Author Archives: Hall

Photography is Not a Crime: The Terrorists Have Won in Boston

Photography is Not a Crime: The Terrorists Have Won in Boston by Maya Shaffer: We can win the war on terror today, or we can choose to keep losing it. The success or failure of any terror attack is dependent … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on Photography is Not a Crime: The Terrorists Have Won in Boston

NJ: Surreptitious recording of defendant and counsel in police interview room suppressed

The surreptitious recording of a meeting with defendant and his counsel in a police interview room when defendant turned himself in was suppressed and contrary to clearly established law. It led to discovery of witnesses. The indictment is not dismissed, … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on NJ: Surreptitious recording of defendant and counsel in police interview room suppressed

SC: When responding to a tip of drug activity in the back yard for a knock-and-talk, it’s reasonable to go to the backyard where all the people seemed to be [Update: Rev’d 12/21/16]

Officers got an anonymous tip of drug activity in the backyard at a particular house. They could drive on the street near the house and see people in the backyard. They went to do a knock-and-talk and went to the … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on SC: When responding to a tip of drug activity in the back yard for a knock-and-talk, it’s reasonable to go to the backyard where all the people seemed to be [Update: Rev’d 12/21/16]

NY3: Despite suppressed statement, plenty of evidence supported strip search for drugs

Defendant was in a car stopped for a traffic offense, and the driver got out agitated and crying that the passengers had drugs on them. They consented to searches of their persons and drugs were found. On the way to … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Drug or alcohol testing, Independent source | Comments Off on NY3: Despite suppressed statement, plenty of evidence supported strip search for drugs

TechCrunch: Protecting Users’ Location Data From An Unconstitutional Search

TechCrunch: Protecting Users’ Location Data From An Unconstitutional Search by Eric Gunderson: Location data is highly sensitive. It contains information about where we live, our daily habits and our network of friends. We discover new places to go; avoid traffic … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information | Comments Off on TechCrunch: Protecting Users’ Location Data From An Unconstitutional Search

Politico: The Man Who Foresaw Baltimore: Nearly 40 years ago, the Kerner Commission warned us of all this. We didn’t listen.

Politico: The Man Who Foresaw Baltimore: Nearly 40 years ago, the Kerner Commission warned us of all this. We didn’t listen. by Bruce Western:

Posted in Police misconduct | Comments Off on Politico: The Man Who Foresaw Baltimore: Nearly 40 years ago, the Kerner Commission warned us of all this. We didn’t listen.

NY Times: Why the N.S.A. Isn’t Howling Over Restrictions

NY Times: Why the N.S.A. Isn’t Howling Over Restrictions by Peter Baker and David E. Sanger WASHINGTON — For years after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, even as the National Security Agency fiercely defended its secret efforts to sweep … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on NY Times: Why the N.S.A. Isn’t Howling Over Restrictions

CA9: No prohibition to placing GPS on car at night

A tracking order was issued with probable cause, and there’s no special requirement that a GPS device can’t be placed at night, compared to the nighttime search requirements. United States v. Brock, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 7195 (9th Cir. April … Continue reading →

Posted in GPS / Tracking Data, Plain view, feel, smell, Staleness | Comments Off on CA9: No prohibition to placing GPS on car at night

TX7: Riley applied to cell phone search incident where it came down between trial and appeal

Search incident cannot support a cell phone search under Riley. Riley came down between trial and appeal, so it applies here because the issue was preserved. Carter v. State, 2015 Tex. App. LEXIS 4271 (Tex. App. – Amarillo April 27, … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Informant hearsay, Probable cause, Search incident, Standing | Comments Off on TX7: Riley applied to cell phone search incident where it came down between trial and appeal

WaPo: Justice Dept. will spend $20 million on police body cameras nationwide

WaPo: Justice Dept. will spend $20 million on police body cameras nationwide by Mark Berman: The Department of Justice plans to launch a pilot program aimed at expanding the use of body cameras worn by police officers across the country. … Continue reading →

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on WaPo: Justice Dept. will spend $20 million on police body cameras nationwide

OR: Furtive gesture alone in OR not enough, but here there was more

Defendant was smoking in a car in a subdivision being developed, so it couldn’t be called a high crime area. A citizen informant called in that the case was suspicious, so an officer was dispatched to see. When defendant saw … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on OR: Furtive gesture alone in OR not enough, but here there was more

S.D.Cal.: Parolee executed a “fourth waiver” so only real question was whether there was probable cause to believe he lived in the place searched

Defendant was a California parolee who had executed a “fourth waiver,” and he knew he was subject to a parole search at any time. The only question was whether the officers had probable cause to believe he was living there … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search | Comments Off on S.D.Cal.: Parolee executed a “fourth waiver” so only real question was whether there was probable cause to believe he lived in the place searched

Just Security: USA Freedom and the Surveillance Reform That Almost Was

Just Security: USA Freedom and the Surveillance Reform That Almost Was by Elizabeth Goitein: Committee markups can be a dry affair, an opportunity for political showboating, or both. Yesterday’s markup of the USA Freedom Act in the House Judiciary Committee … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on Just Security: USA Freedom and the Surveillance Reform That Almost Was

ITWorld: House committee approves bill to end NSA phone records program

ITWorld: House committee approves bill to end NSA phone records program by Grant Gross A U.S. Congress committee has overwhelmingly approved legislation designed to stop the bulk collection of U.S. phone records by the National Security Agency. The 25-2 vote … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on ITWorld: House committee approves bill to end NSA phone records program

American Thinker: Homeland Chief: Fourth Amendment ‘Beyond My Competence’

American Thinker: Homeland Chief: Fourth Amendment ‘Beyond My Competence’ by Mark J. Fitzgibbons: Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson, a man with sweeping power to invade the property rights and privacy of every American using judge-less warrants to search and … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on American Thinker: Homeland Chief: Fourth Amendment ‘Beyond My Competence’

ND: Visitor’s purse could be searched on execution of SW for house for drugs

The affidavit for search warrant named defendant’s house but not his name. The probable cause was for drugs. Once inside, there was a woman visiting. Officers could search her purse as a part of the warrant. [The specification of name … Continue reading →

Posted in Scope of search, Warrant execution | Comments Off on ND: Visitor’s purse could be searched on execution of SW for house for drugs

CA4: Denial of consent to enter but admission of meth justified seizure of house to get a SW

Officers came to defendant’s house to do a knock-and-talk about a methamphetamine lab. “Then one of the troopers asked Appellant if he would consent to a search of the home. He refused to consent and informed the troopers they were … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Seizure | Comments Off on CA4: Denial of consent to enter but admission of meth justified seizure of house to get a SW

ND: Dog sniff in condominium hallway was not curtilage

Dog sniff in the common hallway of a condominium is different than Jardines’s porch. There is a much lesser reasonable expectation of privacy there, and the dog sniff was valid. (Among a split of authority.) State v. Williams, 2015 ND … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage | Comments Off on ND: Dog sniff in condominium hallway was not curtilage

Wyo.Law.: Digital Evidence and the Fourth Amendment: United States v. Ganias and Judicial Recognition of the ‘Right to Deletion’

Blake Anthony Klinkner, Digital Evidence and the Fourth Amendment: United States v. Ganias and Judicial Recognition of the ‘Right to Deletion’, 52 Wyo. Law. (April 2015): In United States v. Ganias, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches | Comments Off on Wyo.Law.: Digital Evidence and the Fourth Amendment: United States v. Ganias and Judicial Recognition of the ‘Right to Deletion’

The Atlantic: “Thank God for Cellphone Video Cameras”

The Atlantic: “Thank God for Cellphone Video Cameras” by Robinson Meyer: The vast technological change which has helped make a movement possible.

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on The Atlantic: “Thank God for Cellphone Video Cameras”