3: Trial court decided issue defense didn’t raise, and state prejudiced

CA8: Rodriguez loses on remand to Davis GFE [the ultimate perversion of good faith: the guy whose case made the rule loses, too]

WaPo: Volokh Conspiracy: Rodriguez wins, Rodriguez loses by Orin Kerr (United States v. Rodriguez, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 15675 (8th Cir. September 3, 2015):

Posted in Good faith exception | Comments Off on CA8: Rodriguez loses on remand to Davis GFE [the ultimate perversion of good faith: the guy whose case made the rule loses, too]

techdirt: DOJ Reasserts Its Right To Engage In Seized Data Fishing Expeditions

techdirt: DOJ Reasserts Its Right To Engage In Seized Data Fishing Expeditions by Tim Cushing: Last June, the Second Circuit appeals court restored a bit of Fourth Amendment protection to computers/devices seized by government investigators. In the case being appealed, … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches | Comments Off on techdirt: DOJ Reasserts Its Right To Engage In Seized Data Fishing Expeditions

Connecticut Law Tribune: Police Video Surveillance of Psychologists’ House Prompts Lawsuit

Connecticut Law Tribune: Police Video Surveillance of Psychologists’ House Prompts Lawsuit by Christian Nolan: A married couple from Westport is suing the town and several of its police officers for what they claim is unlawful video surveillance of their home.

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on Connecticut Law Tribune: Police Video Surveillance of Psychologists’ House Prompts Lawsuit

S.D.Ala.: The Coast Guard had authority to board a moored ship to conduct an oil dumping investigation; a complete search occurred after PC developed

A whistleblower contacted the Coast Guard that his oil tanker he was on approaching Mobile had been oil dumping. The Coast Guard boarded the ship when it was docked and conducted an inspection of the engine room and common areas. … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search | Comments Off on S.D.Ala.: The Coast Guard had authority to board a moored ship to conduct an oil dumping investigation; a complete search occurred after PC developed

OH2: The driver matched the description of the owner of the vehicle, so ordering him out was reasonable when a warrant came back for owner

Defendant’s LPN showed that the owner was the same person who had committed criminal trespass. The driver matched the general description of the owner, so that justified getting the driver out. State v. Goines, 2015-Ohio-3505, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3427 … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on OH2: The driver matched the description of the owner of the vehicle, so ordering him out was reasonable when a warrant came back for owner

E.D.La.: Omitted informant information needs to be dispositive to undermine PC

More information could probably be included in all search warrant affidavits, but that doesn’t make them misleading for omissions. The omissions must be “dispositive” of probable cause, not just cast a little doubt on it. United States v. Wijetunge, 2015 … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on E.D.La.: Omitted informant information needs to be dispositive to undermine PC

Ars Technica: New law permits North Dakota cop drones to fire beanbag rounds from the sky

Ars Technica: New law permits North Dakota cop drones to fire beanbag rounds from the sky by Cyrus Farivar: To pass new warrant requirement, lawmaker compromised to allow less-than-lethals.

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on Ars Technica: New law permits North Dakota cop drones to fire beanbag rounds from the sky

NYTimes: After a Killing, Body Cameras Are Expanded in San Antonio

NYTimes: After a Killing, Body Cameras Are Expanded in San Antonio by Manny Fernandez: One day after a bystander’s cellphone video was released that appeared to show sheriff’s deputies fatally shooting a Hispanic man who had his hands raised in … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on NYTimes: After a Killing, Body Cameras Are Expanded in San Antonio

WA: PC for intoxication is what must be shown, not particularly drug or alcohol

In a felony DUI case under, probable cause to suspect drug intoxication did not have to be identified separately from probable cause to suspect alcohol intoxication, and the affidavit for the warrant was sufficient. The warrant had sufficient particularity to … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on WA: PC for intoxication is what must be shown, not particularly drug or alcohol

AJC: Officer, homeowner shot when DeKalb police respond to wrong house

Atlanta Journal-Constitution: Officer, homeowner shot when DeKalb police respond to wrong house by Ben Gray and Alexis Stevens. They entered solely because of an unlocked, not open, door: A DeKalb County police officer was critically injured, a homeowner injured and … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on AJC: Officer, homeowner shot when DeKalb police respond to wrong house

CA9: Court ordered DNA collection permissible solely to exclude persons from an investigation

A Phoenix officer was shot and killed on duty. “More than 300 public safety personnel, the chief of police, and the mayor quickly converged on the scene. Roughly 100 people entered the area where Sergeant Drenth’s body was discovered, including … Continue reading →

Posted in DNA | Comments Off on CA9: Court ordered DNA collection permissible solely to exclude persons from an investigation

The Hill: Supreme Court pressed to rule on police access to cellphone data

The Hill: Supreme Court pressed to rule on police access to cellphone data by Lydia Wheeler:

Posted in Cell site location information | Comments Off on The Hill: Supreme Court pressed to rule on police access to cellphone data

Dallas News: [Texas] Invasive body cavity searches will now require a warrant

Dallas News: Invasive body cavity searches will now require a warrant by Brandi Grissom:

Posted in Body searches | Comments Off on Dallas News: [Texas] Invasive body cavity searches will now require a warrant

ND: Officer who had no authority to move things in car conducted a search, so it wasn’t a valid plain view

The officer only had permission to move defendant’s vehicle. Inside, he moved around something to get a better look at a bag and searched it. The motion to suppress should have been granted because this was not a valid plain … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on ND: Officer who had no authority to move things in car conducted a search, so it wasn’t a valid plain view

CA5: Ptfs’ failure to show lack of PC doomed § 1983 case

There was no effort on the part of plaintiffs to show that their arrest was without probable cause. They submitted city recall petitions, but some of the names were friends and relatives of the persons being recalled. The recallees hired … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Consent, Probable cause, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA5: Ptfs’ failure to show lack of PC doomed § 1983 case

Journal Sentinel: Report shows deep racial disparity in arrests in Madison

Journal Sentinel: Report shows deep racial disparity in arrests in Madison: A black person in Madison is over 10 times more likely than a white person to be arrested, according to an analysis published Sunday by the Wisconsin State Journal. … Continue reading →

Posted in Pretext | Comments Off on Journal Sentinel: Report shows deep racial disparity in arrests in Madison

NPR: Why Utah Is The Only State Trying To Track And Limit SWAT-Style Tactics

NPR: Why Utah Is The Only State Trying To Track And Limit SWAT-Style Tactics by Martin Kaste: The phrase police militarization conjures up an image of cops wrapped in Kevlar, barging into homes with semi-automatic weapons. But familiar as that … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on NPR: Why Utah Is The Only State Trying To Track And Limit SWAT-Style Tactics

OH9: A challenge to evidence under the rules of evidence is brought by a motion in limine, not a motion to suppress

A challenge to evidence under the rules of evidence is brought by a motion in limine, not a motion to suppress. That’s for constitutional grounds. State v. Johnson, 2015-Ohio-3449, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3327 (9th Dist. August 26, 2015). One … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Motion to suppress | Comments Off on OH9: A challenge to evidence under the rules of evidence is brought by a motion in limine, not a motion to suppress

D.N.M.: Gov’t fails to show consent for search of person; body recording doesn’t back it up

Defendant did not consent to a search of her person on a stop on a train. Defendant’s alleged “okay” on the body recording made by the officer and shown on the government’s transcript is an incoherent mumble, and not clear … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras, Consent | Comments Off on D.N.M.: Gov’t fails to show consent for search of person; body recording doesn’t back it up