Author Archives: Hall

S.D.Ill.: Exigency still applied to entry into house day after a shooting where a possible victim unaccounted for

The day after a shootout, the police find another possible location for gunfire and enter the house under the emergency exception. The entry is reasonable because one person was unaccounted for and it was possible that person was inside. Observations … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on S.D.Ill.: Exigency still applied to entry into house day after a shooting where a possible victim unaccounted for

E.D.Wis.: Motion to suppress decided on police reports alone: only a hunch and no reasonable suspicion

Based on the police reports alone which are provided the court in the defendant’s effort to get an evidentiary hearing, the court denies the evidentiary hearing and then suppresses the search finding that the stop was based on a mere … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on E.D.Wis.: Motion to suppress decided on police reports alone: only a hunch and no reasonable suspicion

MA: Asking def what was in his mouth was a seizure without RS (it was a baggie of crack)

Officers encountered defendant on the street. He mumbled when he talked to them, and they asked what was in his mouth. That became a seizure. “We conclude that a reasonable person would not have felt free to terminate the encounter, … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on MA: Asking def what was in his mouth was a seizure without RS (it was a baggie of crack)

E.D.Ark.: Inevitable discovery applies; def counsel overlooked suppression motion, but it wouldn’t have won

The state conceded that defense counsel’s failure to file a motion to suppress satisfied the performance prong of Strickland. At issue, however, was the prejudice prong, and that failure did not amount to prejudice because the evidence would have been … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on E.D.Ark.: Inevitable discovery applies; def counsel overlooked suppression motion, but it wouldn’t have won

Reuters: Civil liberties groups: Freedom at stake in 2nd Circuit seized hard drive case

Reuters: Civil liberties groups: Freedom at stake in 2nd Circuit seized hard drive case by Alison Frankel:

Posted in Computer and cloud searches | Comments Off on Reuters: Civil liberties groups: Freedom at stake in 2nd Circuit seized hard drive case

Chicago Sun Times: Editorial: Laws need to catch up with drone technology

Chicago Sun Times: Editorial: Laws need to catch up with drone technology: Do we want somebody firing a gun from a drone in Chicago or elsewhere in Illinois, which is precisely what happened recently in Connecticut? That’s just one of … Continue reading →

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on Chicago Sun Times: Editorial: Laws need to catch up with drone technology

MD: DUI arrest supports SI for source

A DUI arrest provides probable cause that evidence of intoxication will be found in the vehicle, so a search incident to arrest is justified. Taylor v. State, 2015 Md. App. LEXIS 102 (July 30, 2015). Officers executing a search warrant … Continue reading →

Posted in Scope of search, Search incident, Warrant execution | Comments Off on MD: DUI arrest supports SI for source

MT: Daily breath testing of persons as a condition of pretrial release for DUI offenses was not per se an unreasonable search

Daily breath testing of persons as a condition of pretrial release for DUI offenses was not per se an unreasonable search. Balanced with the state’s interest in preventing DUIs, it was reasonable. State v. Spady, 2015 MT 218, 2015 Mont. … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on MT: Daily breath testing of persons as a condition of pretrial release for DUI offenses was not per se an unreasonable search

CA4: Even GPS failed to prove a conspiracy, thereby requiring a wiretap

Even GPS tracking is not the end all be all of criminal investigation. GPS was shown to be an inadequate technique to tie together a conspiracy in needing a wiretap. United States v. Eccleston, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 13376 (4th … Continue reading →

Posted in GPS / Tracking Data | Comments Off on CA4: Even GPS failed to prove a conspiracy, thereby requiring a wiretap

D.Md.: Strategic basis for waiving motion to suppress: it improved plea bargain

Defense counsel filed a colorable motion to suppress that here apparently improved defendant’s plea bargaining position. Thus it was reasonable to waive the motion for the plea, and there was no ineffective assistance. Walker v. United States, 2015 U.S. Dist. … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on D.Md.: Strategic basis for waiving motion to suppress: it improved plea bargain

E.D.Mich.: CSLI in mid-2014 was subject to GFE

The government’s warrantless collection of cell site location data in mid-2014 was not clearly contrary to any established law, so the government’s actions were in good faith. The court also follows the fact they were third-party records. United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Cell site location information, Probable cause | Comments Off on E.D.Mich.: CSLI in mid-2014 was subject to GFE

D.Neb.: Body camera video shows defendant’s alleged consent at his door was involuntary

Body camera video shows defendant’s alleged consent at his door was involuntary, and the USMJ’s R&R is rejected. United States v. Rodriguez, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 98292 (D.Neb. July 28, 2015):

Posted in Body cameras, Consent | Comments Off on D.Neb.: Body camera video shows defendant’s alleged consent at his door was involuntary

The Hill: Facial recognition quietly taking hold

The Hill: Facial recognition quietly taking hold By Mario Trujillo: There are no laws that expressly regulate the software.

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on The Hill: Facial recognition quietly taking hold

NPR: A Lawyer’s Advice For Black Men At Traffic Stops: ‘Comply Now, Contest Later’

NPR: A Lawyer’s Advice For Black Men At Traffic Stops: ‘Comply Now, Contest Later’: It’s been nearly a year since a police officer shot and killed Michael Brown, an unarmed African-American 18-year-old, in Ferguson, Mo. Since then, more deadly police … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on NPR: A Lawyer’s Advice For Black Men At Traffic Stops: ‘Comply Now, Contest Later’

NYTimes: Training Officers to Shoot First, and He Will Answer Questions Later

NYTimes: Training Officers to Shoot First, and He Will Answer Questions Later by Matt Apuzzo: When police officers shoot people under questionable circumstances, William J. Lewinski often appears as an expert witness who says they had no choice but to … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on NYTimes: Training Officers to Shoot First, and He Will Answer Questions Later

N.D.Iowa: Gas meter on side wall doesn’t mean side isn’t curtilage as to the police; look in window suppressed

The side wall of a house where the gas meter was was still curtilage. Just because the gas company is invited there doesn’t mean the police are. United States v. Conerd, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 98629 (N.D.Iowa July 28, 2015): … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage | Comments Off on N.D.Iowa: Gas meter on side wall doesn’t mean side isn’t curtilage as to the police; look in window suppressed

AK: Inventory void when conducted as pretext for search incident of driving on suspended DL

On defendant’s arrest for driving on a suspended DL, the officer decided to tow the vehicle and conducted an inventory on the street that started with the area around which he would “lunge, reach, or grasp.” On finding cocaine, the … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Inventory | Comments Off on AK: Inventory void when conducted as pretext for search incident of driving on suspended DL

CO: No REP in a jail call, particularly where there is a recorded warning on the call

Defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his jail calls because he knew that they were recorded. The calls at issue were to “to coerce the victim not to testify” showing consciousness of guilt. People v. Degreat, 2015 COA … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CO: No REP in a jail call, particularly where there is a recorded warning on the call

CA4: Objectively reasonable reliance on NCIC readout supported arrest on an outdated warrant still in system; NCIC’s errors ignored

NCIC showed a warrant was outstanding, and defendant told the officer it was quashed. Yet, it still was in the system. The officer checked various databases from his car computer, and he found nothing that showed that the warrant wasn’t … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception | Comments Off on CA4: Objectively reasonable reliance on NCIC readout supported arrest on an outdated warrant still in system; NCIC’s errors ignored

AK: Emergency exception applied to state trooper’s entry several hours after being called because of the remoteness of the location

This case was a domestic shooting in rural Alaska. Tribal officers were called, and they called for the State Troopers who were far better trained in crime scene preservation and homicide investigation. Their later entry was still under the emergency … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Seizure | Comments Off on AK: Emergency exception applied to state trooper’s entry several hours after being called because of the remoteness of the location