Author Archives: Hall

Today is the 255th anniversary of the “Writs of Assistance Case” and the 13th anniversary of this blog

See one of the prior posts on Paxton’s case, the original Writs of Assistance case, argued today in 1761. John Adams credited James Otis’s argument, which he witnessed and attempted to transcribe, as helping foment the Revolution and led directly … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Today is the 255th anniversary of the “Writs of Assistance Case” and the 13th anniversary of this blog

GA: Bailee of car could consent to search; Randolph on shopping for consent limited to homes

Defendant loaned her car to her pastor, and that was a bailment that permitted him to consent to a search. Defendant refused consent, and the court, likely in dicta but maybe not because it’s not central to the case, limits … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Excessive force | Comments Off on GA: Bailee of car could consent to search; Randolph on shopping for consent limited to homes

E.D.Pa.: No First Amd. right to video police on the job in CA3, but excessive force claim goes to trial

There is no First Amendment right to record police on the street doing their job in the Third Circuit. The First Amendment claim has to include expressive conduct, and this isn’t. The plaintiffs’ excessive force and false arrest claims, however, … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on E.D.Pa.: No First Amd. right to video police on the job in CA3, but excessive force claim goes to trial

N.D.Cal.: Searching a Bible during a house drug search was reasonable in case it was hollowed out

Searching a Bible during a house drug search was reasonable in case it was hollowed out. A page was dog eared and noted as potentially relevant to the case. Opening the Bible was reasonable under the circumstance. The case starts … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay, Scope of search | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Searching a Bible during a house drug search was reasonable in case it was hollowed out

N.D.Ga.: Failure to swear affiant doesn’t void SW; GFE applies despite magistrate’s mere alleged cursory review

The issuing magistrate’s failure to swear the affiant officer is a judicial failure, not a law enforcement failure, and it doesn’t void the warrant, and there was probable cause. Also, the magistrate’s apparently cursory review of the affidavit still made … Continue reading →

Posted in Neutral and detached magistrate, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Failure to swear affiant doesn’t void SW; GFE applies despite magistrate’s mere alleged cursory review

D.Ore.: Fair inference shown in affidavit that cell phone used in drug trafficking for its SW

The affidavit for the cell phone search warrant provides at least a fair probability of a connection between defendant’s cell phone and his drug activity. “Many, if not most, people who use cell phones with storage capabilities keep important information … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Franks doctrine, Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on D.Ore.: Fair inference shown in affidavit that cell phone used in drug trafficking for its SW

CA5: Consent valid despite language barrier; could have been just giving in to the inevitable

The USMJ’s finding was that the officer obtaining defendant’s consent was professional and not overbearing. Yes, there was a language barrier, but there was a Spanish consent form. And, despite the language barrier, defendant could understand. Knowledge that drugs would … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA5: Consent valid despite language barrier; could have been just giving in to the inevitable

WaPo: Court: No First Amendment right to videorecord police unless you are challenging the police at the time

WaPo: Court: No First Amendment right to videorecord police unless you are challenging the police at the time by Eugene Volokh:

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on WaPo: Court: No First Amendment right to videorecord police unless you are challenging the police at the time

CA5: Search issue reserved in conditional plea is a limitation, and issues not specified are abandoned

Defendant’s conditional plea reserved “the issue of the validity of the search warrant,” and it limits the appeal. Thus, issues of consent and probable cause are outside the issues reserved in the conditional plea and thus abandoned. United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Standards of review | Comments Off on CA5: Search issue reserved in conditional plea is a limitation, and issues not specified are abandoned

N.D.Okla: Material govt’s LEO witnesses to consent were so bad govt retracted their testimony, and search fails

The government realized when they called defendant’s estranged wife near the end of the suppression hearing about the alleged consent search of their house that “As the suppression hearing unfolded over the course of two days, the credibility of certain … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent | Comments Off on N.D.Okla: Material govt’s LEO witnesses to consent were so bad govt retracted their testimony, and search fails

NYTimes: Editorial: The Supreme Court and Police Searches

NYTimes: Editorial: The Supreme Court and Police Searches: Should incriminating evidence be used against a defendant if it was discovered in the course of an illegal police stop? That was the question before the Supreme Court on Monday, the first … Continue reading →

Posted in SCOTUS | Comments Off on NYTimes: Editorial: The Supreme Court and Police Searches

NLJ: In First Arguments Since Scalia’s Death, Two Textbook Cases for the Justice

NLJ: In First Arguments Since Scalia’s Death, Two Textbook Cases for the Justice by Marcia Coyle: On their first day on the bench after the death of Justice Antonin Scalia, eight justices of the U.S. Supreme Court found themselves in … Continue reading →

Posted in SCOTUS | Comments Off on NLJ: In First Arguments Since Scalia’s Death, Two Textbook Cases for the Justice

WaPo: Apple tells Justice Dept. to withdraw demands for help, says its objections are ‘absolutely not’ about marketing

WaPo: Apple tells Justice Dept. to withdraw demands for help, says its objections are ‘absolutely not’ about marketing by Mark Berman: The public dispute between the Justice Department and Apple continued Monday as the tech giant called on the government … Continue reading →

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on WaPo: Apple tells Justice Dept. to withdraw demands for help, says its objections are ‘absolutely not’ about marketing

M.D.Ala.: Motion to withdraw plea for IAC denied; it wasn’t, and this is just a “change of heart”

The court denies defendant’s motion to withdraw his plea for IAC because defense counsel allegedly overlooked a valid motion to suppress, seriously complicated now by the fact it was third party consent of the codefendant. “It is most apparent to … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on M.D.Ala.: Motion to withdraw plea for IAC denied; it wasn’t, and this is just a “change of heart”

ME: Four failed breath tests in 90 min was exigency for warrantless blood draw

The state showed exigent circumstances for a warrantless blood draw. The officer took defendant to a nearby police station where he had after hours access to get a breath sample, but the machine wasn’t working and he didn’t know it. … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on ME: Four failed breath tests in 90 min was exigency for warrantless blood draw

KY: Def’s trailer in the woods was observed from open fields; no crossing of the curtilage

KSP officers received an anonymous tip defendant was manufacturing methamphetamine on his rural property. They went to the address given to find that it was his mother’s house, and he lived down a gravel road in the woods. They went … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Curtilage, Open fields | Comments Off on KY: Def’s trailer in the woods was observed from open fields; no crossing of the curtilage

CO criminal defense lawyer disbarred for seeking warning for client of a search and telling a witness to lie; the witness was wired

A criminal defense lawyer attempted to get a tipoff to the client of an impending search and then he advised a client to lie to the police. The client disposed of marijuana plants which were not found during a search … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CO criminal defense lawyer disbarred for seeking warning for client of a search and telling a witness to lie; the witness was wired

LA4: Custodial arrest for pedestrian offense was unreasonable and violation of statute

The state’s petition for a supervisory writ is denied. Defendant was stopped for a pedestrian offense, and arresting him was unreasonable and a violation of statute. He should have been cited, and the trial court’s suppression order was correct. State … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Qualified immunity, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on LA4: Custodial arrest for pedestrian offense was unreasonable and violation of statute

DC: Sitting in a car looking in your lap isn’t reasonable suspicion of anything

Officers approached defendant sitting in his Jeep at 14th & U in D.C., looking down into his lap. It turned out he was looking at his phone. The police order to get out of the car was without reasonable suspicion … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on DC: Sitting in a car looking in your lap isn’t reasonable suspicion of anything

CA6 sustains suspicionless TN probation searches of all sex offenders in community, reserving Knights question of lack of legitimate probation purpose, such as merely to harass

Tennessee permits suspicionless probation and parole searches, and they searched all sex offenders’ homes in one community just because they wanted to. Under defendant’s mattress they found a computer with pornography on it. The court does not reach the issue … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on CA6 sustains suspicionless TN probation searches of all sex offenders in community, reserving Knights question of lack of legitimate probation purpose, such as merely to harass