Category Archives: Ineffective assistance

Cal.1: Telling def to keep hands out of pockets and move to sidewalk was not a seizure

Defendant was not detained when officers asked him to keep his hands out of his pockets and to step onto the sidewalk. The encounter did not become a detention until the officers used force to grab defendant’s arm and told … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Reasonable suspicion, Staleness | Comments Off on Cal.1: Telling def to keep hands out of pockets and move to sidewalk was not a seizure

TN: Procedural errors in handling the paperwork of a SW after execution are overlooked if no prejudice

Alleged mishandling of the paperwork on a search warrant for new DNA in a cold case hit could have resulted in a motion to suppress, but it’s not obvious that it would be granted because procedural defects in the return … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on TN: Procedural errors in handling the paperwork of a SW after execution are overlooked if no prejudice

OH4: Isolated unsolicited comment def refused to consent to search was not error and was harmless error at best

An isolated comment volunteered by a witness that defendant refused to consent to a search that was never mentioned again wasn’t error. Even so, the evidence of guilt was overwhelming so it’s harmless. State v. Angus, 2017-Ohio-1100, 2017 Ohio App. … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on OH4: Isolated unsolicited comment def refused to consent to search was not error and was harmless error at best

UT: Defense “counsel was [not] ineffective for not filing a motion to suppress based on an unresolved proposition of law.”

“We cannot conclude that Edgar’s trial counsel was ineffective for not filing a motion to suppress based on an unresolved proposition of law.” State v. Edgar, 2017 UT App 53, 2017 Utah App. LEXIS 53 (March 23, 2017):

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on UT: Defense “counsel was [not] ineffective for not filing a motion to suppress based on an unresolved proposition of law.”

D.Minn.: USMJ recommends Playpen warrant be suppressed

R&R recommends Playpen warrant be suppressed. United States v. Carlson, 16-cr-00317-JRT-FLN (D. Minn. March 23, 2017). Defense counsel wasn’t ineffective for not challenging the particularity of the search warrant in this case. “In our view, the warrant describes the character … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on D.Minn.: USMJ recommends Playpen warrant be suppressed

E.D.Tenn.: Defense counsel’s choice of questions during suppression hearing was a strategy choice

Defense counsel’s handling of the suppression hearing and the questions asked was within the strategy choices of counsel. And, even if defendant had a real point here, he can’t show he was prejudiced by anything that wasn’t put into evidence. … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on E.D.Tenn.: Defense counsel’s choice of questions during suppression hearing was a strategy choice

DE: Heavy foot traffic between a house there is PC as to doesn’t make the other subject to search

Heavy foot traffic between two homes is not indicative of criminal activity even where there is plenty of probable cause as to one. The other home is not guilty by association. State v. Harding, 2017 Del. Super. LEXIS 113 (March … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Probable cause | Comments Off on DE: Heavy foot traffic between a house there is PC as to doesn’t make the other subject to search

N.D.Fla.: No IAC for failure to challenge stop when there was plenty of PC

Officers had a wealth of probable cause from consensually monitored conversations to stop the vehicle defendant was riding in. Therefore, defense counsel couldn’t be ineffective for not making a meritless motion to suppress for lack of PC. United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on N.D.Fla.: No IAC for failure to challenge stop when there was plenty of PC

D.Minn.: Not subpoenaing drug dog’s records not shown to be IAC for lack of prejudice

Defense counsel not subpoenaing the drug dog’s records wasn’t prejudicial where defendant can’t show that the drug dog’s use would be disallowed in the case. “There is no reason to believe that any additional information would have altered the probable … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Ineffective assistance, Informant hearsay | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Not subpoenaing drug dog’s records not shown to be IAC for lack of prejudice

MA: Impoundment unreasonable in purported “high crime” area that was partly residential with other cars already there; Swiss Army knife not an indicator other weapons in car

Defendant was stopped and arrested in a “high crime” area [which apparently didn’t include stripping cars]. The area was partly residential and other cars were parked on the street, too. That alone didn’t make it reasonable to have to impound … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Inventory | Comments Off on MA: Impoundment unreasonable in purported “high crime” area that was partly residential with other cars already there; Swiss Army knife not an indicator other weapons in car

MS: No IAC for not pursuing an obvious scrivener’s error; warrant issued same day it was applied for

The search warrant was clearly issued September 4th. The typo “Aug.” was on some of the papers, but reading the entirety of the paperwork, it was obvious this was only a scrivener’s error. The warrant was issued the same day … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on MS: No IAC for not pursuing an obvious scrivener’s error; warrant issued same day it was applied for

CA9: States court’s rationale for rejecting 4A claim subject to “unreasonable application” clause of § 2254(d)(1) on habeas

On federal habeas, the state court’s determination that defense counsel was reasonable in not filing a motion to suppress was subject to the “unreasonable application” clause of § 2254(d)(1). The state court’s denials were not an unreasonable application of the … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on CA9: States court’s rationale for rejecting 4A claim subject to “unreasonable application” clause of § 2254(d)(1) on habeas

TN: Def’s post-conviction burden is to show that the motion to suppress would have prevailed

On a post-conviction petition that defense counsel was ineffective, the defense has to put on proof to show that there is some reason to believe that the motion to suppress would have been granted if it had been pursued at … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on TN: Def’s post-conviction burden is to show that the motion to suppress would have prevailed

TX11: Smell of MJ from car and def’s person justified search of both

The smell of marijuana coming from a car and then defendant’s person when he got out is probable cause to search both. Defendant said he smoked all the marijuana five hours before the stop. Then he was found chewing it, … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Plain view, feel, smell, Probable cause | Comments Off on TX11: Smell of MJ from car and def’s person justified search of both

GA: Def counsel wasn’t ineffective for not arguing more strenuously an issue raised and rejected

Defendant’s IAC claim here was that defense counsel didn’t argue more vigorously the motion to suppress such that he would have won it it had been better argued. How to argue is “strategy.” In light of his lack of standing, … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on GA: Def counsel wasn’t ineffective for not arguing more strenuously an issue raised and rejected

NY1: Issue of fact on PC precludes SJ of assault and battery claim

An “issue of fact as to probable cause for [an] arrest precludes summary dismissal of [an] assault and battery claim”. Burgos-Lugo v. City of New York, 2017 NY Slip Op 00534, 2017 N.Y. App. Div. LEXIS 536 (Jan. 26, 2017).* … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force, Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on NY1: Issue of fact on PC precludes SJ of assault and battery claim

E.D.Mich.: Squeezing bag of MJ when taking it off def wasn’t unreasonable; it was apparent what it was

Squeezing a baggie of suspected marijuana to sense its feel was not unreasonable, if that is part of defendant’s argument, which isn’t obvious. It was at arms length when seized, and its appearance was marijuana anyway. United States v. Barnes, … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Plain view, feel, smell | Comments Off on E.D.Mich.: Squeezing bag of MJ when taking it off def wasn’t unreasonable; it was apparent what it was

UT: Def counsel failed to provide effective assistance in getting 4A issue before court for resolution

Defense counsel failed to adequately defend the accused on his motion to suppress by not briefing and failing to get it before the court for a hearing, essentially abandoning the client. The issue was left cloudy enough in the record … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance | Comments Off on UT: Def counsel failed to provide effective assistance in getting 4A issue before court for resolution

E.D.Tenn.: When state officers seize and hold property in federal case, return of property under Rule 41(g) not possible

State officers obtained a search warrant for defendant’s property which they held but was being used in a federal prosecution. Rule 41(g) does not enable the defendant to get return of property held by state officials even though there is … Continue reading →

Posted in Ineffective assistance, Rule 41(g) / Return of property | Comments Off on E.D.Tenn.: When state officers seize and hold property in federal case, return of property under Rule 41(g) not possible

CO: No IAC for not challenging P2P search of computer since no REP

Defense counsel was not ineffective for not challenging the search of defendant’s computer via a P2P connection on Limewire that resulted in his child pornography conviction. By going online via Limewire, defendant essentially opened his computer to the outside world, … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches, Ineffective assistance, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Search incident | Comments Off on CO: No IAC for not challenging P2P search of computer since no REP