Author Archives: Hall

KS decides four cases on implied consent: “refusal to submit” cannot be prosecuted under due process

Punishing withdrawal of implied consent in a suspected DUI case violates due process. “Refusal to submit” cannot be separately prosecuted. Four cases decided Feb. 26th: State v. Ryce, 2016 Kan. LEXIS 107 (Feb. 26, 2016):

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on KS decides four cases on implied consent: “refusal to submit” cannot be prosecuted under due process

N.D.Cal.: Pre-Riley warrantless state search of cell phone was valid, so GFE applies

Defendant’s cell phone was searched without a warrant pre-Riley under California’s Diaz which expressly permitted warrantless cell phone searches. Therefore, that search was valid at the time under the good faith exception. United States v. Williams, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Good faith exception | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Pre-Riley warrantless state search of cell phone was valid, so GFE applies

OR: Even if stop invalid, false name given to officer is attenuated

While the officer at the suppression hearing couldn’t remember the basis for the traffic stop, the crux was that defendant gave a false name when arrested, and that was an independent illegality attenuated from the stop. The false name charge … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation, GPS / Tracking Data | Comments Off on OR: Even if stop invalid, false name given to officer is attenuated

NY: Seizure of bag of clothes at ER lacked any belief of connection to def’s shooting

Defendant came to a hospital ER with a gunshot wound, and the police were called. Defendant’s clothes were put in a clear plastic bag. Without any information about entrance or exit wounds and whether the clothes were evidence of a … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on NY: Seizure of bag of clothes at ER lacked any belief of connection to def’s shooting

CA5: Excessive force ptf has to show how clearly established law was violated; here, they did not

A search for business records was done with force and guns drawn because of officers’ fear of retaliation because the business owner didn’t like the ordinance he was to pay sales taxes under. When police entered, the owner drew his … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Qualified immunity, Warrant execution | Comments Off on CA5: Excessive force ptf has to show how clearly established law was violated; here, they did not

E.D.Mich.: Still a private search even though police were kept informed of what was happening

Defendant’s phone and computer were subjected to a private search, albeit the searcher keeping the police informed what she was doing. She wasn’t a government agent. United States v. McCoy, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 20890 (E.D.Mich. Feb. 22, 2016). The … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Private search, Probable cause | Comments Off on E.D.Mich.: Still a private search even though police were kept informed of what was happening

GA: Absent owner of car called by police consented against driver

Defendant was driving somebody else’s car and was stopped by the police. The police called the owner to get consent to search, and that was binding on the defendant. Also, he wasn’t there at the time. Gomillion v. State, 2016 … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Nexus, Probable cause | Comments Off on GA: Absent owner of car called by police consented against driver

IN: Two untested and uncorroborated informants couldn’t corroborate each other to make PC

Two untested and uncorroborated informants couldn’t corroborate each other to make probable cause. Gerth v. State, 2016 Ind. App. LEXIS 44 (Feb. 18, 2016). Defendant’s stop was consensual. “The question presented in this case is whether a police officer may … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on IN: Two untested and uncorroborated informants couldn’t corroborate each other to make PC

WaPo: Apple says FBI seeks ‘dangerous power,’ files motion opposing court order to help unlock iPhone

WaPo: Apple says FBI seeks ‘dangerous power,’ files motion opposing court order to help unlock iPhone by Mark Berman and Ellen Nakashima:

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on WaPo: Apple says FBI seeks ‘dangerous power,’ files motion opposing court order to help unlock iPhone

Cincinnati Enquirer: Ky. seizure laws under scrutiny by local lawmaker

Cincinnati Enquirer: Ky. seizure laws under scrutiny by local lawmaker by James Pilcher: Kentucky law requires police and sheriff departments to report how much property and cash they seize and keep as the result of criminal investigations. But an Enquirer … Continue reading →

Posted in Forfeiture | Comments Off on Cincinnati Enquirer: Ky. seizure laws under scrutiny by local lawmaker

NYTimes: The Apple Case Will Grope Its Way Into Your Future

NYTimes: The Apple Case Will Grope Its Way Into Your Future by Farhad Manjoo: If every device can monitor you, and if they can all be tapped by law enforcement officials under court order, can anyone ever have a truly … Continue reading →

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on NYTimes: The Apple Case Will Grope Its Way Into Your Future

NYTimes: Apple Is Said to Be Trying to Make It Harder to Hack iPhones

NYTimes: Apple Is Said to Be Trying to Make It Harder to Hack iPhones by Matt Apuzzo and Katie Benner:

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on NYTimes: Apple Is Said to Be Trying to Make It Harder to Hack iPhones

CAAF: Consent was withdrawn before seizure, and seizure lacked PC; no GFE for later SW

Defendant orally withdrew his consent before seizure of his computers and again in writing the next day. The seizure violated the Fourth Amendment because there wasn’t probable cause at the time, and that undermines the government’s alternative argument that the … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Good faith exception, Inevitable discovery | Comments Off on CAAF: Consent was withdrawn before seizure, and seizure lacked PC; no GFE for later SW

NY Co.: Overbreadth in email warrant doesn’t require suppression of all emails; third party doctrine should be revamped for the electronic era

The New York eavesdropping statute only applies to communications in transit, not to emails. Despite the overbreadth of the email warrant, the court won’t suppress all the emails. Those that are suppressed have to be returned. The court argues for … Continue reading →

Posted in Overbreadth, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on NY Co.: Overbreadth in email warrant doesn’t require suppression of all emails; third party doctrine should be revamped for the electronic era

ID: A 15 year old runaway on the property is an exigent circumstance

The search of defendant’s shed for a 15 year old runaway was reasonable on exigent circumstances, and there was a no contact order between them. State v. Smith, 2016 Ida. App. LEXIS 20 (Feb. 16, 2016). Defendant moved to suppress … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Emergency / exigency, Independent source | Comments Off on ID: A 15 year old runaway on the property is an exigent circumstance

IL: Warrantless blood draws pre-Neely are valid under GFE

Illinois law before McNeely permitted warrantless blood draws, and pre-McNeely searches would be valid under Davis good faith. People v. Harrison, 2016 IL App (5th) 150048, 2016 Ill. App. LEXIS 73 (Feb. 18, 2016). A 2254 petitioner gets a COA … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Drug or alcohol testing, Good faith exception | Comments Off on IL: Warrantless blood draws pre-Neely are valid under GFE

Boston Globe: Public kept in the dark about BPD’s use of covert cell trackers

Boston Globe: Public kept in the dark about BPD’s use of covert cell trackers by Shawn Musgrave: The Boston Police Department is keeping the public largely in the dark about how it uses covert cellphone trackers — devices that have … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site simulators | Comments Off on Boston Globe: Public kept in the dark about BPD’s use of covert cell trackers

USA Today: U.S. Marshals secretly tracked 6,000 cellphones

USA Today: U.S. Marshals secretly tracked 6,000 cellphones by Brad Heath: Federal marshals have secretly used powerful cellphone surveillance tools to hunt nearly 6,000 suspects throughout the United States, according to newly-disclosed records in which the agency inadvertently identified itself … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site simulators | Comments Off on USA Today: U.S. Marshals secretly tracked 6,000 cellphones

WaPo: Constitutionality of StingRay use by D.C. police is challenged

WaPo: Constitutionality of StingRay use by D.C. police is challenged by Spencer S. Hsu: Public defenders and civil liberties groups are challenging the constitutionality of the first-known use by local police in the nation’s capital of covert cellphone-tracking technology without … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site simulators | Comments Off on WaPo: Constitutionality of StingRay use by D.C. police is challenged

Criminal Law Reporter: Apple, FBI iPhone Fight Reveals Fourth Amendment Flaws

Criminal Law Reporter: Apple, FBI iPhone Fight Reveals Fourth Amendment Flaws by Jessica DeSilva: Apple Inc.’s public refusal to comply with a court order requiring the company to assist the FBI in gaining access into an iPhone belonging to one … Continue reading →

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on Criminal Law Reporter: Apple, FBI iPhone Fight Reveals Fourth Amendment Flaws