Author Archives: Hall

CA6: PC for a cell phone SW shown because it was used in a fraud case; computer search standards applied and satisfied

In a fraud case, probable cause was shown to search a cell phone for both evidence of the fraud and text messages where the co-conspirators were communicating with each other. Nexus was shown because defendant was using his cell phone … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Computer and cloud searches, Nexus, Overbreadth | Comments Off on CA6: PC for a cell phone SW shown because it was used in a fraud case; computer search standards applied and satisfied

CA3: Officers confronted with an unknown call of a screaming woman were not unreasonable in waiting to sort it out, even though it resulted in a delay of getting a woman to the hospital where she died

In a “tragic” case of a young woman dying from lock of oxygen to the brain from an asthma attack, police responded to a 911 call of a “woman screaming” and didn’t know what they had. When they arrived, the … Continue reading →

Posted in Community caretaking function, Qualified immunity, Reasonableness, Seizure | Comments Off on CA3: Officers confronted with an unknown call of a screaming woman were not unreasonable in waiting to sort it out, even though it resulted in a delay of getting a woman to the hospital where she died

E.D.Tex.: Protective sweep was justified just after door opened on knock-and-talk, but court doesn’t even tell us why

Thirteen police came to defendant’s house, and four came on the porch for a knock-and-talk. His wife answered and opened the door three feet. She stepped back and officers entered to conduct a protective sweep. After explaining the reasonable suspicion … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep | Comments Off on E.D.Tex.: Protective sweep was justified just after door opened on knock-and-talk, but court doesn’t even tell us why

Alabama appellate decisions now free; link changed

Because an Alabama search and seizure case came through today, and they are so seldom seen, I went to their website to see if anything had changed, and it has: opinions are now free, and the link on the state … Continue reading →

Posted in Scope of search | Comments Off on Alabama appellate decisions now free; link changed

D.Nev.: FBI internet ruse against USAO advice leads to suppression of entry by deception (R&R adopted)

The USMJ issued her R&R on February 2d, and I posted the next day. Friday, the USDJ adopted the R&R, and the press goes wild, apparently oblivious to the news stories from February 2d. United States v. Phua, 2015 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches, Consent | Comments Off on D.Nev.: FBI internet ruse against USAO advice leads to suppression of entry by deception (R&R adopted)

WaPo: State seizes 11-year-old, arrests his mother after he defends medical marijuana during a school presentation

WaPo: State seizes 11-year-old, arrests his mother after he defends medical marijuana during a school presentation, Radley Balko’s ‘The Watch’ Blog: The boy was defending his mother’s use of a drug that helps her deal with an awful condition.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on WaPo: State seizes 11-year-old, arrests his mother after he defends medical marijuana during a school presentation

WaPo: As police body cameras catch on, a debate surfaces: Who gets to watch?

WaPo: As police body cameras catch on, a debate surfaces: Who gets to watch? by Peter Hermann and Aaron C. Davis:

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on WaPo: As police body cameras catch on, a debate surfaces: Who gets to watch?

MA: While PC for a no-knock warrant wasn’t shown, GFE otherwise applies to no-knock

The affidavit for the search warrant included a no-knock request, but the fact that powder cocaine was sought wasn’t shown to be enough to justify a no-knock. Probable cause of a likelihood of destruction is required under Massachusetts law. Defendant … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Knock and announce | Comments Off on MA: While PC for a no-knock warrant wasn’t shown, GFE otherwise applies to no-knock

NJ: No cause shown to order passenger out of car under state law

Under New Jersey law, the driver can per se be ordered out of the car under Mimms, but not so with the passenger. Here, the trial court’s initial findings didn’t resolve this, and it was previously remanded. After the remand, … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on NJ: No cause shown to order passenger out of car under state law

NPR: Boston Marathon Surveillance Raises Privacy Concerns Long After Bombing

NPR: Boston Marathon Surveillance Raises Privacy Concerns Long After Bombing: Nearly a million people will line the streets to watch the Boston Marathon on Monday, and someone else will be watching them. Bill Ridge with the Boston Police says video … Continue reading →

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on NPR: Boston Marathon Surveillance Raises Privacy Concerns Long After Bombing

E.D.La.: A power co. had standing to challenge overbroad subpoenas at a gov’t audit

A power company stated an injury-in-fact for standing to contest the agency’s action on, inter alia, Fourth Amendment grounds that its request for production of records in an audit constituted a likely Fourth Amendment violation for an overbroad or oppressive … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay, Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters | Comments Off on E.D.La.: A power co. had standing to challenge overbroad subpoenas at a gov’t audit

D.Ariz.: When a SW expires before execution, a new affidavit is not required if timeliness can still be met

The first search warrant in defendant’s child pornography case expired when it wasn’t timely served, so another was sought on the same affidavit. While staleness is always a potential issue, there is no mandatory requirement that a new affidavit be … Continue reading →

Posted in Staleness, Warrant execution | Comments Off on D.Ariz.: When a SW expires before execution, a new affidavit is not required if timeliness can still be met

D.Ariz.: There is standing in a borrowed cell phone; no justification here for search

Defendant’s denial of ownership of a cell phone in his car was not determinative of his standing to challenge its search. Actually, he was loaned the phone because his was broken, and he was legitimately in possession. The question posed … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Reasonable suspicion, Standing | Comments Off on D.Ariz.: There is standing in a borrowed cell phone; no justification here for search

TN: An RV parked off the property but connected by an electrical cord to the house was subject to search under a warrant for the house

To search vehicles under a search warrant for real property, the vehicles must belong to a person named in the warrant to identify the place or things to be searched. Vehicles belonging to visitors are not subject to search under … Continue reading →

Posted in Particularity, Scope of search, Warrant execution | Comments Off on TN: An RV parked off the property but connected by an electrical cord to the house was subject to search under a warrant for the house

PA: Fourth Amendment applies to mental commitment proceedings

The Fourth Amendment applies in mental commitment proceedings, and there must be probable cause for the seizure of the person the state seeks to commit. The fact that the criminal rules don’t apply to these proceedings does not mean that … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Seizure | Comments Off on PA: Fourth Amendment applies to mental commitment proceedings

HuffPo: D.C. Mayor Doesn’t Want You To See Police Body Camera Footage

HuffPo: D.C. Mayor Doesn’t Want You To See Police Body Camera Footage by Jason Cherkis: After this month’s police killing of Walter Scott in South Carolina, Americans were treated to another lesson in how police departments can spin such incidents. … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on HuffPo: D.C. Mayor Doesn’t Want You To See Police Body Camera Footage

NPR: Seattle Police Body Camera Program Highlights Unexpected Issues

NPR: Seattle Police Body Camera Program Highlights Unexpected Issues: NPR’s Audie Cornish talks with the Seattle Police Department’s Chief Operating Officer Mike Wagers about the challenges that bodycams and dashcams present to the department. In addition to figuring out how … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on NPR: Seattle Police Body Camera Program Highlights Unexpected Issues

EFF: Police Must Respect the Right of Citizens to Record Them

EFF: Police Must Respect the Right of Citizens to Record Them by Sophia Cope: “I’m asking all the citizens of North Charleston to continue taping.” That is what Councilwoman Dorothy Williams said in response to the shooting death of Walter … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on EFF: Police Must Respect the Right of Citizens to Record Them

CA9: Injunction against racially profiling Hispanics affirmed as modified

The injunction against the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office for profiling Hispanics is affirmed as modified. Ortega v. Arpaio, 13-16285 (9th Cir. April 15, 2015). The summary from the court follows:

Posted in Racial profiling | Comments Off on CA9: Injunction against racially profiling Hispanics affirmed as modified

Courthouse News Service: Ferguson Police Face Scrutiny of 8th Circuit

Courthouse News Service: Ferguson Police Face Scrutiny of 8th Circuit by Joe Harris: ST. LOUIS (CN) – A black man who claims he was charged with destruction of police property for bleeding on Ferguson police officers’ uniforms during a brutal … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Excessive force | Comments Off on Courthouse News Service: Ferguson Police Face Scrutiny of 8th Circuit