Author Archives: Hall

PA: Request for ID of two men sitting at a vacant building didn’t rise to a detention

Two men sitting at a vacant building in the daytime, but in an area known for burglaries, could be asked for identification and it written down. It was a mere encounter and not a detention. One defendant’s continued furtive conduct … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on PA: Request for ID of two men sitting at a vacant building didn’t rise to a detention

CA6: Heck bar doesn’t apply to third parties not in prior criminal case

One plaintiff’s complaint over his arrest was Heck barred, but third party Fourth Amendment claims were not. [This came up through a complex procedural issue.] Hayward v. Cleveland Clinic Found., 2014 U.S. App. LEXIS 13802, 2014 FED App. 0157P (6th … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Consent, Drug or alcohol testing, Inventory | Comments Off on CA6: Heck bar doesn’t apply to third parties not in prior criminal case

E.D.Wis.: “‘Reliance on vague, conclusory allegations is insufficient’” to get a hearing on a motion to suppress

“‘Reliance on vague, conclusory allegations is insufficient’” to get a hearing on a motion to suppress. “Defendant correctly notes that the government bears the burden of justifying a warrantless search, but this does not relieve him of his burden of … Continue reading →

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on E.D.Wis.: “‘Reliance on vague, conclusory allegations is insufficient’” to get a hearing on a motion to suppress

GA: Deliberately delaying the computer check during a traffic stop unreasonably extended it

The officer wrote a traffic ticket and then decided to run a computer check, and that unnecessarily prolonged the stop, making it unreasonable. State v. Allen, 2014 Ga. App. LEXIS 538 (July 16, 2014). Monitoring a controlled buy with the … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on GA: Deliberately delaying the computer check during a traffic stop unreasonably extended it

USA Today: Investigation: ATF drug stings targeted minorities

USA Today: Investigation: ATF drug stings targeted minorities by Brad Heath: The nation’s top gun-enforcement agency overwhelmingly targeted racial and ethnic minorities as it expanded its use of controversial drug sting operations, a USA TODAY investigation shows. The Bureau of … Continue reading →

Posted in Police misconduct | Comments Off on USA Today: Investigation: ATF drug stings targeted minorities

The Atlantic: New Surveillance Whistleblower: The NSA Violates the Constitution

The Atlantic: New Surveillance Whistleblower: The NSA Violates the Constitution by Conor Friedersdorf: A former Obama administration official calls attention to unaccountable mass surveillance conducted under a 1981 executive order.

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on The Atlantic: New Surveillance Whistleblower: The NSA Violates the Constitution

NYTimes: Racy Photos Were Often Shared at N.S.A., Snowden Says

NYTimes: Racy Photos Were Often Shared at N.S.A., Snowden Says by Michael S. Schmidt: WASHINGTON — The former National Security Agency contractor Edward J. Snowden said in a wide-ranging interview published on Sunday that the oversight of surveillance programs was … Continue reading →

Posted in FISA | Comments Off on NYTimes: Racy Photos Were Often Shared at N.S.A., Snowden Says

NJ: No violation of “neutral and detached magistrate” requirement where issuing magistrate didn’t remember prior prosecution of one defendant when an ADA

The judge issuing the search warrant here had, over six years earlier, as an ADA prosecuted one of the eight defendants in this case. He didn’t remember the case. When it was brought to his attention, he recused from the … Continue reading →

Posted in Warrant requirement | Comments Off on NJ: No violation of “neutral and detached magistrate” requirement where issuing magistrate didn’t remember prior prosecution of one defendant when an ADA

VI: The question is not whether the driver is guilty of a traffic offense, just whether there is RS

The officer stopped defendant because he swerved, and defendant claimed it was because he was avoiding a pedestrian. The government isn’t required to prove that it was true or not; the question is reasonable suspicion of bad driving, and it … Continue reading →

Posted in Drug or alcohol testing, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on VI: The question is not whether the driver is guilty of a traffic offense, just whether there is RS

S.D.N.Y.: SW for email account can be for all emails, disagreeing with D.D.C.

Disagreeing with a USMJ for the District Court for District of Columbia, a USMJ in the Southern District of New York held that an entire email account can be the subject of a search warrant, not just itemized files. The … Continue reading →

Posted in E-mail, Overbreadth | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: SW for email account can be for all emails, disagreeing with D.D.C.

IA rejects SCOTUS probation and parole search exception on state constitution

On state constitutional grounds, Iowa refuses to follow SCOTUS on probation and parole searches. A search warrant is required without consent. “For the above reasons, we think Cullison remains good law. We decline to overrule it. The United States Supreme … Continue reading →

Posted in Probation / Parole search, State constitution | Comments Off on IA rejects SCOTUS probation and parole search exception on state constitution

AZ: Open door in area known for string of burglaries justified entry

Officers came to defendant’s house looking for somebody else as a suspect because of a significant number of home burglaries in the area. They found a gate, a 120′ driveway, and opened the gate. About 15′ in they noticed that … Continue reading →

Posted in Emergency / exigency, Reasonable suspicion | Comments Off on AZ: Open door in area known for string of burglaries justified entry

N.D.Ga.: Not briefing an argument in a motion to suppress is waiver

There was a hearing on defendant’s motion to suppress. He raised multiple issues. That which were not briefed in the post-hearing brief are deemed abandoned. “Defendant has failed to perfect, delineate the arguments for, or otherwise expound upon the basis … Continue reading →

Posted in Border search, Consent, Motion to suppress | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Not briefing an argument in a motion to suppress is waiver

N.D.Ga.: Buie in the real world; it’s not always clear

The protective sweep in defendant’s small home was not justified by the circumstances, but it did not taint the subsequent consent. United States v. Smallwood, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 96248 (N.D. Ga. June 27, 2014). Interesting discussion of Buie before … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Protective sweep | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: Buie in the real world; it’s not always clear

CA11: Defendant lacked standing on the curtilage of a house he was often a guest in when he was fleeing police and stopped in front yard

Defendant was riding a bicycle on the wrong side of the street, and the police recognized him from prior investigations, so they followed and attempted to stop him. He pedelled faster and went to house and entered a gate to … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage, Ineffective assistance, Probable cause, Standing | Comments Off on CA11: Defendant lacked standing on the curtilage of a house he was often a guest in when he was fleeing police and stopped in front yard

Two large records searches, not overbroad when read with the attachments

Defendant was lawyer involved in a fraud, and the court of appeals finds that his office was “permeated with fraud” such that a broad records search was permitted. Attachment A to the warrant limited discretion, and he contended it was … Continue reading →

Posted in Overbreadth, Particularity | Comments Off on Two large records searches, not overbroad when read with the attachments

SC: Open container conviction wasn’t collateral estoppel to cocaine possession filed in different court from the same stop

Defendant was charged in municipal court with an open container and was convicted after trial. He was also charged in circuit court with crack possession, and the state argued offensive collateral estoppel from losing the prior search claim. The court … Continue reading →

Posted in Motion to suppress | Comments Off on SC: Open container conviction wasn’t collateral estoppel to cocaine possession filed in different court from the same stop

D.Del.: Passenger lacked standing to contest placement of GPS, aside from the fact it was before Jones

Defendant as a passenger lacked standing in the GPS placement on another’s vehicle before Jones, never even having to discuss Davis good faith. United States v. Cabrera, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 96288 (D. Del. July 16, 2014).* Defendant’s overbreadth challenge … Continue reading →

Posted in GPS / Tracking Data, Ineffective assistance, Overbreadth, Particularity | Comments Off on D.Del.: Passenger lacked standing to contest placement of GPS, aside from the fact it was before Jones

OH10: No REP in IP subscriber information under OH Constitution

There is no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP subscriber information under the Ohio Constitution. Other Ohio courts and other state courts have so held. [In fact, no other court disagrees yet.] State v. Fielding, 2014-Ohio-3105, 2014 Ohio App. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Informational privacy, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on OH10: No REP in IP subscriber information under OH Constitution

CA11: No exigency present on a domestic call to justify warrantless entry into home

No reasonable officer could conclude on these facts that there was exigency for a warrantless entry. There was no evidence that actual violence was occurring or threatened. Therefore, qualified immunity was denied. Walters v. Freeman, 2014 U.S. App. LEXIS 13540 … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Emergency / exigency, Qualified immunity | Comments Off on CA11: No exigency present on a domestic call to justify warrantless entry into home