Author Archives: Hall

OH5: Can’t appeal a suppression issue that wasn’t dispositive of his case because it was merely advisory

Defendant couldn’t appeal a suppression issue that wasn’t dispositive of his case because it was merely advisory. State v. Cooley, 2015-Ohio-3904, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3773 (5th Dist. September 23, 2015). Defense consent was valid, and it was not based … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent | Comments Off on OH5: Can’t appeal a suppression issue that wasn’t dispositive of his case because it was merely advisory

IL: A forced chemical test of the blood two days after an accident was after the reduced REP of a driver had lapsed

A chemical test of appellant’s blood violated the Fourth Amendment because the police sought a chemical test two days after the car accident when plaintiff no longer had a diminished expectation of privacy. McElwain v. Office of the Ill. Secy. … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Reasonable suspicion, Seizure | Comments Off on IL: A forced chemical test of the blood two days after an accident was after the reduced REP of a driver had lapsed

OH8: Stop wasn’t justified where the video didn’t support the officer’s testimony

Defendant’s stop wasn’t justified where the video didn’t support the officer’s testimony. City of Middleburg Heights v. Wojciechowski, 2015-Ohio-3879, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3758 (8th Dist. September 24, 2015). It was reasonable to stop defendant’s car on a shots fired … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on OH8: Stop wasn’t justified where the video didn’t support the officer’s testimony

GA: Consent to search a motel room for a meth lab includes the trash can

Defendant consented to a search during a knock-and-talk of a motel room for a meth lab. A search of a trash can was within the scope of consent. Fontaine v. State, 2015 Ga. App. LEXIS 562 (September 25, 2015). Defendant … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent | Comments Off on GA: Consent to search a motel room for a meth lab includes the trash can

D.Idaho: Dog on scene in 6 minutes meant no “delay”

The dog arrived within six minutes and conducted a free air sniff around the vehicle, all within the time of the original stop so delay [Rodriguez] is not an issue. United States v. McNabb, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 127020 (D.Idaho … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on D.Idaho: Dog on scene in 6 minutes meant no “delay”

D.Utah: Incorporation of affidavit into warrant made it complete

The application for the search warrant listed the statutes of offenses under investigation, but the search warrant did not. The warrant, however, incorporated the application, so the officers knew what they were searching for. “The search warrant here does not … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant requirement | Comments Off on D.Utah: Incorporation of affidavit into warrant made it complete

TX11: College student has REP in dorm room

A college student has a reasonable expectation of privacy in her dorm room from an entry by the police. The fact the resident assistant could look in there wasn’t determinative. State v. Rodriguez, 2015 Tex. App. LEXIS 9972 (Tex. App. … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on TX11: College student has REP in dorm room

SC: Abandoning cell phone at a crime scene is a waiver of REP, even if it’s password protected

Leaving a cell phone at the scene of a crime and making no effort to reclaim it is an abandonment. Even having a passcode on the phone doesn’t overcome abandonment, following People v. Daggs, 133 Cal. App. 4th 361, 34 … Continue reading →

Posted in Abandonment, Cell phones, Inventory, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on SC: Abandoning cell phone at a crime scene is a waiver of REP, even if it’s password protected

KY: Payton’s “reason to believe” the person named in the arrest warrant is home is less than probable cause

Payton’s “reason to believe” the person named in the arrest warrant is home is less than probable cause. This is apparently the majority rule. Barrett v. Commonwealth, 2015 Ky. LEXIS 1859 (September 24, 2015):

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on KY: Payton’s “reason to believe” the person named in the arrest warrant is home is less than probable cause

N.D.Ill.: No REP in the hallway of a U-Haul storage facility from a dog sniff

Defendant did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the hallway of a U-Haul storage facility. Thus, a dog sniff there was probable cause for a search warrant for the storage unit. United States v. Flores, 2015 U.S. Dist. … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on N.D.Ill.: No REP in the hallway of a U-Haul storage facility from a dog sniff

ID: Exclusionary rule doesn’t apply to DL suspension

The exclusionary rule doesn’t apply to administrative license suspensions for driving under the influence. Bobeck v. Idaho Transp. Dep’t, 2015 Ida. App. LEXIS 86 (September 24, 2015). Defendant was stopped for speeding, but he couldn’t answer basic question about much … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule, Reasonable suspicion, Roadblocks | Comments Off on ID: Exclusionary rule doesn’t apply to DL suspension

Two on qualified immunity

Officers arrived at the scene of a shooting and immediately called for EMS, and called twice more before they finally arrived. Plaintiffs’ quarrel was that they weren’t more emphatic about the degree of injury. “A reasonable officer in Piotrowski’s or … Continue reading →

Posted in Qualified immunity | Comments Off on Two on qualified immunity

N.D.Iowa: Anonymous 911 call wasn’t good enough under Florida v. J.L.

This 911 call that defendant was likely with a gun was more like Florida v. J.L. than Naverette v. California, and it lacked indicia of reliability. While it’s a “close case,” the motion to suppress should be granted. “Nothing in … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay | Comments Off on N.D.Iowa: Anonymous 911 call wasn’t good enough under Florida v. J.L.

W.D.Pa.: 71 minutes for consent search of car on PA Turnpike didn’t make it unreasonable per se

Defendant consented in writing to a search of his vehicle but it took 71 minutes before any drugs were found. The length of search alone does not make it unreasonable nor violate the terms of the consent. If he had … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Reasonableness | Comments Off on W.D.Pa.: 71 minutes for consent search of car on PA Turnpike didn’t make it unreasonable per se

NJ goes back to automobile exception and retreats from its 2009 requirement of a telephonic search warrant if at all possible in automobile searches

New Jersey retreats from its 2009 requirement of a telephonic search warrant if at all possible in automobile searches essentially as a failed experiment. Thus, the court goes back to probable cause and exigency and the automobile exception. State v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception | Comments Off on NJ goes back to automobile exception and retreats from its 2009 requirement of a telephonic search warrant if at all possible in automobile searches

MA: Because possession of MJ is a civil infraction, the smell of burnt MJ in a car isn’t probable cause to search the car where there was no showing of need to protect highway safety

“A District Court judge erred in denying the criminal defendant’s pretrial motion to suppress evidence of controlled substances that a police officer discovered after having stopped the defendant’s motor vehicle following the detection of an odor of burnt marijuana coming … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on MA: Because possession of MJ is a civil infraction, the smell of burnt MJ in a car isn’t probable cause to search the car where there was no showing of need to protect highway safety

D.Haw.: Alleged illegal search by “marshals of the Kingdom of Atooi” wasn’t acquiesced in by federal or state officials

A crate of marijuana was searched by “marshals of the Kingdom of Atooi,” a Polynesian kingdom within Hawai’i not otherwise described. Their search was not at insistence or with the acquiescence of the state or federal government, and it could … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Ineffective assistance, Private search | Comments Off on D.Haw.: Alleged illegal search by “marshals of the Kingdom of Atooi” wasn’t acquiesced in by federal or state officials

CA5: Shooting suicidal person in back so he wouldn’t turn was objectively unreasonable; framing him for assault on an officer violates due process

It was objectively unreasonable to shoot a young man with a gun to his own head when his back was to the officers. Plaintiff also made a prima facie due process claim for being framed by the police for assaulting … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force, Police misconduct | Comments Off on CA5: Shooting suicidal person in back so he wouldn’t turn was objectively unreasonable; framing him for assault on an officer violates due process

WaPo: Obama administration explored ways to bypass smartphone encryption

WaPo: Obama administration explored ways to bypass smartphone by Andrea Peterson and Ellen Nakashima: An Obama administration working group has explored four possible approaches tech companies might use that would allow law enforcement to unlock encrypted communications — access that … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Surveillance technology | Comments Off on WaPo: Obama administration explored ways to bypass smartphone encryption

Wall Street Journal Law Blog: Spy Court Recruits Outside Lawyer in Phone-Records Case

Wall Street Journal Law Blog: Spy Court Recruits Outside Lawyer in Phone-Records Case by Joe Palazzolo: The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court occupies a super secure space inside the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, behind a biometric hand-scanner … Continue reading →

Posted in National security | Comments Off on Wall Street Journal Law Blog: Spy Court Recruits Outside Lawyer in Phone-Records Case