MI: Handcuffing uncooperative def at scene of accident wasn’t unreasonable

Defendant was handcuffed because he was uncooperative during basic questions about the accident he was walking away from, where the officer believed he was involved. On the totality, this was not unreasonable. The officer here was responding to an OnStar report of a car crash in a rural area. OnStar got no response from the car. As he neared the scene, he encountered defendant walking on the road, and the officer attempted to talk to him. Defendant didn’t want to answer. The officer ordered him to stop, and there was reasonable suspicion at this point: Defendant leaned when he walked, like he was intoxicated, and he was inappropriately dressed to be merely walking on a rural road in the dead of winter. People v. Evans, 2026 Mich. App. LEXIS 8873 (Oct. 20, 2026)*:

Burleson thus resorted to the more restrictive method of detention, handcuffing defendant and placing him in the patrol car, to effectuate the purpose of his investigative stop, which was to confirm or dispel his reasonable suspicion that defendant had been driving a vehicle while intoxicated. Clearly, Burleson could not have accomplished that purpose without resorting to more restrictive methods because defendant was not willing to cooperate with any level of detention. Thus, the increase in both the length of the stop, and the necessity of more restrictive methods for accomplishing it, are primarily attributable to defendant. Burleson’s conduct was not unreasonable under the circumstances. Royer, 460 US at 500.

This entry was posted in Arrest or entry on arrest. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.