Category Archives: Stop and frisk

MD: A stop and a frisk have separate constitutional justifications; courts must confine Terry to its 4A mooring

This Terry stop failed reasonable suspicion and all tenets of Terry. [Subtext: Police are abusing Terry, and the courts have to control them.] Ames v. State, 2017 Md. App. LEXIS 121 (Feb. 3, 2017) (Moylan, J.) (caution: The Lexis version … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on MD: A stop and a frisk have separate constitutional justifications; courts must confine Terry to its 4A mooring

OH6: Because OH limits minor misdemeanor searches more than the 4A, search of def because of marijuana flakes on shirt was unreasonable

Defendant was a passenger in a vehicle stopped for suspicion the driver had a suspended DL because of a computer check. Defendant was made to get out of the vehicle despite being blind. The officer noted marijuana flakes on his … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, State constitution, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OH6: Because OH limits minor misdemeanor searches more than the 4A, search of def because of marijuana flakes on shirt was unreasonable

OH5: Fire inspector’s violation of city agreement to give notice before inspections warranted his firing

Jeffries complained that he was subjected to arbitrary and invasive fire inspections, and the city agreed to give him prior notice. Lanzer, however, violated that agreement and was fired by the city. “However, as stated above, the City of Louisville … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OH5: Fire inspector’s violation of city agreement to give notice before inspections warranted his firing

MD: Trial court erred in suppressing virtual replay of Wardlow

Officers approached a group of men on the street in a high crime area telling them to stay put and not run. Defendant, however, sprinted away. Two officers were on bikes and caught up to him, and he admitted he … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on MD: Trial court erred in suppressing virtual replay of Wardlow

CA7: RS of drugs in a backpack was justification for frisk for gun; taking key to do a protective sweep of apt before seeking consent was valid on this record

Defendant’s frisk for weapons was justified because there was reasonable suspicion he had drugs in a backpack that had been deposited in an apartment, which defendant lied about going to. Drugs and firearms “go hand in hand,” (See, e.g., United … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on CA7: RS of drugs in a backpack was justification for frisk for gun; taking key to do a protective sweep of apt before seeking consent was valid on this record

CA8: Key fob in pocket, common today, is not RS def was driving a nearby stolen car

A key fob in one’s pocket, common today, is not reasonable suspicion defendant was driving a nearby stolen car. The seizure was suppressed. United States v. Craddock, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 20118 (8th Cir. Nov. 8, 2016):

Posted in Plain view, feel, smell, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on CA8: Key fob in pocket, common today, is not RS def was driving a nearby stolen car

N.D.W.Va.: “Officers are not required to completely confirm reasonable suspicions before they may perform an investigative stop — only to possess a suspicion that is reasonable.”

“Defendant’s identity was not relevant to reasonable suspicion that he committed an assault, since the witnesses who reported the assault did not know his identity and therefore could not report it to Captain Root. Captain Root had only a physical … Continue reading →

Posted in Arrest or entry on arrest, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on N.D.W.Va.: “Officers are not required to completely confirm reasonable suspicions before they may perform an investigative stop — only to possess a suspicion that is reasonable.”

S.D.N.Y.: Coming out of drug house also known for guns was RS

Defendant’s coming out of a drug house was reasonable suspicion for a stop and frisk where it was known that drugs and guns had been seized there just a few months before. United States v. Williams, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: Coming out of drug house also known for guns was RS

N.D.Ga.: Officer was credible on search 9 years ago by admitting what he couldn’t remember

The consent search in this case was nine years before the suppression hearing. The officer’s willingness to admit that which he could not remember made him more credible, and it was expected he couldn’t remember all of it because it … Continue reading →

Posted in Burden of proof, Consent, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Officer was credible on search 9 years ago by admitting what he couldn’t remember

Reason: Trump Calls for More ‘Stop and Frisk’ of Citizens While Stumping for the Black Vote

Reason: Trump Calls for More ‘Stop and Frisk’ of Citizens While Stumping for the Black Vote by Scott Shackford: What Fourth Amendment?

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on Reason: Trump Calls for More ‘Stop and Frisk’ of Citizens While Stumping for the Black Vote

WA: Objective reasonable facts justified frisk of def when his companion was arrested

“This case requires us to decide under what circumstances officers making a lawful arrest may seize a companion of the arrestee in the absence of reasonable suspicion to independently justify a Terry stop of the companion. We hold that where … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonableness, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on WA: Objective reasonable facts justified frisk of def when his companion was arrested

CT: Two police cars converging on def and telling him to stop was a seizure

Two police cars driving at defendant in a Subway parking lot from different directions and stopping him was a stop. And, he was ordered to stop by an officer. State v. Edmonds, 2016 Conn. LEXIS 251 (Sept. 13, 2015) (concur; … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Seizure, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on CT: Two police cars converging on def and telling him to stop was a seizure

VI: Nervousness is not RS; patdown unjustified and no reason shown

Defendant’s stop was admittedly justified, but the detention was without reasonable suspicion of wrongdoing. Mere nervousness isn’t enough, and the officer didn’t articulate more. A patdown was unreasonable. People v. Hodge, 2016 V.I. LEXIS 123 (Aug. 24, 2016). Defendant showed … Continue reading →

Posted in Seizure, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on VI: Nervousness is not RS; patdown unjustified and no reason shown

MD: The length of handcuffing did not turn Terry stop into a de facto arrest

Despite the handcuffs, the detention remained a Terry stop. “Use of handcuffs does not elevate an investigatory detention to an arrest when concern that weapons are present and officer safety provide the bases. Continued use of handcuffs after a frisk … Continue reading →

Posted in Dog sniff, Seizure, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on MD: The length of handcuffing did not turn Terry stop into a de facto arrest

OR: Going into pocket after patdown unreasonable; no articulation of anything being a weapon

Defendant consented to a patdown, and the officer exceeded the scope of the patdown by going into the pocket. He felt something, but he didn’t articulate that it could be a weapon. The officer’s general observations about drug dealers didn’t … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OR: Going into pocket after patdown unreasonable; no articulation of anything being a weapon

E.D.Ky.: Collective knowledge doesn’t require any one of them to know everything they collectively know

There was reasonable suspicion for the stop, which the defense didn’t seriously contest. What they did contest was collective knowledge, and that doctrine does not require that each officer know what the others know. United States v. Johnson, 2016 U.S. … Continue reading →

Posted in Collective knowledge, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on E.D.Ky.: Collective knowledge doesn’t require any one of them to know everything they collectively know

ID: Shoplifting stop didn’t justify a frisk

Defendant was stopped out in the parking lot of a store as an alleged accessory to shoplifting. The stop was with reasonable suspicion, but the frisk for weapons was not. Heroin was found in his pocket, and it is suppressed. … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on ID: Shoplifting stop didn’t justify a frisk

NYLJ: Panel Upholds NYC Measure That Prohibits Biased Policing

NYLJ: Panel Upholds NYC Measure That Prohibits Biased Policing by Andrew Denney: State law does not pre-empt a New York City law prohibiting discriminatory policing that was enacted in 2013 amid concerns about the NYPD’s increased reliance on stop-and-frisk tactics, … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NYLJ: Panel Upholds NYC Measure That Prohibits Biased Policing

NYTimes: Editorial: Policing the Police on Stop-and-Frisk

NYTimes: Editorial: Policing the Police on Stop-and-Frisk: Three years have passed since a Federal District Court ruled that New York City’s stop-and-frisk program violated constitutional prohibitions against unreasonable search and seizure and discriminated against minority citizens, who were disproportionately and … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NYTimes: Editorial: Policing the Police on Stop-and-Frisk

OH2: Patdown unreasonable because it was for drugs not safety

Pat down was unreasonable because officer didn’t have any safety concerns and was looking for drugs. State v. Kinnison, 2016-Ohio-3481, 2016 Ohio App. LEXIS 2337 (2d Dist. June 17, 2016). Defendant was indicted, had a motion to suppress hearing, had … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OH2: Patdown unreasonable because it was for drugs not safety