Category Archives: Third Party Doctrine

S.D.N.Y.: AirBnB can’t block all discovery of customer’s third-party records

In AirBnB’s case against NYC, the city gets discovery of some of AirBnB’s customer records because it is third-party information subject to disclosure at least to determine the extent of an expectation of privacy. AirBnB, Inc. v. City of New … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: AirBnB can’t block all discovery of customer’s third-party records

CA9: While there was no basis for def’s stop, his and his passenger’s flight after stopping was an intervening circumstance

The court agrees that there was no basis for defendant’s traffic stop, but, after defendant stopped the car, his passenger bailed out of the car and ran, and then defendant took off and went another two miles before he was … Continue reading →

Posted in Attenuation, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA9: While there was no basis for def’s stop, his and his passenger’s flight after stopping was an intervening circumstance

D.Ariz.: Carpenter doesn’t change the third-party doctrine as to IP information

Carpenter doesn’t change the third-party doctrine as to IP information. United States v. McCutchin, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 36811 (D. Ariz. Mar. 7, 2019). The affidavits “are somewhat thin,” but this is deferential, not de novo, review, and, while this … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Standards of review, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on D.Ariz.: Carpenter doesn’t change the third-party doctrine as to IP information

D.V.I.: “Premises” includes the curtilage

The premises for a search warrant includes the curtilage, and drugs found hidden outside the house on the curtilage just a few feet from the house were properly seized. United States v. Dowling, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 34956 (D. V.I. … Continue reading →

Posted in Curtilage, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on D.V.I.: “Premises” includes the curtilage

The Federalist Society: Justice Gorsuch, Carpenter, & the Fourth Amendment

The Federalist Society: Justice Gorsuch, Carpenter, & the Fourth Amendment [POLICYbrief] by Ashley Baker:

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on The Federalist Society: Justice Gorsuch, Carpenter, & the Fourth Amendment

W.D.La.: USPS website usage records are third-party records, and def had no REP in them

The government had digital evidence that defendant tracked a package on the USPS. His motion to suppress this third-party evidence is denied. First, anybody could track a package on the USPS website if they had the tracking number, and, second, … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on W.D.La.: USPS website usage records are third-party records, and def had no REP in them

MN law that requires identifying information on renters is third party information and voluntary disclosure doesn’t offend Patel

Defendant rented a motel room in Minnesota, and state law requires the hotelier to gather certain basic identifying information about the renter. The police came and inquired of the hotel. They ran defendant’s information and learned that he’d been convicted … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on MN law that requires identifying information on renters is third party information and voluntary disclosure doesn’t offend Patel

ABA Criminal Justice: Carpenter v. United States: Building a Property Based Fourth Amendment Approach to Digital Data

ABA: Carpenter v. United States: Building a Property Based Fourth Amendment Approach to Digital Data by Melody J. Brannon, 33 Criminal Justice No. 4 at 20 (Winter 2019):

Posted in Property rights, Reasonable expectation of privacy, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on ABA Criminal Justice: Carpenter v. United States: Building a Property Based Fourth Amendment Approach to Digital Data

The Champion: Building on Carpenter: Six New Fourth Amendment Challenges Every Defense Lawyer Should Consider

The Champion: Building on Carpenter: Six New Fourth Amendment Challenges Every Defense Lawyer Should Consider by Michael Price and Bill Wolf (NACDL, Dec. 2018) at 20-25: The implications of the Supreme Court’s decision in Carpenter v. United States are just … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, Third Party Doctrine, Tracking warrant | Comments Off on The Champion: Building on Carpenter: Six New Fourth Amendment Challenges Every Defense Lawyer Should Consider

New law review article: Fourth Amendment Reasonableness After Carpenter

This brief essay is great insight into arguing the next steps of Carpenter, reasonableness, property rights, and whether the reasonable expectation of privacy test will be changed. We recommend you read all you can about Carpenter because the right reasonableness … Continue reading →

Posted in Reasonable expectation of privacy, Reasonableness, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on New law review article: Fourth Amendment Reasonableness After Carpenter

WaPo: Motel 6 agrees to pay up to $7.6 million to settle claim it helped ICE target Latino guests

WaPo: Motel 6 agrees to pay up to $7.6 million to settle claim it helped ICE target Latino guests by Lindsey Bever: After a nationwide class-action lawsuit against Motel 6, the chain agreed to pay as much as $7.6 million … Continue reading →

Posted in Immigration arrests, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on WaPo: Motel 6 agrees to pay up to $7.6 million to settle claim it helped ICE target Latino guests

D.R.I.: IP addresses def used weren’t like detailed tracking information from CSLI requiring a SW

Defendant’s use of IP addresses his computer signed in through isn’t enough like CSLI in Carpenter to require a search warrant. United States v. Monroe, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 186998 (D. R.I. Nov. 1, 2018):

Posted in Computer and cloud searches, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on D.R.I.: IP addresses def used weren’t like detailed tracking information from CSLI requiring a SW

NY Times: Most White Americans’ DNA Can Be Identified Through Genealogy Databases

NY Times: Most White Americans’ DNA Can Be Identified Through Genealogy Databases by Heather Murphy: And, of course, it can be subpoenaed by the government.

Posted in DNA, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on NY Times: Most White Americans’ DNA Can Be Identified Through Genealogy Databases

CA5: IP information “falls comfortably within the scope of the third-party doctrine” after Carpenter; no comparison to CSLI

Whatever the status of the third-party doctrine after Carpenter, nothing would change as to subpoenaing IP address information in a child pornography case. “The information at issue here falls comfortably within the scope of the third-party doctrine.” United States v. … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA5: IP information “falls comfortably within the scope of the third-party doctrine” after Carpenter; no comparison to CSLI

WaPo: A serial rapist eluded police for years. Then they searched a genealogy site.

WaPo: A serial rapist eluded police for years. Then they searched a genealogy site. by Eli Rosenberg:

Posted in DNA, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on WaPo: A serial rapist eluded police for years. Then they searched a genealogy site.

N.D.Ala.: No REP in bank records under still settled law

“Petitioner argues that the IRS’s summonses to Bank of America and Regions Bank violate his Fourth Amendment rights. … The Eleventh Circuit recently considered and rejected a Fourth Amendment challenge to an IRS summons directed towards a bank because the … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell site location information, Good faith exception, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on N.D.Ala.: No REP in bank records under still settled law

Law360: Airbnb Suit Challenges New NYC Rental Data Collection Law

Law360: Airbnb Suit Challenges New NYC Rental Data Collection Law by Pete Brush Airbnb Inc. sued New York City on Friday claiming a new law requiring online rental companies to share data about their clientele violates the U.S. Constitution, but … Continue reading →

Posted in Surveillance technology, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Law360: Airbnb Suit Challenges New NYC Rental Data Collection Law

CA7: City’s use of “smart meter” is a search, but it is reasonable because it’s not for criminal purposes and law enforcement never knows

The use of a smart meter to collect energy consumption in homes is a search under the Fourth Amendment under Kyllo. It is, however, a reasonable search because it is purely for the use of the power company and city … Continue reading →

Posted in Search, Surveillance technology, Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on CA7: City’s use of “smart meter” is a search, but it is reasonable because it’s not for criminal purposes and law enforcement never knows

Washington Post: Subpoena for app called ‘Discord’ could unmask identities of Charlottesville white supremacists

Washington Post: Subpoena for app called ‘Discord’ could unmask identities of Charlottesville white supremacists By Meagan Flynn: Discord, which was started in 2015 as a secure chat app for videogamers, also happened to be conducive for white supremacists, white nationalists, … Continue reading →

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Washington Post: Subpoena for app called ‘Discord’ could unmask identities of Charlottesville white supremacists

Talk Business: SmartDrive focuses on fleet safety using video to improve risky driver behavior

Talk Business: SmartDrive focuses on fleet safety using video to improve risky driver behavior by Jeff Della Rosa:

Posted in Third Party Doctrine | Comments Off on Talk Business: SmartDrive focuses on fleet safety using video to improve risky driver behavior