Author Archives: Hall

Don’t expect much this week

I had five major deadlines in a row. No. 4 was a brief finished at 9:45 last night after two weeks of work in one of the FBI withdrawn hair analysis cases from a 1979 conviction. With our state abstracting … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Don’t expect much this week

CA1: Two computer tech’s searches were private searches; police called after first, but didn’t have enough

Defendant took his computer for repair, and the repair guy encountered pictures of children that made him uncomfortable. He called the police and described them. The officer didn’t think that a crime occurred, and he said so. The computer guy … Continue reading →

Posted in Private search | Comments Off on CA1: Two computer tech’s searches were private searches; police called after first, but didn’t have enough

W.D.Mo.: General description of attacker here was a complete lack of PC for arrest

Defendant was searched incident to arrest for a rape. There, however, was a complete lack of probable cause for his arrest, and the search is suppressed. He was only the same general height and description of the attacker, and he … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Probable cause | Comments Off on W.D.Mo.: General description of attacker here was a complete lack of PC for arrest

FL5: SW in burglary had no nexus, was fatally overbroad, and no GFE

The affidavit for the search warrant in this case completely lacked probable cause by showing a nexus to defendant, 12 other burglaries, and the place to be searched. Moreover, the list of things to be seized was completely without particularity … Continue reading →

Posted in Good faith exception, Nexus, Overbreadth | Comments Off on FL5: SW in burglary had no nexus, was fatally overbroad, and no GFE

NPR: Court Ruling Forces Police In Southern States To Reconsider Use Of Tasers

NPR: Court Ruling Forces Police In Southern States To Reconsider Use Of Tasers by Martin Kaste: The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unexpectedly ruled to limit how officers may use Tasers or other stun guns. In states such as … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on NPR: Court Ruling Forces Police In Southern States To Reconsider Use Of Tasers

WaPo: Radley Balko’s “The Watch” Blog: A new report shows the limits of police body cameras

WaPo: Radley Balko’s “The Watch” Blog: A new report shows the limits of police body cameras Cameras can be a step toward transparency, but it depends on how they’re used.

Posted in Body searches | Comments Off on WaPo: Radley Balko’s “The Watch” Blog: A new report shows the limits of police body cameras

NC: Strip search for drugs in buttocks was based on PC

Officers had probable cause to believe that defendant had drugs secreted on his person. When a search of his clothing produced nothing, officers could then make him remove his clothes to search underneath them. Drugs were hidden in his buttocks. … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Strip search | Comments Off on NC: Strip search for drugs in buttocks was based on PC

techdirt: Prosecutors Argue Cell Site Location Data Is Something Every User Shares With ‘The Rest Of The World’

techdirt: Prosecutors Argue Cell Site Location Data Is Something Every User Shares With ‘The Rest Of The World’ by Tim Cushing: The state of Maryland’s defense of the Baltimore PD’s warrantless use of Stingray devices continues, taking the form of … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information | Comments Off on techdirt: Prosecutors Argue Cell Site Location Data Is Something Every User Shares With ‘The Rest Of The World’

NY3: Nighttime search was justified, and defendant wasn’t even home

Police justified a nighttime search warrant at defendant’s house. He was a suspect in a robbery with a knife to the victim’s throat where the victim was forced into an apartment. In the ensuing struggle, the victim said the suspect … Continue reading →

Posted in Automobile exception, Nighttime search | Comments Off on NY3: Nighttime search was justified, and defendant wasn’t even home

Cal. AG argues exclusionary rule shouldn’t apply in a death case penalty phase; held, not preserved below

Defendant’s car was not on the premises when a warrant was served there, so it was not subject to the search warrant. Defendant denied ownership of the car, but nobody inquired into whether he had a legitimate possessory interest in … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on Cal. AG argues exclusionary rule shouldn’t apply in a death case penalty phase; held, not preserved below

D.Nev.: SWAT team in your house is “custodial” for Miranda purposes

After the LVMPD SWAT team raided defendant’s house and held everybody at gunpoint in zipties, the situation was custodial. The government had no evidence defendant was Mirandized before he made an incriminating statement. [The fact the government argued it wasn’t … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest | Comments Off on D.Nev.: SWAT team in your house is “custodial” for Miranda purposes

ABAJ: Texas police turn into ‘mobile debt collectors’ with license-reader program

ABAJ: Texas police turn into ‘mobile debt collectors’ with license-reader program by Debra Cassens Weiss:

Posted in Surveillance technology | Comments Off on ABAJ: Texas police turn into ‘mobile debt collectors’ with license-reader program

Reason.com: Fourth Amendment Protections for Emails Inch Forward in Congress

Reason.com: Fourth Amendment Protections for Emails Inch Forward in Congress by Scott Shackford: Legislation would require warrants for old communications. There is a big, huge gap in your Fourth Amendment protection against government searches without a warrant that goes all … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail | Comments Off on Reason.com: Fourth Amendment Protections for Emails Inch Forward in Congress

Voice of San Diego: Watchdog Group Urges Sheriff to Tweak New Body Camera Policies

Voice of San Diego: Watchdog Group Urges Sheriff to Tweak New Body Camera Policies by Kelly Davis: When should an officer be allowed to review body camera footage? Before writing an incident report or after?

Posted in Body cameras | Comments Off on Voice of San Diego: Watchdog Group Urges Sheriff to Tweak New Body Camera Policies

WaPo: Future of the exclusionary rule? Preview of Utah v. Strieff

WaPo: Preview of Utah v. Strieff by Orin Kerr: SCOTUSblog has posted a preview I authored about Utah v. Strieff, a Fourth Amendment case on the scope of the exclusionary rule. Here’s the introduction:

Posted in Exclusionary rule, SCOTUS | Comments Off on WaPo: Future of the exclusionary rule? Preview of Utah v. Strieff

CA6: Judicial immunity against false arrest damages case for judge ordering confinement for non-payment of fines

A municipal judge and clerk were absolutely immune from a damages claim for false arrest under § 1983 where the judge ordered the defendant to jail for nonpayment of fines. Even if wrong, they are judicial acts entitled to immunity. … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens | Comments Off on CA6: Judicial immunity against false arrest damages case for judge ordering confinement for non-payment of fines

E.D.Mich.: “I know what you’re looking for, and all I have is a little weed” is reasonable suspicion

Officers in a “semi-marked vehicle” saw defendant on a street corner, and pulled up and stopped and asked him in a conversational tone what he was doing. “Defendant responded that he had just left the liquor store, that he already … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on E.D.Mich.: “I know what you’re looking for, and all I have is a little weed” is reasonable suspicion

CA3: Throwing three bags over a fence and walking away was an abandonment

Police wanted to talk to defendant in a child pornography investigation, and they learned he was at a storage unit he rented. When defendant saw the police, he threw three bags (“tote bag, a zippered duffel bag, and a wheeled … Continue reading →

Posted in Abandonment, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on CA3: Throwing three bags over a fence and walking away was an abandonment

D.N.M.: While affiant wasn’t sworn, other witnesses were in testifying on application

Defendant consented to a search after being told of the right to refuse. Officers also sought a search warrant for a safe from a tribal judge, and the affiant wasn’t sworn to. Additional testimony was, however. The consent saves the … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Good faith exception, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on D.N.M.: While affiant wasn’t sworn, other witnesses were in testifying on application

W.D.Wash.: The govt didn’t violate the 4A by hacking into a child porn server and running it for two weeks, forwarding all user info to another govt computer

The government took over a child pornography website in Washington state and ran it for two weeks via a Title III warrant from a USMJ in the Eastern District of Virginia. They sent all information of visitors to that website … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches, F.R.Crim.P. 41, Overbreadth | Comments Off on W.D.Wash.: The govt didn’t violate the 4A by hacking into a child porn server and running it for two weeks, forwarding all user info to another govt computer