Author Archives: Hall

Two on reasonable suspicion: CA10 & CA5

“We first analyze each of the factors: (1) Officer Devos’s previous encounter with Mr. Garcia [where he ran and aggressively confronted the officer two weeks earlier], (2) Mr. Garcia’s criminal history [which included a prior armed robbery], (3) Officer Devos’s … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on Two on reasonable suspicion: CA10 & CA5

CA9: Mistaken stop on Automatic License Plate Reader gets no qualified immunity

Plaintiff was subject to an erroneous felony stop because of a hit by an Automatic License Plate Reader. Summary judgment of her § 1983 claim on qualified immunity for false arrest and excessive force was reversed, and the case sent … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Excessive force, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA9: Mistaken stop on Automatic License Plate Reader gets no qualified immunity

Star Tribune: Marine Corps appoints independent attorney to review seized evidence from raid on law offices

Star Tribune: Marine Corps appoints independent attorney to review seized evidence from raid on law offices by Julie Watson: Military criminal investigators raided Marine Corps defense counsel offices at Camp Pendleton, opening files during a 2½-hour search and potentially compromising … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant execution | Comments Off on Star Tribune: Marine Corps appoints independent attorney to review seized evidence from raid on law offices

WaPo: Meet Howard Bowe and Detective Charles Dinwiddie, your latest casualties in the war on drugs

WaPo: Meet Howard Bowe and Detective Charles Dinwiddie, your latest casualties in the war on drugs by Radley Balko: “The way these people were treated has to be judged in the context of a war.” — Former Hallandale Beach, Florida, … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant execution | Comments Off on WaPo: Meet Howard Bowe and Detective Charles Dinwiddie, your latest casualties in the war on drugs

An Alabama dissent in a DUI roadblock case

In Woolen v. State, 2014 Ala. LEXIS 70 (May 9, 2014), Chief Justice Roy Moore dissented from denial of certiorari on a roadblock case (opinion below) that basic standards weren’t complied with:

Posted in Roadblocks | Comments Off on An Alabama dissent in a DUI roadblock case

New Law Review Article: Policing Facts

Policing Facts, Seth W. Stoughton, 88 Tul. L. Rev. 847 (2014). Abstract: The Supreme Court’s understanding of police practices plays a significant role in the development of the constitutional rules that regulate officer conduct. As it approaches the questions of … Continue reading →

Posted in Exclusionary rule | Comments Off on New Law Review Article: Policing Facts

MI: Hot pursuit of suspected robber justified warrantless entry

Police received a call about a cash register till tapping theft or robbery, and defendant was identified as a suspect. He fled into an apartment building, and he was pursued. Police believed he broke into an apartment in flight. The … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency | Comments Off on MI: Hot pursuit of suspected robber justified warrantless entry

NYT: The Polarized Court

NYT: The Polarized Court by Adam Liptak: WASHINGTON — WHEN the Supreme Court issued its latest campaign finance decision last month, the justices lined up in a familiar way. The five appointed by Republican presidents voted for the Republican National … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on NYT: The Polarized Court

CA7: Warrantless entry to seize a mental health patient 9 hrs after Dr’s call wasn’t exigent, but qualified immunity applies

A police entry to seize a person and her guns 9 hours after a doctor’s call she was a danger to herself or others was kind of “exigent,” but nevertheless treated as a violation of the Fourth Amendment. Still, qualified … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Emergency / exigency, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA7: Warrantless entry to seize a mental health patient 9 hrs after Dr’s call wasn’t exigent, but qualified immunity applies

ID: Passing an FST doesn’t negate other PC for DUI arrest

On the totality of circumstances, the officer had probable cause to believe defendant was under the influence, and that can overcome the driver passing an FST. State v. Hunter, 2014 Ida. App. LEXIS 51 (May 6, 2014). An officer doesn’t … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on ID: Passing an FST doesn’t negate other PC for DUI arrest

ND: Officer created exigency didn’t require suppression where there was independent source

Officers created their own exigency by sticking a foot in a motel room door, but the court finds the independent source doctrine saves the search because they already had enough information in the submission for the search warrant independent of … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Independent source | Comments Off on ND: Officer created exigency didn’t require suppression where there was independent source

OH10: Taking and retaining defendant’s DL without reasonable suspicion then running his name for warrants was suppressed

Taking and retaining defendant’s DL without reasonable suspicion then running his name for warrants was suppressed. State v. Westover, 2014-Ohio-1959, 2014 Ohio App. LEXIS 1898 (10th Dist. May 8, 2014): [*P28] We find the running of a warrants check to … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on OH10: Taking and retaining defendant’s DL without reasonable suspicion then running his name for warrants was suppressed

M.D.Ala.: Scrivener’s error in time of issuance of SW is corrected

The time of the warrant of 10:31 pm was clearly a scrivener’s error because it was issued at 9:31 pm. Therefore, the search warrant did not issue after the search began, and the motion to suppress is denied. United States … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Uncategorized, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on M.D.Ala.: Scrivener’s error in time of issuance of SW is corrected

WaPo: Morning Links: DEA launches nationwide synthetic drug sweep

WaPo: Morning Links: DEA launches nationwide synthetic drug sweep by Radley Balko: ● I’ve often seen my reporting co-opted by other publications without credit.* So I try to acknowledge the reporters who originally broke stories that later make national news. … Continue reading →

Posted in Excessive force | Comments Off on WaPo: Morning Links: DEA launches nationwide synthetic drug sweep

N.D.Idaho: SW application is for evidence to be found, not to implicate a target

In a business records search, the question is probable cause to believe evidence will be found, and it isn’t necessary for the search warrant affidavit to implicate a possible target of the search to be valid. United States v. Suarez, … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Scope of search, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on N.D.Idaho: SW application is for evidence to be found, not to implicate a target

PC World: Department of Justice wants expanded permission to hack and search remote computers

PC World: Department of Justice wants expanded permission to hack and search remote computers by Grant Gross: The U.S. Department of Justice wants new authority to hack and search remote computers during investigations, saying the new rules are needed because … Continue reading →

Posted in Computer and cloud searches | Comments Off on PC World: Department of Justice wants expanded permission to hack and search remote computers

SFGate: Magistrate waxes poetic while rejecting Gmail search request by Henry K. Lee

SFGate: Magistrate waxes poetic while rejecting Gmail search request by Henry K. Lee SAN JOSE — A federal magistrate on Friday rejected a bid by prosecutors to search an unidentified target’s Google e-mail account, criticizing the “seize first, search second” … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail, Informational privacy | Comments Off on SFGate: Magistrate waxes poetic while rejecting Gmail search request by Henry K. Lee

BLT: Court: Privacy Outweighs Public Interest in Dispute Over Cell Tracking Records

BLT: Court: Privacy Outweighs Public Interest in Dispute Over Cell Tracking Records by Zoe Tillman: The public doesn’t have a right to information on criminal cases involving warrantless cell phone tracking if the defendant was acquitted or had their case … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Informational privacy | Comments Off on BLT: Court: Privacy Outweighs Public Interest in Dispute Over Cell Tracking Records

Two inventory cases

This was a stop by Texas Tech PD, and defendant’s DL was suspended. Other things indicated drugs or drug usage. Nevertheless, the inventory of the vehicle was conducted in compliance with the department’s inventory policy and it wasn’t shown to … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory | Comments Off on Two inventory cases

AR: Alternative argument on timing of consent not ruled on below, so it’s defaulted

Consent was found against the defendant, and it’s affirmed on appeal because “the record is devoid of any evidence that appellant was coerced into consenting.” Her alternative argument that the consent was obtained after the search was already started was … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Plain view, feel, smell, Protective sweep | Comments Off on AR: Alternative argument on timing of consent not ruled on below, so it’s defaulted