Author Archives: Hall

NY Times: Now, Anyone Can Buy a Drone. Heaven Help Us

NY Times: Now, Anyone Can Buy a Drone. Heaven Help Us by Nick Wingfield: Pranksters’ antics are forcing public safety officials to look at the air above them, generally thought safe and secure, as a place for potential trouble.

Posted in Drones | Comments Off on NY Times: Now, Anyone Can Buy a Drone. Heaven Help Us

WSJ: How It Felt to Be a ‘Suspicious’ Black Teen

WSJ: How It Felt to Be a ‘Suspicious’ Black Teen by Gary Fields: Essay: Ferguson reminds a Journal reporter of times in his youth when he was singled out by police.

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on WSJ: How It Felt to Be a ‘Suspicious’ Black Teen

D.N.M.: PD SOPs aren’t admissible in criminal excessive force cases

Police department SOPs aren’t admissible in a criminal excessive force case under settled Tenth Circuit case law and several cases in this court. United States v. Rodella, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 164786 (D.N.M. November 20, 2014):

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on D.N.M.: PD SOPs aren’t admissible in criminal excessive force cases

E.D.Va.: The “Interplay Between Burden of Proof and Credibility” in suppression hearings

The “Interplay Between Burden of Proof and Credibility” in suppression hearings. United States v. Mobley, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 164844 (E.D. Va. November 25, 2014). This is a warrantless search and the government has the burden:

Posted in Burden of proof | Comments Off on E.D.Va.: The “Interplay Between Burden of Proof and Credibility” in suppression hearings

CA7: Defense witness on apparent authority completely unbelievable

This district court did not credit defendant’s witness on the question of consent. As for credibility, “The court relied on the officers’ corroborative testimony, Hearnes’s ‘willingness to lie to law enforcement and under oath,’ and Hearnes’s demeanor throughout her testimony, … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Burden of proof, Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA7: Defense witness on apparent authority completely unbelievable

NM: When dealing with attenuation of live witness testimony, the witness has to testify at the hearing

After affirmance and on remand of a granted motion to suppress the state raised a Ceccolini argument that live witness testimony is harder to attenuate [see Treatise § 10.12] via a motion to reconsider. The defense argued law of the … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation | Comments Off on NM: When dealing with attenuation of live witness testimony, the witness has to testify at the hearing

D.Minn.: CP via IP address linked to defendant at time is nexus

An identified IP address as being the source of child pornography tied to defendant by an administrative subpoena showing that IP address only at his address during the time in question is nexus for a search warrant. United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on D.Minn.: CP via IP address linked to defendant at time is nexus

WBAL: ACLU alleges police use of Stringray violates 4th Amendment

WBAL: ACLU alleges police use of Stringray violates 4th Amendment by David Collins (with video) The Baltimore Sun: Stringray used to pinpoint suspect’s location by Justin Fenton: ACLU joins Md. federal case over cellphone tracking

Posted in Cell phones, GPS / Tracking Data | Comments Off on WBAL: ACLU alleges police use of Stringray violates 4th Amendment

Bloomberg: How Police Unions Stopped Congress From ‘Militarization’ Reform

Bloomberg: How Police Unions Stopped Congress From ‘Militarization’ Reform: Why even Rand Paul isn’t talking as much about cops with army gear.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Bloomberg: How Police Unions Stopped Congress From ‘Militarization’ Reform

WaPo: Maker of smartphone spying app pleads guilty in federal court

WaPo: Maker of smartphone spying app pleads guilty in federal court by Matt Zapotosky: The maker of a smartphone app once marketed to help catch cheating lovers by listening in on phone calls and tracking locations was ordered Tuesday to … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on WaPo: Maker of smartphone spying app pleads guilty in federal court

CA2: State officers lied about body cavity SW for def’s wife; suppressed as to her but not him; no standing

State officers in Vermont “outrageously” lied to defendant’s wife to get her to submit to a body cavity search for drugs after she’d been detained nearly six hours and was groggy and hanging her head from being handcuffed to a … Continue reading →

Posted in Due process, Standing | Comments Off on CA2: State officers lied about body cavity SW for def’s wife; suppressed as to her but not him; no standing

W.D.N.Y.: Abandonment during an illegal arrest is subject to suppression

In this dropsy case, the court first finds that defendant’s arrest was without probable cause. A bag of pills was found at his feet. No officer saw him drop it, but that’s the inference the government wants to draw. Abandonment … Continue reading →

Posted in Abandonment, Arrest or entry on arrest | Comments Off on W.D.N.Y.: Abandonment during an illegal arrest is subject to suppression

OH4: Difficulty in finding a judge to get a SW at 3 am was exigency for BAC without warrant

Difficulty in getting a search warrant prepared and finding a judge at 3 am was exigency for dispensing with a search warrant in a DUI case because of natural dissipation of BAC. State v. Roar, 2014-Ohio-5214, 2014 Ohio App. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on OH4: Difficulty in finding a judge to get a SW at 3 am was exigency for BAC without warrant

OH3: Where there’s cause for a traffic stop, the ulterior motive to question the passenger about drugs really doesn’t matter

If there is cause for a traffic stop, the ulterior motive to question the passenger about drugs really doesn’t matter. State v. Gartrell, 2014-Ohio-5203, 2014 Ohio App. LEXIS 5044 (3d Dist. November 24, 2014):

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on OH3: Where there’s cause for a traffic stop, the ulterior motive to question the passenger about drugs really doesn’t matter

CA11: A rare reversal of application of the Heck bar to prisoner § 1983 case

The district court erred in applying the Heck bar to plaintiff’s pro se complaint. There is a possibility he can get it to trial without implicating the validity of the conviction. Pritchett v. Farr, 2014 U.S. App. LEXIS 21965 (11th … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens | Comments Off on CA11: A rare reversal of application of the Heck bar to prisoner § 1983 case

CA5: City DPW worker driving pickup in accident he caused could be drug tested

City Public Works Department supervisor was subject to drug testing under city employment manual for an on the job vehicle accident where his pickup truck grazed a tree stump and he was admittedly at fault. The test was about three … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing | Comments Off on CA5: City DPW worker driving pickup in accident he caused could be drug tested

IN: When stop of car is because owner has suspended DL but owner is passenger, stop must end

The officer stopped the car because the owner had a suspended DL. The owner was in the back seat and said who she was and that she was suspended. At that point, there was no justification for asking the driver … Continue reading →

Posted in Independent source, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on IN: When stop of car is because owner has suspended DL but owner is passenger, stop must end

NM: BAC blood draw by SW doesn’t require arrest already have occurred

A BAC blood draw by search warrant does not require the defendant be under arrest first. “[A] constitutionally permissible search of a person’s blood may arise either from an arrest pursuant to the Implied Consent Act or a valid search … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Drug or alcohol testing, Due process | Comments Off on NM: BAC blood draw by SW doesn’t require arrest already have occurred

GA: Loud yelling and cursing at officers conducting a search here constituted crime of obstruction

Defendant was properly convicted of misdemeanor obstruction of an officer for screaming and yelling during execution of a search warrant where the officers tried to get him to stop three times, and finally it took two to deal with him, … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant execution | Comments Off on GA: Loud yelling and cursing at officers conducting a search here constituted crime of obstruction

CIO: NSA privacy director defends agency’s surveillance

CIO: NSA privacy director defends agency’s surveillance by Grant Gross The U.S. National Security Agency’s surveillance programs are legal and under close scrutiny by other parts of the government, the agency’s internal privacy watchdog said Monday in an online Q&A. … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on CIO: NSA privacy director defends agency’s surveillance