Category Archives: Third Party Doctrine

PA: Refusing to submit to BAC blood draw under SW supports obstruction of justice conviction

Refusal to submit to a blood draw search warrant for BAC supports a conviction for obstruction of justice. Commonwealth v. Palchanes, 2019 Pa. Super. LEXIS 1186 (Nov. 27, 2019). The CI’s basis of knowledge and reliability was adequately shown, and … Continue reading →

Posted in Informant hearsay, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine, Warrant execution | Comments Off on PA: Refusing to submit to BAC blood draw under SW supports obstruction of justice conviction

W.D.Wash.: No reasonable expectation of privacy in Bitcoin records

There is no reasonable expectation of privacy in Bitcoin records. Zietzke v. United States, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 204274 (W.D. Wash. Nov. 25, 2019):

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on W.D.Wash.: No reasonable expectation of privacy in Bitcoin records

M.D.Pa.: Bank records can’t be equated with CSLI in detail, and a subpoena is constitutionally sufficient

Defendant’s bank records cannot be equated with CSLI such that a search warrant is required rather than a subpoena. As Carpenter says: “Our decision today is a narrow one. … We do not disturb the application of Smith or Miller … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on M.D.Pa.: Bank records can’t be equated with CSLI in detail, and a subpoena is constitutionally sufficient

OH: On LPN check, car not matching color on registration is enough for a stop to see if it’s stolen

“When an officer encounters a vehicle the whole of which is painted a different color from the color listed in the vehicle-registration records and the officer believes, based on his experience, that the vehicle or its displayed license plates may … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on OH: On LPN check, car not matching color on registration is enough for a stop to see if it’s stolen

OH6: Search claim can’t be raised on post-conviction, but def would lose on merits anyway

Defendant in post-conviction raises seizure of a Western Union document from Kroger. First, that’s defaulted. Second, it’s admissible through the third-party doctrine. State v. Young, 2019-Ohio-3819, 2019 Ohio App. LEXIS 3873 (6th Dist. Sept. 20, 2019).* Defendant’s guilty plea waives … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on OH6: Search claim can’t be raised on post-conviction, but def would lose on merits anyway

CA8: Patel didn’t bar police requesting look at hotel registry in looking for bank robbers; third-party doctrine applies

City of Los Angeles v. Patel didn’t make the police look at a hotel registry a search. Defendants were suspected of bank fraud and aggravated identity theft in printing bogus checks and cashing them. Police went to a motel where … Continue reading →

Posted in Qualified immunity, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA8: Patel didn’t bar police requesting look at hotel registry in looking for bank robbers; third-party doctrine applies

AZ CoA finds REP in IP information under state constitution where 4A would not

While the Fourth Amendment’s third party doctrine does not recognize a reasonable expectation of privacy in IP information, the court concludes that the state constitution does (and it follows several other states rejecting Miller and Smith on some basis). State … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on AZ CoA finds REP in IP information under state constitution where 4A would not

CA1: Police chief’s order to officer to turn over cellphone and home phone records not a constitutional violation under third-party doctrine; chief gets qualified immunity

Plaintiff is a police officer, and the chief ordered production of his cell phone and home phone records in an internal investigation. The chief gets qualified immunity because of the third party doctrine. Those records were obtainable by subpoena from … Continue reading →

Posted in § 1983 / Bivens, Qualified immunity, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA1: Police chief’s order to officer to turn over cellphone and home phone records not a constitutional violation under third-party doctrine; chief gets qualified immunity

Fix Congress First: Federal Government Seizure of President Trump’s New York State Individual Tax Returns is Most Likely a Violation of the Fourth Amendment

Fix Congress First: Federal Government Seizure of President Trump’s New York State Individual Tax Returns is Most Likely a Violation of the Fourth Amendment by Don Suarez, arguing that Carpenter applies: “We hold only that a warrant is required in … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Fix Congress First: Federal Government Seizure of President Trump’s New York State Individual Tax Returns is Most Likely a Violation of the Fourth Amendment

S.D.N.Y.: IP information does not provide anywhere near the “granular” detail that CSLI or GPS information does, so SW not required

IP information does not provide anywhere near the “granular” detail that CSLI or GPS information does, so a search warrant is not required. United States v. Kidd, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 114627 (S.D. N.Y. July 11, 2019) (citing United States … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: IP information does not provide anywhere near the “granular” detail that CSLI or GPS information does, so SW not required

GA: No REP in a police interview room where a call was overheard and recorded

There is no reasonable expectation of privacy in a police interview room. Defendant had been Mirandized and left alone in the room, knowing he was not free to leave, and told he was a suspect in a crime. He made … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on GA: No REP in a police interview room where a call was overheard and recorded

PA: ID made as a result of warrantless search suppressed, but that which was seen before may be testified to

An officer’s identification made wholly as a result of a warrantless search renders that identification tainted and inadmissible. If, however, eyewitness identification of a defendant occurred prior to illegal conduct by law enforcement may be admissible, if based on observations … Continue reading →

Posted in Independent source, Standing, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on PA: ID made as a result of warrantless search suppressed, but that which was seen before may be testified to

Conservative HQ: Obama-Appointed Judge Allows Democrats To Subpoena Trump Business Records [a 2019 political take on the third-party doctrine]; opinion

Conservative HQ: Obama-Appointed Judge Allows Democrats To Subpoena Trump Business Records. In a ruling that should chill the heart of every American who values his Fourth Amendment rights, Obama-appointed DC District Court Judge Amit Mehta has refused to quash a … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Conservative HQ: Obama-Appointed Judge Allows Democrats To Subpoena Trump Business Records [a 2019 political take on the third-party doctrine]; opinion

D.Minn.: Gov’t proved exigency for warrantless cell phone ping

Defendant’s cell phone was pinged based on exigency. Defendant claims that it was false. “However, the salient facts on which Sgt. O’Rourke based his request are clearly borne out by the evidence.” United States v. Andrews, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, Particularity, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on D.Minn.: Gov’t proved exigency for warrantless cell phone ping

Law.com: ‘Carpenter’ Squared: Review and Reconcile State Court Cases Impacted by Landmark SCOTUS Decision

Law.com: ‘Carpenter’ Squared: Review and Reconcile State Court Cases Impacted by Landmark SCOTUS Decision by Peter A. Crusco In his Cyber Crime column, Peter A. Crusco writes: Now that the initial dust raised by ‘Carpenter’ has settled, it is illuminating … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Law.com: ‘Carpenter’ Squared: Review and Reconcile State Court Cases Impacted by Landmark SCOTUS Decision

CA1 again holds that IP information is third party information not governed by Carpenter

First Circuit again holds that IP information is third party information not governed by Carpenter. United States v. Morel, 2019 U.S. App. LEXIS 11457 (1st Cir. Apr. 19, 2019):

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA1 again holds that IP information is third party information not governed by Carpenter

N.D.Ga.: IP information is not governed by Carpenter

IP information is not governed by Carpenter. “Obtaining information from Kik, Sprint, and Comcast did not allow law enforcement to track Defendant Jenkins’s physical location over an extended period. At most, it allowed them a lead in identifying him — … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable suspicion, Rule 41(g) / Return of property, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on N.D.Ga.: IP information is not governed by Carpenter

MO: No REP in third-party communications with Google and Craiglist

Defendant “fails to demonstrate that he had a legitimate expectation of privacy in the communications he voluntarily delivered to unknown third parties using Google and Craigslist.” State v. Demark, 2019 Mo. App. LEXIS 446 (Apr. 2, 2019). The search warrant … Continue reading →

Posted in Probable cause, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on MO: No REP in third-party communications with Google and Craiglist

CA1: SCA emergency request for Kik app customer info didn’t implicate Carpenter concerns

The government used an emergency application for user data from the Kik app after learning that defendant was allegedly sending child pornography to children through it. The information was nowhere near the quality and intrusiveness of the information in Carpenter, … Continue reading →

Posted in Stored Communications Act, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA1: SCA emergency request for Kik app customer info didn’t implicate Carpenter concerns

techdirt: Utah Senate Passes Bill That Would Lock The Government Out Of Warrantless Access To Third Party Records

techdirt: Utah Senate Passes Bill That Would Lock The Government Out Of Warrantless Access To Third Party Records by Tim Cushing: Perhaps no state has unrolled and rolled up a welcome mat set out for a federal guest faster than … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on techdirt: Utah Senate Passes Bill That Would Lock The Government Out Of Warrantless Access To Third Party Records