Category Archives: Privileges

N.D.Cal.: Compelled use of fingerprint to open cell phone not testimonial

The court at first declined to sign a search warrant for a cell phone that compelled use of a fingerprint to unlock it. After further submissions from the USAO and the FPD as invited amicus, the court concludes that a … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Privileges, Warrant execution | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Compelled use of fingerprint to open cell phone not testimonial

FL5: Existence of SW for BAC record in hospital overcame supboena without notice in violation of statute

Defendant’s BAC level was obtain by subpoena without notice contrary to statute, but they were also obtained by search warrant so they would not be suppressed. The search warrant was particular enough. Dinkins v. State, 2019 Fla. App. LEXIS 12923 … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on FL5: Existence of SW for BAC record in hospital overcame supboena without notice in violation of statute

CNS: Final Warrant Targeting Journalist Deemed Illegal by Judge

Courthouse News Service: Final Warrant Targeting Journalist Deemed Illegal by Judge by Nicholas Iovino:

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on CNS: Final Warrant Targeting Journalist Deemed Illegal by Judge

D.Kan.: USAO in Kansas in contempt for handling litigation over recording attorney-client jail calls

Not a Fourth Amendment case at this point of the litigation, but extremely interesting to everybody in the criminal justice system, including jailers, is United States v. Carter, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 137728 (D. Kan. Aug. 13, 2019), where there … Continue reading →

Posted in Prison and jail searches, Privileges | Comments Off on D.Kan.: USAO in Kansas in contempt for handling litigation over recording attorney-client jail calls

S.D.N.Y.: Seizure of 21 privileged documents out of 1.3M wasn’t a 4A or privilege violation

The government seized 1.3M documents, and 21 apparently were privileged. This doesn’t show that the government was willful disregarding the warrant or the need to protect privileged materials. His iPhone and laptop were properly seized by plain view then subjected … Continue reading →

Posted in Overseizure, Privileges | Comments Off on S.D.N.Y.: Seizure of 21 privileged documents out of 1.3M wasn’t a 4A or privilege violation

Courthouse News Service: Journalist’s Phone Data Was Used to Justify Home, Office Raids

Courthouse News Service: Journalist’s Phone Data Was Used to Justify Home, Office Raids by Nicholas Iovino: Police used records of a journalist’s private communications with a confidential source, obtained by a now-quashed search warrant, to secure permission to raid the … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on Courthouse News Service: Journalist’s Phone Data Was Used to Justify Home, Office Raids

CA4: Def’s unlocking cell phone without sharing passcode was not communicative act

The officer who had defendant’s cell phone asked her to unlock it. She entered the passcode without sharing it or him seeing her do it. It wasn’t a communicative act. It’s like providing a key. Her motion to suppress the … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Overseizure, Privileges | Comments Off on CA4: Def’s unlocking cell phone without sharing passcode was not communicative act

WaPo:Analysis: The Trump administration wants to be able to break into your encrypted data. Here’s what you need to know.

WaPo:Analysis: The Trump administration wants to be able to break into your encrypted data. Here’s what you need to know. By Tim Maurer and Garrett Hinck: And so do governments around the world.

Posted in Privileges, Surveillance technology | Comments Off on WaPo:Analysis: The Trump administration wants to be able to break into your encrypted data. Here’s what you need to know.

D.Idaho: Def can be forced to use finger on Touch ID feature to open phone

The USMJ denied an order to compel the target to use the “Touch ID” feature of his cell phone to open it. On appeal to the USDJ, surveying the cases, the court orders the target to use his finger because … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Privileges | Comments Off on D.Idaho: Def can be forced to use finger on Touch ID feature to open phone

SF Chronicle: Jeff Adachi case: Judge quashes SFPD warrant used to search journalist’s phone

SF Chronicle: Jeff Adachi case: Judge quashes SFPD warrant used to search journalist’s phone by Megan Cassidy: A judge on Thursday quashed a search warrant used by San Francisco police to search a journalist’s phone in what was part of … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on SF Chronicle: Jeff Adachi case: Judge quashes SFPD warrant used to search journalist’s phone

NY3: Evidence seized from defense counsel was not privileged because of crime-fraud exception

Somehow, papers were seized [or obtained] from the county public defender in the case [without explanation, which is not uncommon in New York appellate cases], and defendant claimed attorney-client privilege. The court finds the crime-fraud exception applies, and what was … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on NY3: Evidence seized from defense counsel was not privileged because of crime-fraud exception

ATL: The Difference Between Bryan Carmody And Julian Assange

ATL: The Difference Between Bryan Carmody And Julian Assange by Tyler Broker:

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on ATL: The Difference Between Bryan Carmody And Julian Assange

N.D.Cal.: Govt bears burden of showing attachment limiting search was actually attached, and it failed

For the government to rely on the good faith exception by claiming the attachment limiting the warrant was attached to the search warrant, it bears the burden of showing that, and it didn’t. United States v. Chang, 2019 U.S. Dist. … Continue reading →

Posted in Franks doctrine, Privileges, Scope of search | Comments Off on N.D.Cal.: Govt bears burden of showing attachment limiting search was actually attached, and it failed

OH7: No REP in police interrogation room; conversation with wife after statement to police recorded

Defendant gave a statement to the police and then he was left alone in the interrogation room to talk to his wife for 40 minutes. Police recorded the conversation. There was no reasonable expectation of privacy in the room, and, … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges, Reasonable expectation of privacy | Comments Off on OH7: No REP in police interrogation room; conversation with wife after statement to police recorded

NJ: State’s references to refusal to consent violated 4A & 5A

NJ finally holds that the state’s repeated references to defendant refusing consent as consciousness of guilt violated his Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights. State v. Sui Kam Tung, 2019 N.J. Super. LEXIS 101 (June 28, 2019):

Posted in Consent, Privileges | Comments Off on NJ: State’s references to refusal to consent violated 4A & 5A

TheAppeal.org: ‘Do Not Record’

TheAppeal.org: ‘Do Not Record’ by Elizabeth Weill-Greenberg: Phone calls between prisoners in Orange County and their lawyers were recorded and accessed. How wide the eavesdropping was remains an open question. . . .

Posted in Prison and jail searches, Privileges | Comments Off on TheAppeal.org: ‘Do Not Record’

FL1: Recognizing conflict in many courts on compelled password production, court takes a middle ground: state must show what it wants with “reasonable particularity”

“To what extent does the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination protect a suspect in a criminal case from the compelled disclosure of a password to an electronic communications device in the state’s possession? Courts differ in their legal analysis of … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Privileges | Comments Off on FL1: Recognizing conflict in many courts on compelled password production, court takes a middle ground: state must show what it wants with “reasonable particularity”

NACDL Fourth Amendment Center: Compelled Decryption Primer

NACDL Fourth Amendment Center: Compelled Decryption Primer:

Posted in Cell phones, Privileges | Comments Off on NACDL Fourth Amendment Center: Compelled Decryption Primer

NBC: Give up your password or go to jail: Police push legal boundaries to get into cellphones

NBC: Give up your password or go to jail: Police push legal boundaries to get into cellphones by John Schuppe: “The world should know that what they’re doing out here is crazy,” said a man who refused to share his … Continue reading →

Posted in Cell phones, Privileges | Comments Off on NBC: Give up your password or go to jail: Police push legal boundaries to get into cellphones

NPR: Political Fallout Escalates After SF Police Raid Journalist’s Office

NPR: Political Fallout Escalates After SF Police Raid Journalist’s Office by Sonja Hutson: The San Francisco Police Officers’ Association is calling on the chief of police to resign for his handling of a raid on a reporter’s home. The reporter … Continue reading →

Posted in Privileges | Comments Off on NPR: Political Fallout Escalates After SF Police Raid Journalist’s Office