Author Archives: Hall

FL1: No standing in disclaimed cell phone seized from own house

Defendant didn’t have standing to contest the seizure of cell phones she expressly disclaimed ownership in just because they were taken out of her house. State v. Fosmire, 2014 Fla. App. LEXIS 5739 (Fla. 1st DCA April 22, 2014).* Defense … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Ineffective assistance, Standing | Comments Off on FL1: No standing in disclaimed cell phone seized from own house

TN: Opening car door of person asleep in car in parking lot was unreasonable

Because Tennessee hasn’t yet recognized a community caretaking search, an officer opening a car door of somebody apparently asleep behind the wheel at night in a parking lot was unreasonable. There was no report of a “person in peril” or … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Probable cause, Standing | Comments Off on TN: Opening car door of person asleep in car in parking lot was unreasonable

IL: Mere arrest doesn’t justify towing and inventory

Defendant was a passenger in a car stopped by the police. The driver was being arrested, and he gave the keys over to the defendant. The defendant had stuff in the trunk. The giving of the keys created standing. Mere … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory | Comments Off on IL: Mere arrest doesn’t justify towing and inventory

NYT: Beleaguered Albuquerque Department Reports Another Fatal Shooting by Police

NYT: Beleaguered Albuquerque Department Reports Another Fatal Shooting by Police by Trip Jennings and Fernanda Santos: An Albuquerque police officer fatally shot a suspected car thief on Monday during a foot chase in which, officials said, the suspect pointed a … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on NYT: Beleaguered Albuquerque Department Reports Another Fatal Shooting by Police

BLT: DOJ Challenges Denial of Search Warrant for Email Account

BLT: DOJ Challenges Denial of Search Warrant for Email Account by Lee Tillman: Federal prosecutors are pushing back against U.S. District Magistrate Judge John Facciola, who says the government has repeatedly filed search warrant applications for electronic information that run … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail, Uncategorized | Comments Off on BLT: DOJ Challenges Denial of Search Warrant for Email Account

Reflections on Navarette: What guards against fictitious police reports? Nothing, really

So, on reflection, what does Navarette do to guard against the fictitious 911 call that somebody was driving erratically to justify a stop? Absolutely nothing. In most all of the prior cases, the officer follows for a little while and … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Uncategorized | Comments Off on Reflections on Navarette: What guards against fictitious police reports? Nothing, really

SCOTUS decides Navarette: RS from a 911 call suggesting drunk driving

Navarette v. California 12–9490 (April 22, 2014). Syllabus: A California Highway Patrol officer stopped the pickup truck occupied by petitioners because it matched the description of a vehicle that a 911 caller had recently reported as having run her off … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Uncategorized | Comments Off on SCOTUS decides Navarette: RS from a 911 call suggesting drunk driving

AZ: GPS on another’s vehicle targeting def as driver gave standing; no GFE where no prior state authority

Officers placed a GPS on another person’s vehicle knowing that defendant would be driving it, and he was the target. That gave him standing. The good faith exception doesn’t apply because there was no binding state precedent that said GPS … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule, Good faith exception, GPS / Tracking Data | Comments Off on AZ: GPS on another’s vehicle targeting def as driver gave standing; no GFE where no prior state authority

N.D.Ill.: Consent by person with apparent authority “trumped” defendant’s remote refusal

A woman answered the door at 10 am in a bathrobe, suggesting she lived there or at least spent the night. Further inquiry showed apparent authority. Her consent “trumped” defendant’s remote refusal. United States v. Terry, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Probable cause | Comments Off on N.D.Ill.: Consent by person with apparent authority “trumped” defendant’s remote refusal

E.D.N.C.: DNA swab a search; taking a second was reasonable here

The taking of DNA by a buccal swab is a search, and here it would be reasonable. While the defendant concedes he was at the scene, he didn’t stipulate the issue away, so the government gets another buccal swab for … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant execution | Comments Off on E.D.N.C.: DNA swab a search; taking a second was reasonable here

SCOTUS cert. grant in Heien v. North Carolina: Can mistake of law provide reasonable suspicion?

SCOTUS cert. grant: Heien v. North Carolina (13-604). ScotusBlog here. Issue: Whether a police officer’s mistake of law can provide the individualized suspicion that the Fourth Amendment requires to justify a traffic stop. Note: This is on the defendant’s petition … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on SCOTUS cert. grant in Heien v. North Carolina: Can mistake of law provide reasonable suspicion?

C-Span: Privacy Laws Related to the Use of Drones

C-Span: Privacy Laws Related to the Use of Drones Jeramie Scott (EPIC) spoke by phone about the privacy issues related to the use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) by law enforcement agencies.

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on C-Span: Privacy Laws Related to the Use of Drones

Des Moines Register: Two-thirds frown on personal, commercial drone use

Des Moines Register: Two-thirds frown on personal, commercial drone use “Nearly two-thirds of people asked in a new Pew Research Center survey say personal and commercial drones have no place in U.S. airspace.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Des Moines Register: Two-thirds frown on personal, commercial drone use

The Atlantic: Eyes Over Compton: How Police Spied on a Whole City

The Atlantic: Eyes Over Compton: How Police Spied on a Whole City by Conor Friedersdorf: A sergeant in the L.A. County Sheriff’s Department compared the experiment to Big Brother, even though he went ahead with it willingly. Is your city … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on The Atlantic: Eyes Over Compton: How Police Spied on a Whole City

KS: Trash pull lacked nexus to house; buying fertilizer not PC for a grow operation

Officers did a trash pull because a person living at the target address bought “perlite soil conditioner and liquid fertilizer from the Green Circle Garden Center.” (They were running LPNs of people buying that stuff.) In the trash bags was … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Motion to suppress, Nexus, Probable cause | Comments Off on KS: Trash pull lacked nexus to house; buying fertilizer not PC for a grow operation

CA11: Stop of wrong car on a BOLO was still with RS, and the search was valid because only stop was argued

Officers received a robbery report at 12:30 am that multiple men in a 2011 white Charger had robbed a man at outside an apartment building. Within minutes and four miles away, they pulled in behind a white Charger which is … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA11: Stop of wrong car on a BOLO was still with RS, and the search was valid because only stop was argued

AOL & LAT: LAPD Apologizes For Tampering With Patrol Car Recording Equipment

LATimes: LAPD apologizes to commission for not alerting it to tampering: “Top Los Angeles police officials Tuesday publicly apologized to their civilian bosses for not promptly alerting them that officers had tampered with recording equipment in patrol cars to avoid … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on AOL & LAT: LAPD Apologizes For Tampering With Patrol Car Recording Equipment

CA6: No standing in a carjacked car; EMS didn’t seize passed out suspect

Defendant had no standing in a stolen car. He carjacked it five days earlier, and he was found unconscious in it sitting at the gas pumps of a convenience store. EMS arrived, and he revived. He wasn’t really “seized” by … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Standing | Comments Off on CA6: No standing in a carjacked car; EMS didn’t seize passed out suspect

M.D.La.: Smell of marijuana on traffic stop justified its continuation

“Corporal Spelying’s continued detention of the defendant to ask him questions regarding his suspended license and his travel itinerary did not violate the Fourth Amendment” because he could smell marijuana immediately into the stop. United States v. Robertson, 2014 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Ineffective assistance, Probable cause | Comments Off on M.D.La.: Smell of marijuana on traffic stop justified its continuation

CT declines to require warrant for closed containers under automobile exception

CT declines to require separate warrant requirement for containers under the automobile exception under its state constitution. Virtually all states are in accord under their state constitutions. State v. Williams, 2014 Conn. LEXIS 104 (April 29, 2014):

Posted in Automobile exception | Comments Off on CT declines to require warrant for closed containers under automobile exception