Author Archives: Hall

The Hill: Google: Government creating ‘distractions’ in email privacy debate

The Hill: Google: Government creating ‘distractions’ in email privacy debate by Mario Trujillo: Google and other tech advocates accused federal agencies Wednesday of creating “distractions” during the years-long debate on updating an email privacy law from the 1980s. “We certainly … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail, ECPA | Comments Off on The Hill: Google: Government creating ‘distractions’ in email privacy debate

OH3: Where the drug dog arrived at the scene before the traffic ticket was written, the dog sniff did not extend the stop

Where the drug dog arrived at the scene before the traffic ticket was written, the dog sniff did not extend the stop and was valid. State v. Mote, 2015-Ohio-3715, 2015 Ohio App. LEXIS 3616 (3d Dist. September 14, 2015). A … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Dog sniff, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on OH3: Where the drug dog arrived at the scene before the traffic ticket was written, the dog sniff did not extend the stop

D.S.C.: UnMirandized admission of gun in car created exigent circumstances

It was reasonable for the officer to ask about defendant having a firearm in the car when responding to a 911 call without Mirandizing him under its “public safety exception.” When defendant admitted there was a gun, the officer had … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Ineffective assistance, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on D.S.C.: UnMirandized admission of gun in car created exigent circumstances

CA7: Two 911 calls about a road rage incident led to PC to search defendant’s car

A road rage incident was called into 911 twice by a woman involved who said the other driver was a man blocking her path, beating on her car window and shouting obscenities, and displaying a gun. When police arrived, they … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Informant hearsay, Probable cause | Comments Off on CA7: Two 911 calls about a road rage incident led to PC to search defendant’s car

CA6: If it’s a close case on nexus to a drug dealer’s home, the GFE is good enough for government work

While the proof of nexus to defendant’s house was thin, the USMJ could reasonably draw the inference that defendant’s base of operations for his drug sales was his house. “It is a close question whether Agent Fitch’s affidavit sets forth … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Nexus | Comments Off on CA6: If it’s a close case on nexus to a drug dealer’s home, the GFE is good enough for government work

Slate: Our Inboxes, Ourselves | ECPA in Congress, finally?

Slate: Our Inboxes, Ourselves by Mike Godwin An ancient email privacy law might finally be updated. Congress needs to get it right.

Posted in E-mail, ECPA | Comments Off on Slate: Our Inboxes, Ourselves | ECPA in Congress, finally?

IN: Parent can consent to search of minor child’s bedroom

“As a matter of first impression in Indiana, we hold that it is reasonable under the Fourth Amendment for an officer to rely on the voluntary consent of a minor’s parent to search the minor’s bedroom inside the parent’s home.” … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Arrest or entry on arrest, Reasonableness | Comments Off on IN: Parent can consent to search of minor child’s bedroom

VT: 1:30 am encounter with sleeping def in car in rest area by two officers required reasonable suspicion

Defendant was asleep in his girlfriend’s car in a rest area on I-91 in Vermont at 1 am. A state trooper ran LPNs in the parking lot and saw that the DL of the female owner of the car was … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on VT: 1:30 am encounter with sleeping def in car in rest area by two officers required reasonable suspicion

The Hill: Bill to limit reach of US warrants faces uphill battle in Congress

The Hill: Bill to limit reach of US warrants faces uphill battle in Congress by Mario Trujillo: Congress faces a tough slog to update the email privacy law at the center of Microsoft’s fight against a U.S. warrant mandating that … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail, ECPA | Comments Off on The Hill: Bill to limit reach of US warrants faces uphill battle in Congress

KY declines to suppress parole search where violation of some procedural rule but not the Fourth Amendment

Defendant was subject to a parole search condition, and the search violated some internal policy of the Department of Corrections. It did not, however, violate the Fourth Amendment, and the court holds that the policy violation did not require that … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on KY declines to suppress parole search where violation of some procedural rule but not the Fourth Amendment

CA6: Social media selfie created RS for parole search

Defendant was on supervision for a prior child pornography offense. Police looked to his social media page and found him taking a naked selfie wearing a Santa hat with a camera phone, a violation of the terms of his release. … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CA6: Social media selfie created RS for parole search

AL: 76 year old with prior felonies sentenced to LWOP for 2.2 lbs marijuana

The 76 year old defendant, a prior habitual offender for violent crimes, was sentenced to life without parole for possession of 2.2 pounds of marijuana, the trial court thinking it had no discretion on the sentence. Defense counsel raised a … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on AL: 76 year old with prior felonies sentenced to LWOP for 2.2 lbs marijuana

OH3: A court order issued with PC and otherwise complying with the Fourth Amendment doesn’t have to be called a “search warrant” to be effective

A court ordered GPS device was placed on defendant’s vehicle. His movements watched online and facts the police had learned added up to reasonable suspicion for a stop. [If they had PC for a tracking warrant, why not for the … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on OH3: A court order issued with PC and otherwise complying with the Fourth Amendment doesn’t have to be called a “search warrant” to be effective

CA6: During a long standoff, police sent for coffee and granola bars but no warrant before a sniper killed the suicidal defendant before he could kill himself

Police engaged in a long standoff with a suicidal subject whose only alleged crime was to fire a gun into the woods which he thought were unoccupied. Every window in the house was broken by tear gas canisters, and he … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Emergency / exigency, Excessive force | Comments Off on CA6: During a long standoff, police sent for coffee and granola bars but no warrant before a sniper killed the suicidal defendant before he could kill himself

NJ: “Our view of this testimony is that it represents a profound misunderstanding of the ‘narrow scope of the exigent-circumstance exception’ to the warrant requirement.”

“Our view of this testimony is that it represents a profound misunderstanding of the ‘narrow scope of the exigent-circumstance exception’ to the warrant requirement.” Brown v. State, 2015 N.J. Super. LEXIS 154 (September 11, 2015):

Posted in Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on NJ: “Our view of this testimony is that it represents a profound misunderstanding of the ‘narrow scope of the exigent-circumstance exception’ to the warrant requirement.”

IA: Dispute as to facts doesn’t matter where def’s version supports RS

Even believing the defendant’s version of the facts, there was reasonable suspicion. Therefore, the credibility question doesn’t have to be decided. State v. Gallardo, 2015 Iowa App. LEXIS 803 (September 10, 2015). The only issue on the search here is … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on IA: Dispute as to facts doesn’t matter where def’s version supports RS

ID: Def was arrested twice without a complaint or probable cause for contempt; reversed

Defendant was arrested twice, both times without probable cause or a complaint being filed. For that and other reasons, defendant’s finding of contempt is reversed. State v. Juarez, 2015 Ida. LEXIS 235 (September 9, 2015):

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Probable cause | Comments Off on ID: Def was arrested twice without a complaint or probable cause for contempt; reversed

CA2: Ordering a person to leave a courthouse is likely not a seizure, but grabbing his collar and forcing him to move is a seizure

Ordering a person to leave a courthouse is likely not a seizure. Grabbing his collar and forcing him to move is a seizure. It is subject to the reasonableness requirement. Salmon v. Blesser, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 16070 (2d Cir. … Continue reading →

Posted in Seizure | Comments Off on CA2: Ordering a person to leave a courthouse is likely not a seizure, but grabbing his collar and forcing him to move is a seizure

NJ: Stashing drugs in another person’s drainpipe shows no REP

Defendant who hid drugs in the drainpipe of a neighbor’s house had no standing to challenge a search of the drainpipe. While evidence at the trial differed, this did not give the defendant the right to reopen the suppression hearing. … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on NJ: Stashing drugs in another person’s drainpipe shows no REP

EFF Urges Appeals Court To Toughen Privacy Protections for Devices at the Border Warrants Should Be Required to Search Cell Phones, Computers

EFF Urges Appeals Court To Toughen Privacy Protections for Devices at the Border Warrants Should Be Required to Search Cell Phones, Computers:

Posted in Border search | Comments Off on EFF Urges Appeals Court To Toughen Privacy Protections for Devices at the Border Warrants Should Be Required to Search Cell Phones, Computers