Category Archives: Stop and frisk

MO: “I need to talk to you” is a request not a command

Defendant was not seized by officer who, based on an anonymous tip that defendant was armed, stopped near defendant and walked toward him saying “I need to talk to you.” Defendant backpadeled and reached for his waistband. The officer drew … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on MO: “I need to talk to you” is a request not a command

D.Utah: Defendant was clearly “seized” at the police station; couldn’t even go to bathroom without escort

Defendant was transported to the police station in the caged back of a patrol car and the police had his ID. He was kept incommunicado, denied food and water, and escorted to the bathroom. He was seized, and it was … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on D.Utah: Defendant was clearly “seized” at the police station; couldn’t even go to bathroom without escort

S.D.Fla.: A police officer walking toward you is not necessarily a seizure

Defendant was not seized when a police officer parked in front of him without turning on toplights and walked back. Then defendant fled. United States v. Cameron, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 122726 (S.D. Fla. September 3, 2014):

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on S.D.Fla.: A police officer walking toward you is not necessarily a seizure

TX14: Frisk doesn’t have to stop just because knife was found; officer can keep looking

The officer had reasonable suspicion defendant was involved in an assault and was armed. In the frisk a knife was found. The officer was not obligated to stop with that, and he could continue the frisk. Pills were found, but … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on TX14: Frisk doesn’t have to stop just because knife was found; officer can keep looking

OH6: Reaching only for glove compartment not a “furtive gesture”

Only reaching toward the glove compartment is not a “furtive gesture.” The police secured defendant in the back of a police car and later searched the glove compartment, and it was not a lawful protective frisk of the car under … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OH6: Reaching only for glove compartment not a “furtive gesture”

TX1: Fire scene search of unprotected property months after fire not unlawful

Months after a fire, arson investigators entered defendant’s property again to try to determine the source of the fire. It was not a criminal investigation yet. Significant here was that defendant hadn’t done anything to secure the premises, contrary to … Continue reading →

Posted in Administrative search, Consent, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Stop and frisk, Warrant requirement | Comments Off on TX1: Fire scene search of unprotected property months after fire not unlawful

E.D.Ky.: Ruse to get inside a house didn’t void knock and talk consent

Officers came to defendant’s house to do a knock and talk but used a ruse to get inside: They were looking for a third person with a child support warrant for him. The defendant let them in to check the … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on E.D.Ky.: Ruse to get inside a house didn’t void knock and talk consent

W.D.N.Y.: Not cooperating with an illegal detention under Terry doesn’t add to reasonable suspicion

On night patrol, a Rochester officer and a probation officer decided to stop defendant because he had a paper bag in his hand that conceivably could have had an open container in it. The stop was without reasonable suspicion because … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on W.D.N.Y.: Not cooperating with an illegal detention under Terry doesn’t add to reasonable suspicion

NYTimes: Editorial: Keeping Track: … Stop-and-Frisk

NYTimes: Editorial: Keeping Track: … Stop-and-Frisk:

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NYTimes: Editorial: Keeping Track: … Stop-and-Frisk

Law.com: Police Unions’ Motion Denied in NYC Stop/Frisk

Law.com: Police Unions’ Motion Denied in Stop/Frisk by Andrew Keshner: Southern District Judge Analisa Torres said police unions’ intervenor bids opposing the settlement between New York City and plaintiffs in stop-and-frisk litigation were untimely and the unions had “no significant … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on Law.com: Police Unions’ Motion Denied in NYC Stop/Frisk

IN: Refuses to find any reasonable expectation of privacy in telephone records under state constitution

Defendant didn’t pursue an interlocutory appeal of his suppression motion on telephone records being seized in violation of the state constitution. Therefore, he waived it by objecting at trial. Nevertheless, the court finds that he would lose on the state … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, State constitution, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on IN: Refuses to find any reasonable expectation of privacy in telephone records under state constitution

D.S.D.: Danger not defused, so officer could conduct frisk; it’s “akin to the doctrine of a ‘protective sweep'”

I’ve analogized a frisk of a car authorized under Long as a ‘protective sweep,’ which is usually of a dwelling. Here, a court does too: Officers responded to a use of force report that had been not completely defused. When … Continue reading →

Posted in Protective sweep, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on D.S.D.: Danger not defused, so officer could conduct frisk; it’s “akin to the doctrine of a ‘protective sweep'”

D.Nev.: Effort to show no PC for defendant at the premises only showed a lack of standing

Defendant conflates the probable cause requirement for a search and the standing question. In his effort to show that the government lacked probable cause to connect him to the premises, he succeeded in only showing that he lacked standing to … Continue reading →

Posted in Standing, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on D.Nev.: Effort to show no PC for defendant at the premises only showed a lack of standing

NPR: Top NYPD Cop: Stop-And-Frisk Is Not ‘The Problem Or The Solution’

NPR: Top NYPD Cop: Stop-And-Frisk Is Not ‘The Problem Or The Solution’: It’s been nearly a year since a court ruling curtailed the New York Police Department’s controversial practice known as stop-and-frisk, but NYPD Commissioner William Bratton says the city … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NPR: Top NYPD Cop: Stop-And-Frisk Is Not ‘The Problem Or The Solution’

FL2: Order to truant to empty pockets was a full search that was unreasonable here

While an officer can patdown a truant before putting him in the police car, a full search is unauthorized without probable cause. Order to empty pockets was a full search. R.A.S. v. State, 2014 Fla. App. LEXIS 9575 (Fla. 2d … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on FL2: Order to truant to empty pockets was a full search that was unreasonable here

IN: After express consent, leading officers through the house was implied consent

Defendant first gave express consent and then led them through the house. Defendant’s mother’s consent was also voluntary and she was warned by the consent form that she could refuse the search. Once officers were inside, defendant’s making a “bee … Continue reading →

Posted in Consent, Plain view, feel, smell, Probation / Parole search, Reasonable suspicion, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on IN: After express consent, leading officers through the house was implied consent

OR: Ordering defendant out of his house for an FST was a “stop” and detention as a show of authority

Ordering defendant out of his house for a FST was a “stop” and detention under the state constitution because it was a show of authority. State v. Charles, 263 Or. App. ___, 2014 Ore. App. LEXIS 804 (June 18, 2014). … Continue reading →

Posted in Inventory, Motion to suppress, Particularity, State constitution, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on OR: Ordering defendant out of his house for an FST was a “stop” and detention as a show of authority

NYLJ: Judge Rejects Suit by Police, Upholds Anti-Profiling Law

NYLJ: Judge Rejects Suit by Police, Upholds Anti-Profiling Law: The ruling is a victory for the de Blasio Administration, a defeat for the former Bloomberg Administration, a triumph for civil rights groups and a setback for police unions and law … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NYLJ: Judge Rejects Suit by Police, Upholds Anti-Profiling Law

W.D.Tenn.: Seeing a split of authorities, the court concludes lifting a suspect’s shirt is a search requiring PC

Defendant’s shirt was lifted by the officer to look for a potential weapon. The court finds here that it was without reasonable suspicion. Considering various federal cases from circuit and district courts, there is a split of authority. The court … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Stop and frisk | Comments Off on W.D.Tenn.: Seeing a split of authorities, the court concludes lifting a suspect’s shirt is a search requiring PC

NYLJ: Parties Ask Judge to Resolve Stop/Frisk Motions

NYLJ: Parties Ask Judge to Resolve Stop/Frisk Motions by Mark Hemblett: The parties in the stop-and-frisk litigation have asked Southern District Judge Analisa Torres (See Profile) to resolve motions to intervene by police unions who oppose a settlement between the … Continue reading →

Posted in Stop and frisk | Comments Off on NYLJ: Parties Ask Judge to Resolve Stop/Frisk Motions