Author Archives: Hall

IL: Pre-Jardines dog sniff at an apartment door not saved by Davis good faith exception where no case law authorized it at the time

Pre-Jardines dog sniff at an apartment door not saved by Davis good faith exception where no case law authorized it at the time. [Appellee didn’t even file a brief.] People v. Brown, 2015 IL App (1st) 140093, 2015 Ill. App. … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on IL: Pre-Jardines dog sniff at an apartment door not saved by Davis good faith exception where no case law authorized it at the time

ID erroneously puts burden of proof on driver in DL suspension cases to prove stop was not valid

In DL suspensions in Idaho, the burden is on the driver to show a lack of justification for the stop, not on the state to prove that it was valid. “The hearing officer properly concluded that Wernecke failed to prove … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, GPS / Tracking Data, Reasonable suspicion, Standing | Comments Off on ID erroneously puts burden of proof on driver in DL suspension cases to prove stop was not valid

CA9: Continuing pattern of acts made SW affidavit not stale

Defendant was indicted for use of a chemical weapon. His continuing pattern of vandalism of homes of his former customers made the information in the affidavit for the search warrant not stale. A search warrant for his computer was also … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CA9: Continuing pattern of acts made SW affidavit not stale

PA: Things “in regards to alleged sexual misconduct with a fourteen year old female” particular enough for a cell phone SW

“Contrary to Dougalewicz’s assertion, the Search Warrants sufficiently identified and limited the items to be searched and seized as text messages, phone calls and picture mail from and to the Verizon and Sprint phones, ‘in regards to alleged sexual misconduct … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Particularity | Comments Off on PA: Things “in regards to alleged sexual misconduct with a fourteen year old female” particular enough for a cell phone SW

GA joins jurisdictions finding smell of raw marijuana PC

“Based on the foregoing cases, it appears to be widely accepted in numerous jurisdictions that a trained police officer’s detection of the odor of raw marijuana can be the sole basis for the issuance of a search warrant, and we … Continue reading →

Posted in Plain view, feel, smell, Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on GA joins jurisdictions finding smell of raw marijuana PC

The automobile exception turned 90 this month. Thank you, Prohibition

We missed it: The automobile exception turned 90 years old on March 2. Carroll v. United States, 267 U.S. 132 (1925) (7-2). The justification for the search was the Volstead Act (Prohibition) and the statutory authority given to Prohies to … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception | Comments Off on The automobile exception turned 90 this month. Thank you, Prohibition

CA4: Failure to raise search issue on first appeal waived it for appeal after remand

Defendant’s conviction was previously reversed and remanded. On this second appeal, defendant raises a search issue that wasn’t in the first appeal. That issue is barred by the “mandate rule” that it had to be appealed the first time or … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA4: Failure to raise search issue on first appeal waived it for appeal after remand

D.Nev.: No reasonable mistake of law where only case on point says no RS for stop

A Nevada statute proscribes things “upon” the windshield. Air fresheners hanging from the mirror don’t violate the statute. The only Ninth Circuit case involves an almost identical city code provision, and that court held that something hanging from the mirror … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on D.Nev.: No reasonable mistake of law where only case on point says no RS for stop

E.D.Mo.: Not knowing your address while walking “home” in a high crime area and pulling up pants because of likely weight of gun was RS

Walking alone at night in a high crime area [the ‘hood?] and pulling up pants strongly suggested defendant had a gun there in his pants. He was nervously looking at the police car. He said he was going home but … Continue reading →

Posted in Border search, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on E.D.Mo.: Not knowing your address while walking “home” in a high crime area and pulling up pants because of likely weight of gun was RS

S.D.Miss.: Mississippi AG’s office’s subpoena to Google was retaliatory under the First Amendment and overbroad under the Fourth Amendment

The Mississippi AG’s office’s subpoena to Google was retaliatory under the First Amendment and overbroad under the Fourth Amendment. Google, Inc. v. Hood, 3:14cv981-HTW-LRA (S.D. Miss. March 27, 2015):

Posted in Subpoenas / Nat'l Security Letters | Comments Off on S.D.Miss.: Mississippi AG’s office’s subpoena to Google was retaliatory under the First Amendment and overbroad under the Fourth Amendment

ACLU Press Release: ACLU, Portland Police Reach Settlement in Filming Case

ACLU, Portland Police Reach Settlement in Filming Case: PORTLAND – The ACLU of Maine and counsel for Portland Police Officer Benjamin Noyes have reached a settlement in a lawsuit brought on behalf of a Bar Harbor couple who were arrested … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on ACLU Press Release: ACLU, Portland Police Reach Settlement in Filming Case

SCOTUS per curiam: Grady v. North Carolina: Satellite based monitoring of sex offenders implicates the Fourth Amendment; reversed for reconsideration under Jones

North Carolina’s satellite based monitoring (SBM) of sex offenders is designed to effect a government search of the location of sex offenders under Jones. It matters not that it is in the context of a civil case. The state court … Continue reading →

Posted in GPS / Tracking Data, SCOTUS | Comments Off on SCOTUS per curiam: Grady v. North Carolina: Satellite based monitoring of sex offenders implicates the Fourth Amendment; reversed for reconsideration under Jones

KS: Davis GFE applied to a blood draw process valid at time but later held unconstitutional

Defendant was involved in a head-on accident and was unconscious at the hospital when his blood was drawn. The good faith exception to the exclusionary rule applies because, at the time of the blood draw, it was lawful under state … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Reasonableness, Seizure | Comments Off on KS: Davis GFE applied to a blood draw process valid at time but later held unconstitutional

GA: Implied consent rejected in Georgia under McNeely; actual consent is required.

Implied consent rejected in Georgia under McNeely. Actual consent is required. “Nevertheless, sister states have considered statutory implied consent as an exception to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement in the wake of McNeely, and have reached varying conclusions as to … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on GA: Implied consent rejected in Georgia under McNeely; actual consent is required.

CA5: Texas deer breeding industry is “closely regulated”

Based on prior case law, “the provisions regulating the [Texas] deer breeder industry are sufficiently ‘extensive’ to place that activity ‘squarely within the class of industries to which Burger applies.’” Therefore, it was a closely regulated industry, and the administrative … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Burden of proof, Consent | Comments Off on CA5: Texas deer breeding industry is “closely regulated”

upworthy: Rarely does the president invite someone to the White House to criticize a 44-year-old policy.

upworthy: Rarely does the president invite someone to the White House to criticize a 44-year-old policy by Parker Molloy: “The way we treat nonviolent drug crimes is problematic, and from a fiscal perspective, it’s breaking the bank.” “It’s draconian, and … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on upworthy: Rarely does the president invite someone to the White House to criticize a 44-year-old policy.

AP Exclusive: Before leak, NSA mulled ending phone program

AP Exclusive: Before leak, NSA mulled ending phone program by Ken Dilanian: WASHINGTON — The National Security Agency considered abandoning its secret program to collect and store American calling records in the months before leaker Edward Snowden revealed the practice, … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on AP Exclusive: Before leak, NSA mulled ending phone program

E.D.Mo.: Having def roll up sleeves to photograph his tattoos at time of arrest was reasonable

Officers investigating child pornography found an outstanding arrest warrant for defendant, so they went and executed it first and did a search incident of the person. They also got a search warrant. They seized a cell phone and got a … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on E.D.Mo.: Having def roll up sleeves to photograph his tattoos at time of arrest was reasonable

CA7: Parole search permitted of gym bag left in cousin’s car when defendant wasn’t present

Defendant was on parole and suspected of being involved in a shooting. He left a gym bag in his cousin’s car. The parole search condition permitted the search of his gym bag even though he wasn’t present at the time. … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA7: Parole search permitted of gym bag left in cousin’s car when defendant wasn’t present

CA7: Inmate forced to wear a see-through jumpsuit for prison transfer stated 8th Amd. claim but not 4th

Plaintiff inmate was forced to wear a see-through jumpsuit, and he stated an Eighth Amendment claim, but not one under the Fourth Amendment. He couldn’t comply with PLRA. “We reverse and remand for further proceedings. King’s transfer to the state … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Strip search | Comments Off on CA7: Inmate forced to wear a see-through jumpsuit for prison transfer stated 8th Amd. claim but not 4th