Author Archives: Hall

W.D.Ky.: Text messages to 11 year old boy for sex was justification for warrantless seizure of cell phone

The seizure of defendant’s cell phone incident to his arrest was reasonable. Defendant was accused by an 11 year old boy of sexual conduct on Fort Campbell, and the FBI and Army CID investigated and got enough information to have … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Search incident | Comments Off on W.D.Ky.: Text messages to 11 year old boy for sex was justification for warrantless seizure of cell phone

KCCI8: GOP presidential contenders talk social issues in Iowa

KCCI8: GOP presidential contenders talk social issues in Iowa by Steffi Lee: “You’ve got to run somebody who is different. You’ve got to run somebody who says you know what, not only are we the party of the second amendment, … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on KCCI8: GOP presidential contenders talk social issues in Iowa

TX14: Driving slow on low tires in the middle of nowhere justified community caretaking stop

Defendant’s stop was objectively reasonable under the community caretaking function. He was driving 10 in 25 mph zone with seriously deflated tires causing the car to wobble on the highway, and it was in the middle of nowhere. Lollie v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on TX14: Driving slow on low tires in the middle of nowhere justified community caretaking stop

FL4: Parole searches not limited by time of day, but must be reasonable; this one at 5:45 am with 8 officers

Florida case law long has recognized warrantless probation and parole searches on reasonable suspicion, and statute is not required. Here, there wasn’t even a parole condition to submit to parole searches. This search started at 5:45 am and was reasonable, … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search, Reasonableness | Comments Off on FL4: Parole searches not limited by time of day, but must be reasonable; this one at 5:45 am with 8 officers

D.Mont.: 27 minute stop not overlong on these facts; applying Rodriguez

Two days after Rodriguez, the District of Montana applies it finding a 27 minute traffic stop reasonable under the facts of that case. United States v. Iturbe-Gonzalez, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 53536 (D.Mont. April 23, 2015):

Posted in Reasonableness | Comments Off on D.Mont.: 27 minute stop not overlong on these facts; applying Rodriguez

KS declines to apply exclusionary rule to city officer’s extraterritorial arrest

The Kansas Supreme Court refuses in this case to apply the exclusionary rule to an extraterritorial police operation that resulted in defendant’s arrest, understanding why the trial court suppressed. The legislature modified the common law rule of territoriality somewhat, but … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on KS declines to apply exclusionary rule to city officer’s extraterritorial arrest

CA5 en banc: Border Patrol agent’s shooting of unarmed teenager across border gets qualified immunity

On en banc review, the panel decision is reinstated. The U.S. government has sovereign immunity for the shooting death of an armed Mexican teenager standing in Mexico shot from the U.S. at Ciudad Juarez, across the border from El Paso. … Continue reading →

Posted in Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA5 en banc: Border Patrol agent’s shooting of unarmed teenager across border gets qualified immunity

E.D.N.C.: Court doesn’t credit that officer smelled marijuana

Court doesn’t credit that officer smelled marijuana and suppresses search for lack of probable cause to search the person. Video of stop and car search was instrumental. United States v. Price, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 52734 (E.D. N.C. April 22, … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Probable cause | Comments Off on E.D.N.C.: Court doesn’t credit that officer smelled marijuana

PA: Hot pursuit of a drug dealer to his door permitted warrantless entry when door answered

Officers observed defendant involved in a drug deal and then pursued him to his house and knocked and then entered on answer. This was not a police created exigency. The court engages in a lengthy state constitutional and historical review … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on PA: Hot pursuit of a drug dealer to his door permitted warrantless entry when door answered

Treatise on sale until 4/26

Lexis Bookstore is having a sale through Sunday, but you probably have to ask them because it’s really for titles over $500. From the publisher: Search and Seizure, Fifth Edition – List $473, Your Price $402 A Savings of $70 … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Treatise on sale until 4/26

TX2: Defense argument at “Catch-22”: If he lived there, arrest warrant good enough to enter; if not, other person consented

Defendant’s argument about the place entered being his home was a “Catch-22” for him. If he lived there, the arrest warrant authorized entry to get him, and the plain view was valid. If he didn’t, the other occupant had authority … Continue reading →

Posted in Apparent authority, Arrest or entry on arrest | Comments Off on TX2: Defense argument at “Catch-22”: If he lived there, arrest warrant good enough to enter; if not, other person consented

Marshall Project: Why Cops Aren’t Ready for Their Close-Up

Marshall Project: Why Cops Aren’t Ready for Their Close-Up by Alysia Santo: A police officer makes the case for keeping your distance. In March, State Rep. Jason Villalba (R-Texas), filed a bill that would have made it a misdemeanor for … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Marshall Project: Why Cops Aren’t Ready for Their Close-Up

SCOTUSBlog: Argument preview: Pre-trial detainees and excessive force in jail

SCOTUSBlog: Argument preview: Pre-trial detainees and excessive force in jail by Richard M. Re: Kingsley v. Hendrickson will be the Court’s next word on the law of excessive force. The case focuses on the relatively narrow question of what should … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on SCOTUSBlog: Argument preview: Pre-trial detainees and excessive force in jail

W.D.Mo.: Officer’s subjective belief of “reasonable mistake of law” irrelevant under Heien

The stop was based on a municipal ordinance that prohibited obstructions “upon” the windshield or windows. The government relied on reasonable mistake of law under Heien v. North Carolina, but the court disagrees. An air freshener was not “upon” and … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonableness | Comments Off on W.D.Mo.: Officer’s subjective belief of “reasonable mistake of law” irrelevant under Heien

NJ: Codefendant’s appeal not law of the case; parties get to argue their own cases

The decision in a co-defendant’s separate appeal on a search and seizure question is not “law of the case” as to another defendant’s appeal. The law of the case doctrine requires the same parties, and it would offend due process … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on NJ: Codefendant’s appeal not law of the case; parties get to argue their own cases

IA: Where owner of car was a woman with a revoked DL, the officer didn’t see it was a man driving until he got to the driver’s window

The officer ran the LPN of the vehicle in front of him, and the owner, a woman, came back with a revoked DL. He stopped the car. When he got to the driver’s door, he saw a man, and then … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on IA: Where owner of car was a woman with a revoked DL, the officer didn’t see it was a man driving until he got to the driver’s window

D.Md.: A cell phone found on a drug dealer is virtually per se probable cause there is evidence to be found on it; it’s a “tool of the trade”

A cell phone found on a drug dealer is virtually per se probable cause there is evidence to be found on it. Thus, there was PC for a warrant and nexus to the crime. United States v. Fisher, 2015 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Nexus | Comments Off on D.Md.: A cell phone found on a drug dealer is virtually per se probable cause there is evidence to be found on it; it’s a “tool of the trade”

WaPo: In Fourth Amendment cases, it’s a toss-up

WaPo: In Fourth Amendment cases, it’s a toss-up by Orin Kerr: A lot of people think that today’s Supreme Court is conservative and pro-government in Fourth Amendment cases. It can be hard to analyze those views because they often hinge … Continue reading →

Posted in SCOTUS | Comments Off on WaPo: In Fourth Amendment cases, it’s a toss-up

Columbus Dispatch: Supreme Court ruling on drug-dog searches should have little effect in Ohio

Columbus Dispatch: Supreme Court ruling on drug-dog searches should have little effect in Ohio by Alan Johnson: Officials with the Ohio State Highway Patrol and Columbus police said they already follow a procedure in which officers must have a reasonable … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff | Comments Off on Columbus Dispatch: Supreme Court ruling on drug-dog searches should have little effect in Ohio

ComputerWorld: The new legislation would extend the telephone records collection section of the law for five years

ComputerWorld: The new legislation would extend the telephone records collection section of the law for five years by Grant Gross: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell introduced a bill that would extend the surveillance provisions of the Patriot Act until 2020, … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on ComputerWorld: The new legislation would extend the telephone records collection section of the law for five years